Home | Community | Message Board


This site includes paid links. Please support our sponsors.


Welcome to the Shroomery Message Board! You are experiencing a small sample of what the site has to offer. Please login or register to post messages and view our exclusive members-only content. You'll gain access to additional forums, file attachments, board customizations, encrypted private messages, and much more!

Shop: Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order   MagicBag.co All-In-One Bags That Don't Suck, Certified Organic All-In-One Grow Bags   Mushroom-Hut Grow Bags

Jump to first unread post Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |  [ show all ]
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: redgreenvines]
    #29729318 -

No, that was general, not to LoadedShaman in particular.

The challenge was to anyone who is defending materialism as a complete story: show me how to derive I am this one from physical facts alone, without using I, here, now, or any other indexical to do the work.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy] * 1
    #29729331 -

cubedryeguy said:
I am not going to defend Loaded Shaman's version of this, because I think it goes too far.

I do not agree there is no past, or that reality is created by YOU, or that saying we only know things NOW means the past did not happen. Rahz is right that confusing when you become aware of a fact with when the fact occurred is confusing epistemology with ontology.
I am defending a much narrower claim, and I think it is the strongest part of what he is trying to get at.

Suppose you had a complete third person description of the universe. Every atom, every brain state, every person, past present future, all in one book. You read it cover to cover. You would still not know one thing: which person in the book you are.

You would know that person #4,382,019 is sitting in a chair reading this post. You would know his memories, his history, his brain state. You would not know that you are that person, experiencing from inside that skull, rather than experiencing from someone else's.

I grant the past happened. I grant I was in the womb. I grant the baby photo is of a real past baby. That does not close the gap, because the book can include all of that and still leave out which center you are.

I am not claiming this is a ghost or an extra ingredient added to the universe. I am not claiming a new particle. I am claiming perspective itself is the thing to be explained, not just indexed. I am claiming it is a real kind of knowledge, self locating knowledge, that cannot be captured in purely third person language. Words like I, here, and now are not optional decoration. They are how that knowledge is expressed, and you cannot paraphrase them away without losing the knowledge itself.

I agree changing biology changes awareness. Anesthesia, brain damage, psychedelics, all of that is real. That shows dependence, not identity. Dependence is not the same as being purely biological. Memory does locate me, and I am not pretending memory is a list in a book. Memory is lived as mine. My question is not whether biology is tied to a center. It clearly is. My question is why there is a center at all when that biology is happening, why there is something it is like to be the process, rather than the process just happening with no one home.

Two replies I expect, so let me answer them in advance.

First, that is just language, not metaphysics. If language tracks real knowledge, and there is real knowledge that third person language cannot express, then a purely third person description is incomplete. It does not matter if you call the gap linguistic or metaphysical. The gap is real, and materialism promised a complete description.

Second, duplication solves it, each copy will think it is the one. That does not solve it, it multiplies it. The book can tell you Copy A is in Philly and Copy B is in Pittsburgh. It can distinguish them perfectly as that one and this one. What it cannot tell you, without you already knowing which perspective you occupy, is whether you are the Philly one or the Pittsburgh one. You cannot get from there are two brains in two places to this is the one I am without smuggling in an I to do the picking.

Loaded Shaman's best point, cleaned up, is the emergence point: you cannot get an I from a description that contains only NOT I, unless you smuggle the I in at the start. I am not claiming that proves emergence is impossible in general. I am claiming it is a specific, unsolved problem for this case.

So here is the challenge: show me how to derive I am this one from physical facts alone, without using I, here, now, or any other indexical to do the work. If you cannot, then there is at least one real kind of knowledge that is not third person physical knowledge, and materialism as a complete story is still incomplete on its own terms.



You're good I appreciate your reply; the other dude was bad faith 101.

I'll respond to this one when I get back in.


--------------------
:leaf:
"Real knowledge is to know the extent of one’s ignorance." — Confucius

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy]
    #29729332 -

Hypothetically speaking: What if I could walk up to you from behind and then pat you on the shoulder and say hello before walking past you and away onwards while waving back at thee the whole tme.  All without saying any of the no-no words you listed.  Ya? :cool:

As with respect to cognition, self-recognition, identification, and so on - that'll do.
Just a tacit sort of agreement would do - if we could. (which, ya, we can)
Or did i misunderstand where you where coming from and pat someone or something else on the 'shoulder'?


--------------------
Give me Liberty caps or give me Death caps.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: The Blind Ass] * 1
    #29729343 -

That is the word game version, not the challenge.

The challenge was not can you interact without saying I. It was can you derive which one you are from physical facts alone, without already assuming it.

Your pat assumes it. You still have to pick out this body to pat it, even if you do it silently. Dropping the words does not drop the picking out. Tacit agreement assumes it too, we both already know who we are before we agree.

You showed two bodies can interact. You did not show how either body knows which one it is from physical facts alone.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy]
    #29729356 -

An intriguing thought experiment indeed. I must admit that I will refrain from participating in that game. I am content with my awareness of myself consciously, without the need for name games or no name games. The shared world continues to exist regardless of these matters, even, at times, in part, due to them—although I cannot extract words from my experiences.

It is important to remember the details that pass through all my senses in the moment-to-moment flow of life universally. As for the concept of “who I am”—with respect to the unique environment, body, and mind that constitutes the organism—that is “me” (so to speak)—I am truly blind to it.

I simply follow along causally as she goes. By “causally,” I do not mean it only in the textbook sense, but rather in the living of it and the omnipresence of it. The University…the shared-in Cosmos...She is quite the captivating omnimultindividual - if I may say so for myself.  That's good enough for me.  Nondual awareness possesses a node of sorts ( in a manner of speaking ) one which has had to have  much evolve first and much develiop along the way- that I may specifically designate that  for the human being of which is reflected by the notion of 'thyself' or even a touch of the wind on my skin - and it is known to be automatically recognized by this individual, at least.


Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy] * 1
    #29729365 -

Asking how to derive “I am this one” from a third-person book seems like a trick question. The thought experiment, where you read the book of the universe cover to cover and still don’t know which person you are, conjures a disembodied mind hovering outside the universe, shopping for a body to belong to.

But "I" isn’t a mysterious label. It can simply be the method a brain uses to distinguish its own embodiment from other bodies and from the wider environment. Like "here" or "now," it's indexing, and a complete description of the world wouldn't contain it for the same reason a complete list of times wouldn't contain "now." Self is also not as persistent as language might suggest, so it’s no surprise that a question built on a fixed, prior I can be problematic.

More importantly, which body one is and why there is anyone home at all are two different questions. The first is about identity, the second is the hard problem of consciousness. Consciousness can remain a mystery without the identity question counting against materialism.

I’m not wholly a materialist myself despite what others may think, but I don’t see the point in forcing my subjectivity into a rational debate as a premise. I can take it seriously as something a complete account would eventually have to address, without pretending to know how.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: The Blind Ass]
    #29729375 -

You'll know who you are when you don't pay your bills. 
That, or when you search so hard your head explodes and lands in front of a mirror before consciousness fades as the blood drains from you.

It really needn't be so complicated.  Not anymore than it need be.


--------------------
Give me Liberty caps or give me Death caps.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: The Blind Ass] * 1
    #29729393 -

the question regarding the idea of me-myself and of you-yourself, and all the other you-yourselves, involves qualia, in the sense of how it feels to be myself, and for you, afaik it is how you must feel to be yourself.
otherwise it is all about competing on intellect and word games, for these are linguistic tools we learn at an early age in socializing, the feelings and presence are what it is about.

on the other, and possibly main thread idea, I am not even sure it is an idea, since any aspect of it that I have questioned has not warranted a reply from OP.

"the other dude was bad faith 101;" must be me, being referred to as materialist. I see spiritual matters as ideas that we recognize as being meritorious and or beautiful and uplifting. With that perspective I am definitely more spiritual than materialist.

As a materially observant naturalist, whom some people disdainfully regard as materialist (a term I thought applied to greedy criminals), I understand the value and limits of memory and perception in terms of neurons. This offends many people. That seems a bit strange to me.

I must appear to be such a materialist that I am totally beneath contempt, such that Loaded Shaman answers none of my questions.


--------------------
:brainfart: _ :finger:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Rahz]
    #29729397 -

I am not positing a disembodied mind shopping for a body. I am already in a body, reading the book. The point is not that a soul exists outside. The point is that even with the whole book, I still would not know which entry is me. That is not a soul, that is self locating knowledge.

Calling it indexing does not explain it, it names it. I agree it is indexing. My question is why there is anything that needs indexing at all. A complete list of times does not contain now, and that is exactly the problem. A complete account of time still has to explain why each observer has a now. Same here. A complete account of the world still has to explain why each brain has an I.

I agree self is not as persistent as language suggests. That does not dissolve it. Even if the self changes, at any moment I still know I am this one now.

And I do not think identity and the hard problem are two separate questions. Which body I am is just the hard problem made concrete. Why is there anyone home at all, in this body, right now? If you split them, you make the identity question disappear by definition, you do not solve it.

You said you can take this seriously as something a complete account would eventually have to address. That is all I am asking for. I am not asking you to solve it now, and I am not forcing subjectivity in as a premise. I am saying subjectivity is data a complete account has to address. If we agree on that, we agree more than we disagree.

So here is the follow up: can you show how indexing arises from non-indexical facts, without just saying the brain does it? If indexing is just a method, what is the method made of, and why does using it feel like something?

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: The Blind Ass]
    #29729400 -

This reminds me, Cubedguy, reminds me of some experiences of the 'obe' variety. Also this is not the first instance of such an experience, and in fact, there have been numerous instances, albeit at different times.  Guess what though?

Of these experiences, which now serve as vivid memories within me, they are integral parts of my identity. One particular experience, which I will refer to as an OBE (an admittedly misleading term), involved three individuals lying essentially unconscious on the floor with me. I managed to gain access to the right one, which was fortunate. Honestly, how could it be otherwise? What led the way? Remembrance, Presence, Location, Conditioning + Luck & inevitability .

Interestingly, this experience ultimately revealed the true order of operations for the world. It demonstrated that there is a constructed sense to the genuine sense of an omnipresence that I would describe as the Cosmos. This omnipresence encompasses all things and their relationships, particularly the sequence of events that occur amidst the cosmic intermix. It’s not a race to figure out the difference between the two that are always connected, from the moment we’re born to the end of our lives. If we’re lucky, we get to seemlessly move on to the beyond, which, insofar as I can tell, is where we all always already are, at present. So, anyways our lives ‘take place amongst that suchness. Seems so anyhow, right? Pretty cool, right?! :laugh:

Also, as a state of mind - an attitude - I think this goes 'without saying' (at least, for myself) ≈ Before Zazen, during Zazen, after Zazen -Continuous Awareness' Present (sans unconsciousness).  In which there is no need to understand anything, frankly.  And I still do what I must regardless.  So yeah, word games or not, its so much simpler than both you and I are making it out to be friendo.


--------------------
Give me Liberty caps or give me Death caps.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy]
    #29729407 -

Identity relates to the hard problem of consciousness just as everything does, but making plans for Sunday doesn't require solving consciousness to be meaningful or intelligible.

But your reply suggests that your challenge is for someone to solve the hard problem of consciousness. If that is your ultimate gist... I don't know.

If you are already in a body reading the book, you are already physically situated at a specific index. The only reason you could read the book and wonder "which entry is me?" is because the thought experiment artificially severs your sensory and causal link to the body.

People often conduct similar experiments. It's an interesting experiment but I don't suggest conducting it full time.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy]
    #29729415 -

cubedryeguy said:
... Even if the self changes, at any moment I still know I am this one now.
...



Active mental contents change continuously, at a regular rhythm.
Even if we wish to lock our attention on something solid (physically or mentally), our "awareness" will shift onto something that is changing while what is not changing (including what we are trying to lock attention on) will be suppressed from awareness.

so the question I ask you is what do you mean by "know"

do you mean A?. that you have considered you are this self before and have let the matter rest and are confident to state "I am this one now" because it is consistent with how you have been handling it before.
or B?. that you you just thought it and it is still ringing in your present feeling that "I am this one now".
or C?. that it has become your practice, like a mantra, to sustain the repetition of "I am this one now". even if it once meant something specific, now it means almost everything.

is it possible, that what you honestly mean by self, is the awareness?


--------------------
:brainfart: _ :finger:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: The Blind Ass]
    #29729425 -

Yeah, that last part landed for me.

It made me think of Watts and that story about God being asked how he created the universe, and God just saying, I just did it. Not because there was a big reason behind it, just for fun, just so. We are the ones who complicate it after with extra explanations.

Your OBE story is actually my point in lived form. You said you managed to gain access to the right one, and what led the way was Remembrance, Presence, Location. That is self locating knowledge, lived, not in a book. How did you know it was the right one? That is the whole question.

And I agree on the Zazen part. Before Zazen, during Zazen, after Zazen, Continuous Awareness Present. If that is true, then this thread is also Zazen. The word games, the challenge to Rahz, the back and forth, that is not outside the suchness, that is also suchness happening. We do not have to stop playing the game to notice it is simple. The game is part of the simplicity.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: redgreenvines]
    #29729442 -

"I" generally assumes a lot. There is utility in it, but when we try define it outside the simple index it becomes subject to change which we must react to with a changing definition, or taking pains to be comprehensive and perhaps never fitting it all in.

I've brought up polarity in contrast to duality various times. To me, the strict materialist and the strict spiritualist are playing the same game. To say that the spiritual is real and objectivity is an illusion is similar to saying objectivity is real so spirituality is an illusion.

I try not to entertain that kind of dualism when I engage in philosophy.

And when I want to keep it simple, I am. I am here. Here is where I am. There is no further validation required or further specifics necessary. Whether it's pleasant or not, it's whole. The need for more words seems like the squirming worm you sometimes describe.

Worms don't stand up in defiance of reality, nor do they tap dance or stick their finger up their nose because it's humorous.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Rahz]
    #29729452 -

Fair, let me clarify, because it is not to solve the hard problem on the spot.

I agree making plans for Sunday does not require solving consciousness. Practical talk works fine without a complete theory. My point was never that we cannot talk about identity until we solve it. My point was that if materialism claims to be the complete story, it has to address this knowledge, not define it away as outside the story.

And yes, the book experiment severs the sensory link on purpose. That is not a flaw, that is the diagnostic. If you put the link back, you have not explained it, you have just used it. You can describe situatedness third person, body at coordinates, eyes receiving photons. That description still does not tell you that you are the one at those coordinates without adding I am that one.

You just said it yourself to redgreenvines: I am here, no further validation required. That is exactly the direct knowing I meant. I am not defending strict spiritualism, and I am not positing a dualism. I am saying that direct knowing is data any account, materialist or not, has to address.

So the question stays: can you explain how the first person knowing of situatedness arises from non-indexical facts, without just pointing to it and saying, there it is?

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: redgreenvines]
    #29729459 -

Good question. Of the three, it is B, closest, but I need to split B in two.

B is closest on timing, it is present and fresh, but not on kind. It is not a thought about myself that is still ringing. It is acquaintance with myself. Not A, I am not resting on a belief I settled before. Not C, it is not a mantra I repeat until it means everything.

It is direct, like knowing you are in pain. You do not infer it from consistency, you feel it present. Mental contents change, I agree, awareness shifts, I agree. But there is still an experience of mineness at any moment, without inferring it.

Rahz just put it the same way to you: I am here, no further validation required. That is what I mean.

And yes, it is possible what I mean by self is the awareness. If self is awareness, then the question just becomes: how does this awareness arise, here, now, dependently, rather than just happening with no one home? That does not dissolve it, it restates it.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy]
    #29729496 -

Well, I would say that direct knowing isn't necessarily data that has to be addressed further. If someone wants to tickle their mind with it they can, but like I said, I don't recommend living in that state, as you seem to agree to some extent.

Materialism addresses material concerns. Yes, we can speak about the eye being connected to the brain, and some interesting science might come out of that (useful), but it doesn't speak to the hard question. What does?

It's not that I have it all figured out. It's that I got tired of trying for some mythical unity that can be handled like an object or idea that can be empirically tested. I can enjoy being perplexed occasionally, but I don't need a material understanding of why and how I am here. I enjoy being stupid like that.

As far as my non-dualism goes, the more polar realization is that subjectivity isn't intended to answer for objectivity, just as objectivity isn't intended to answer for subjectivity. The dualist will disagree of course, but I find plenty of room to speak to materialism without invoking the subjective, and my subjective experience isn't something I care to dissect with materialistic questions. In principle, they are not separate, but the "more unifying answer" to that is not something I care to push into my 60s and 70s like a boy thirsty for knowledge. How much unity do we need? That's mostly a rhetorical question and I don't begrudge anyone for their own probing or answers out to the point it becomes a matter of liberty. I got my eyes out!

What would be so great about extinguishing the mystery anyway? (not a rhetorical question)

Subjectivity makes objectivity meaningful. Objectivity makes subjectivity meaningful. That is the nature of polarity, two as one, in a dance, not the same but probably not fundamentally different. This is in consideration of the side of philosophy that does not rely on objectivity alone. Such a view is not inherently less philosophical imo. I do not consider myself a strict materialist for these reasons, but I doubt anyone here thinks of me as a spiritualist. It is not my concern.

To try and put it into words, if everything can be explained objectively, and it's seen to extinguish subjectivity, I suppose it's a wrong explanation as a matter of temperament.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Rahz]
    #29729511 -

I agree in a lot of ways. Where I split is that my temperament points the other way right now. I am comfortable not knowing, but I am not done playing with myself yet. For me, the probing is part of the game. I do not want to solve the mystery away, I just want to keep playing with it a while longer, even if it never turns into something I can measure. So I get settling into that stance for the long haul, I am just not there yet. And maybe I am never there. Can that be zazen?

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy]
    #29729527 -

Yes, I think so. If you're just poking I don't see why it wouldn't be zen.

But if you were an old man, you wouldn't have to ask. :oldman:


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy] * 1
    #29729562 -

in reply to
Quote:
do you mean A?. that you have considered you are this self before and have let the matter rest and are confident to state "I am this one now" because it is consistent with how you have been handling it before.
or B?. that you you just thought it and it is still ringing in your present feeling that "I am this one now".
or C?. that it has become your practice, like a mantra, to sustain the repetition of "I am this one now". even if it once meant something specific, now it means almost everything.




cubedryeguy said:
Good question. Of the three, it is B, closest, but I need to split B in two.

B is closest on timing, it is present and fresh, but not on kind. It is not a thought about myself that is still ringing. It is acquaintance with myself. Not A, I am not resting on a belief I settled before. Not C, it is not a mantra I repeat until it means everything....



B suggests that you are working with the issue/idea, and specifically it is part of short term memory. i.e. within the last 5 minutes the attitude or feeling of mineness was among your mental contents. Please understand that if you feel something anywhere in your body, emotion, or even imagination, then that for the moment it is happening, that feeling or sensation or idea is part of your active mental contents - which is your awareness which flows into memory (acquaintance is another word for familiarity which is basically perceptive reflex in which resting memory patterns become reactivated).
So since it was recently active, it easily bounces into awareness at the slightest trigger.[short term memory has been characterized by testing accessibility of memory patterns - recently learned patterns are more accessible than those of more than 5 minutes ago etc.]

If that is the case, then in some other context, when the matter has not recently been discussed; i.e. you have been working on something unrelated, then it is likely that the concept/feeling will not be among your active mental contents, or your recently active mental contents.

when it is not recent, it does not emerge from memory so readily, unless it is part of a routine or elicited by awareness of change in the context.

Quote:
cubedryeguy said:It is direct, like knowing you are in pain. You do not infer it from consistency, you feel it present. Mental contents change, I agree, awareness shifts, I agree. But there is still an experience of mineness at any moment, without inferring it.

Rahz just put it the same way to you: I am here, no further validation required. That is what I mean...



I do not think I said no further validation was required, I said what I think is happening after interpreting what you said. There is still an active question, and you agree that the question of self highlights "awareness", and I am very interested in that conversation. i.e. what is awareness? the sense of presence? what is thought?


Quote:
cubedryeguy said:And yes, it is possible what I mean by self is the awareness. If self is awareness, then the question just becomes: how does this awareness arise, here, now, dependently, rather than just happening with no one home? That does not dissolve it, it restates it.



Awareness arises in two clearly if broadly defined states of mind, 1. waking consciousness, and 2. dreaming (both asleep or daydreaming), however, in dreamless sleep there is no awareness.

In those two  broadly defined states of mind the dominant brainwave is Theta approx 6 peaks per second. Other waves are also happening, the high speed ones are involved in static activation pattern suppression (20 cycles per second up to 200 cycles per second)
but Theta is produced during associative memory formation and perceptive reflexes.

So we can correlate the presence or absence of awareness with the theta wave. Not all active mental contents are in synch at 6hz, but if they have been active in the last 1/6th of a second then they will be interconnected into memory engrams.

We could say that awareness is our mind making memory & awareness includes familiarity (which is the reactivated associated feelings, ideas, routines...) with what we are aware of.
this means that active mental content not only creates memory but also at the same time creates the familiarity reaction which contributes to the active mental content 1/6th of a second later.

both awareness and familiarity occur at this continuing 6hz rate while awake or dreaming

when I refer to active mental content I reference sensation as well as those associative engram patterns of cortical neurons that are excited during feelings or ideas or movements etc. etc. just a moment before;

- memory is otherwise simplified as Neurons that fire together wire together.

anyway, I do not consider "mine-ness" an essential attribute to awareness, although it can become a distracting lens or intellectual game. One mind one body is pretty much the rule, and to that extent Rahz need not question the mine-ness as such other than yes there is a mine-ness to every dimension of freedom around you including how your body moves, what you can say or do and with whom... and this may not be other than familiarity.


--------------------
:brainfart: _ :finger:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Jump to top Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |  [ show all ]

Shop: Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order   MagicBag.co All-In-One Bags That Don't Suck, Certified Organic All-In-One Grow Bags   Mushroom-Hut Grow Bags


Similar ThreadsPosterViewsRepliesLast post
* Describe a version of reality. (Creativity encouraged.)
( 1 2 3 all )
PowerTrip 2,561 57 07/20/06 02:55 AM
by MushmanTheManic
* Birth and Death: Paradoxical Bookends of the Absolute Self Loaded Shaman 36 6 11/16/26 04:18 PM
by The Blind Ass
* your mind COULD be creating reality
( 1 2 3 all )
Moonshoe 7,512 47 07/17/04 05:04 AM
by Source
* imagination is reality
( 1 2 3 all )
DoctorJ 3,462 56 05/22/06 04:02 PM
by redgreenvines
* Reality is your best friend
( 1 2 all )
SkorpivoMusterion 5,827 35 10/06/10 04:47 PM
by trentinxd
* Reality: Our objective, benelovent friend SkorpivoMusterion 1,349 10 11/19/05 05:04 PM
by Ped
* can you prove the existence of absolute, objective morality?
( 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 all )
Anonymous 23,335 157 12/21/04 08:31 AM
by deafpanda
* Reality isn't real
( 1 2 3 all )
ShroomismM 5,269 43 09/24/06 05:01 PM
by Telepylus

Extra information
You cannot start new topics / You cannot reply to topics
HTML is disabled / BBCode is enabled
Moderator: Middleman, DividedQuantum
245 topic views. 1 members, 74 guests and 29 web crawlers are browsing this forum.
[ Show Images Only | Sort by Score | Print Topic ]
Search this thread:

Copyright 1997-2026 Mind Media. Some rights reserved.

Generated in 0.03 seconds spending 0.005 seconds on 16 queries.