Auto-SummaryThe post discusses the nature of religion, particularly Buddhism, and why some people have a negative view of it. The author argues that organized religion often presents a single, absolute method of human existence, which can be off-putting. They also highlight the importance of objectivity in belief systems and the tendency of many religious people to focus on differences rather than similarities. The post concludes by emphasizing that there is no single right way to worship or understand religion.
Yes, you could say that Democracy is the same thing, and some people /do/ say this. It is the self-percieved strong sheparding the percieved weak through the valley of temptation and judgement. As for trying to force my beliefs...I can't say that such isn't how I've come across. My beliefs are my beliefs, but the very forum that is inclusive for most of my discussions isn't so much about /swaying/ public opinion into your arena insomuch as it is a method for all people to express their opinions. Much like this forum here. I don't try to convert anyone, I don't believe that there is any single right way for all people to live, worship or exist. I simply express my beliefs and let the weight of what I say influence people...or not influence them. But religion doesn't think that way, especially organized religion. The preaching mentality is what puts most people off to religion (and that is the question I'm trying to answer, not spark more debate about the nature of the question), the mentality of there being that single method of human existance that is the absolute /best/ way a human can exist. And perhaps what is /more/ off-putting is when the assertions of the ideals are in direct opposition with evidence. I'm not condoning or advocating hate towards religion, I'm simply saying why it is that people /do hate/ religion. I honestly don't feel any of the hate myself, coming from a background in buddhism, but I know /why/ it is there and the source of it. I think that's the question here and that's whats important.
Now the periphial debate on if we can (or more importantly, should) consider 'Buddhism' to be inclusive into the category of 'religion'. Alan Watts mused that either Buddhism is the most psychological religion or the most religious psychology. I agree with his non-biased approach. I know a great many 'True Buddhist' who utilize buddhism the same way that most Christians utilize Christianity - and that is trying to secure and assure some tangible foothold in the after-life.
In fact, in India, it is not uncommon for practicing 'buddhists' (I include the quotes to further emphasize that even when you're in a religion, you have your own idea of what a true religious person in the context of your religion must behave like. That there can be true and un-true buddhists for example) to disregard a person in need, dismissing their plight as an act of their own 'bad karma' and thusly none of their responsibility. They focus upon themselves only and upon /their/ plight and thus foster ego rather than attempt to quell it (I am sure that they would probably view most western versions of 'Buddhists' with as much contempt as we do them. We are likely not 'true' in their eyes which simply shows that there is no 'true' version except perhaps the original).
When I talk to buddhists about the similarities of their religion with those of other religions, what I'm struck most by is the absolute refusal of these normally rational individuals to focus on similarities rather than differences - especially when the similarities are so central and the differences so periphial. The similarity that most strikes me as a recurring theme through all of these religions is the theme of 'Salvation'. We all probably understand salvation in the traditional judeo-christian sense, but Salvation also plays a large role in buddhism. Only here it is called 'Liberation'. Now I am fully aware that the actual goal of buddhism isn't merely the liberation of consciousness at death, but also the refuting of ego within this lifetime and the understanding of the nature of suffering that comes with it. But what I see in many buddhists isn't that same understanding, but rather, taking it on as just another method of salvation.
In all methods of these methods and teachings, mankind is born into sin (In buddhism, born into a hellish world of suffering) and because of this tragic mishap, must postrate himself to dieties (many buddhist worship Hindu dieties and many others worship representations of long deceased enlightened masters) through ritual so that he can be freed (Liberated) from this tarnished existance to rise to some ultimate after-life point of bliss and eternal happiness (Nirvana). Again, I realize that to everyone who has ever put any effort into studying buddhism and its practices, this is a rather glib interpretation, but I know that you understand exactly what I mean. People take only what they want from religion. They're not wrong in doing so. As I have said and continue to say, there isn't any right way to worship. They're just doing what they believe they must as humans.
Again, to refocus on the question, the reason that most people 'hate' religion is because all religions advocate themselves as the 'true' path. That there is one 'righteous' path and all others are just delusion, temptation, illusion or deception. I guess to distill /that/, people resent religions and their followers because they do not seem to have any sense of objectivity concerning their beliefs (they can't take a step back and acknowledge the similarities between what they're saying and what others say, rather, continually point back to the differences).
There's no one right way to do anything. Find what works best for you, just don't expect it to work for anyone else. In the strange attractor of life, people can come close to repeating the same pattern, but never completely replicate it.
Ish
|