Auto-SummaryThis forum post clarifies key aspects of copyright law, particularly regarding the creation and protection of works. The author emphasizes that copyright is automatically secured upon creation of a work, and registration with the U.S. Copyright Office is required only for legal proceedings. They argue that website hosts are liable for hosting copyrighted material without permission, leading to removal of such content upon notification. The post also discusses the concept of "fair use" for transformative works, such as parody, and provides examples. Lastly, it asserts that photos on websites are considered works under copyright law, serving as evidence of ownership. Overall, the summary highlights the broad scope of copyright protection and practical implications for online content creators and hosts.
nushroom.while i dont doubt what you do in the least, you are mistaken if you dont think the very brief post i made is correct. i would point you 1st to title 17 of the us code - copyrights. further, 3d has already listed the link i would point you to as well; its the federal copyright office website he's quoting from (if no one bothered to look at the link) that says copyright is created upon creation of the work (as well as the code itself). so that question is over. also, keep in mind that what encompasses a "work" is to be construed very broadly in my following ramblings...
as far as your post to ryche- you are correct as to the court part. you wanna take someone to court and get damages, attys fees, and statutory fines for infringing your copyright? first the work must be registered (generally) with the copyright office before you may file a motion in court. this process will likely be used as a finding of fact within a trial- as the copyright office will determine the true ownership of the copyright- what would mainly be left to the ct would be to determine damages. but- to have a work (which has been copyrighted) removed from online publications, - you dont have to go to court for that. why? theres caselaw which says that ancillary providers of works used without permission that are copyrighted (specifically, a webhost which allows copyrighted material to be posted to their site by one of their users) are liable as well as the original violator to the copyright holder for copyright infringement, once they have been notified as such. so website providers once notified will remove the user/materials/etc because they dont want to be liable to the copyright holder. ook in any webhost terms of service youll find its a TOS violation to take copyrighted works, and this becomes the end of their account. it is not a legal route in the primary sense of the word, but the threat of legal force (in a secondary manner) will make servers remove the images and perhaps the user, as private actors (the courts/law dont have to get involved here). i believe the case was netcom v (? some christian group. i cant remember off the top of my head, but im sure you can read it at findlaw.com). again, the issue is that copyright is secured at the moment of creation- but if you want nice things like the law to back you up, you have to register it. this is not to say it must be registered before the offense for it to be valid (and not a bar to court), but you have to register it before you go to court.
as far as "digimarc"- im not familiar but i can infer that this is some sort of photo software, about uploading things to the web. (?) in any case, uploading it and making the pics public on the web, as well as the requisite copyright tags, is "proof" (facts) which will be a part of the case (if it went to court). the publication of works is a factor in establishing the copyright, but is not required (is not a bar to having the case held up in court).
as far as "real life" - copyright protections are "real life". your scenarios about stealing songs are pretty far from "real life". musicians often employ copyright schemes to protect their works. something that may garner cash in the future will often be registered at the copyright office. but there are other methods to determine the true owner of the copyright- "poor man's copyrights" are used quite often in the music industry. (where a musician mails a copy of his song thru the postoffice, to himself, and the letter remains sealed.) this is used as "proof"- facts which can be admitted into evidence- as to the real owner of the rights.) but again, copyright is created once the work is created, and runs with the owner til 70 years after his.her death! now, ownership of songs is pretty different than illustrative pics on a website- because whereas a pic lifted from a site may cause damage to the original business' copyright holder (thru lost sales, etc.), a song in and of itself is the primary source of cash (where a pic lifted wholesale is not). theyre not treated differently in copyright law, but one creator has far more impetus to register a song or establish ownership than another, because the gap between profits is huge. (thats why the analogy to songs and original works that may lead to $ may be leading you astray).
as far as "new creations", and vanilla ice. generally, a "transformative" work is within the boundaries of "fair use"- fair use is when someone can use a copyrighted work. the work, once changed into something wholesale and different is then in the realm of "fair use", and copyright protections are no longer implicated. if i took a recording of "i touch myself", took the name off the album and put my own- without changing anything- then the copyright protections would kick in. if i tranformed a 50's bubblegum pop song into a rap parody, then it falls within fair use. the case i am referring to was roy orbison's... damn, i dont remember the name of the song. but again, go to findlaw and search roy orbison, you can read about fair use and transforamtive works there.
as far as a pic published to the net- it seems your argument centers around the definition of "works", and you say website photos are not included. well, yes they are. the title's definition of "work" is meant to encompass tangible forms of expression. and they are also supposed to be read VERY broadly, in favor of the owner who claims it is a work. a photo is- digitized to a website or not- a work. websites are forms of expression, in a tangible form, which can be recognized not only as a work of the creator but also serves as proof in and of itself of whom the "work" (whether it be pics, words, etc on a website) belongs to. thats why theyre included.
***Please Donate Blood. American Red Cross***
-------------------- ? oscill8 2001, 2002
"Any data submitted to Shroomery.org becomes our property"
|