Auto-SummaryThe author shares their personal experience with LED lighting for growing ornamental cacti and small plants in a small grow room. They believe LED is not suitable for large areas or tall plants, and may not be the best choice for everyone. They mention that their living room plants thrive under HPS/MH bulbs, and they only use LED for small plants or small grow rooms. The author criticizes the idea that everyone should switch to LED, and believes that the suitability of LED lighting depends on the specific cultivation needs. They also discuss the uniqueness of different plants and the potential benefits of LED for commercial growers in terms of reduced electricity costs.
Well I don't said it's fact but I said I feel more and more as the time goes by anne trying to lobby people to buy LED from certain companies.
I don't claim this to be fact, just said I feel like it..
Only I know for fact LED is not perfect light for ornament cactus, it's only suitable for small grow room because these light doesn't generate so much of heat. It's not suitable for large area of plants nor tall columars.
I could think only LED for ornamental cacti if I have thousands of € to spend for them, add them to walls around grow room and to the ceiling but there is more effective light tech what will penetrate way more better small foliage and gives effective light meters away from actual bulbs.
However, IF annie purpose is to do grow room as small as possible, then LED is best.. But thinking of using them to light big area of different plants indoors, I don't buy it.
Maybe later when LED tek are improved enough and they're cheaper.
Anne tek are only suitable for certain type of cultivation, it's proven already, but I bet it's not suitable for most of grow rooms/greenhouses whatever people have.
One friend of mine use HPS and grow cannabis, he keep cacti over the winter around cannabis plants in his growing tent. IF I go and say "throw your 600W HPS away and buy hundred of € worth of LED.. He probably just think I'm stupid. Well that is totally different environment also and he use HPS only over winter when sun are shining from very low at horizon.. Most of the time he keep cacti at balcony outdoors, enjoying sun.
There are lots of growers and lots of different grow rooms. Some grow only columnars, some cobulars, some grow cacti for consumption, some grow for ornamental.
It's wrong information to say everyone need to get LED and nothing more.. Some people doesn't use lights at all. Only windowsill sun at winter time and greenhouse over summer.
Anne should say the fact LED is only good for small grow rooms and small plants, they are not for everyone.. I could think if some noob demolish the greenhouse, buy shitloads of LED and then starts to think what is wrong when columars starts to grow slim and only tallest plants are not elongating so bad.
LED are not best choice for all, only for people who want to grow small plants in small grow room.
My "grow room" are living room.. HPS+MH bulbs are above south window, Every plant no matter where they are in the 5x5meter room, they are doing fine and love the light.. Only 150€ investment to have 5x5meter area enough light so every corner of living room where are plants are enjoying.
I have cucumber plant spent winter in living room, meters away from my light source, it blooms and doing fine but since it's winter I need to take flowers away and keep it with very low water and wait it's warm enough I can move the to greenhouse. Also chili plants are love to spent "dormant" in my living room corner, meters away from light source.
I should obtain too much LED lights to make sure I have enough light to 5x5meter living room and therefor make sure every chili and every cucumber and other ornamental plants are satisfied with the light I offer them.
Ofc when summer comes and soon sun shines above horizon, I can slowly start shut down my lights and move most plants to greenhouse and then I don't consume any electricity, in fact my electric bill are smaller than plants under LED because I don't need electricity for nothing at summer time.
Anne seems to purposely confuse few basic things, word dirt sounds disgusting and bad, dirt are not even same than living soil organism. I am not against hydro cultivation I have done it myself with another species of plants. However, plants have been in soil millions of years, if it's bad for plants, how the hell they have survived in the nature anyway?
This tek should be sold to people who do grafts in small room and small plants without caring the appearance of plants, only what matter is production of mass.
One thing more, what really make one strain unique and another not? IMO every peyote grown from seed are different than another seed grown plants. IF this "unique" are only matter of what anne think of plant.. From my perspective, I have seed grown plants, everyone is unique on it's own way.. I know no one have same clone of peyote I have and that makes them unique. OR what is the definition of "unique peyote"? Do anne only have access to declare one from 20k seed grown plants to unique and rest growers doesn't have permission to see their own seed grown plants as unique?
Every peyote are unique on their own way.. I just want to know the real factor what makes anne clones unique and another people clones "common ugly dirt shit peyote what is not grow under LED"?
I see things differently.. If I sow 20k seeds, every seedling are unique because they are not clones, they are from different seed. Ofc there can be very different plant along these all what can be defined as unique on it's chemical properties or appearance but real, the real unique definition are very poor in my mind.
If unique means it's strain what anne have, then unique definition is "peyote from anne"
Everything seems to black and white from anne perpective what I have read the posts.. What define unique? What define best? What define noob?
Are that "noob" the person who dare ask advice from another growers? and "pro" are person who doesn't "need" to ask any kind of advice form anyone...
Maybe some people just want to conversation and same time change their experiences about growing cacti, asking something what should and what should not do does't make anyone noob?
And yet, every "noob" I find out are these who say "hello, I don't know this, I ask from you" ..There is nothing bad to advice people, if information is right.. anne can advice people but only those who ask about LED and peyote grafting to pereskiopsis.. no doubt.
I don't see "noob" is the person who ask about cacti and still have experience of growing cacti and ask things in the meaning to want to chance ideas with another and start a dialog.
And what comes to LED. I have cut off my house lighting from 500W to 40W by using LED to light house, bathroom, kitchen, hall, living room, etc.. Some cheap "white LED" light.. IT's good for that purpose, but IF LED are developed enough, I would say ALL commercial growers would have change their lighting to LED to reduce electric bill because electric consuming eat's profit of business if someone use grow lights.. One good example is commercial cannabis growers who sell their cannabis to legal markets, why they have not change to LED because of cheaper electric bill? maybe because what you save from electric bill, you loose from harvest. But I don't want to mix cannabis anymore to this..
Just saying, why they still use Heat generating electric consuming HPS and not LED? IF LED really are the best, every expert would have done this and cut their electric costs in business but they have not done this.. Isn't what obvious?
Edited by intelligentlife (01/08/14 10:54 AM)
|