Home | Community | Message Board


This site includes paid links. Please support our sponsors.


Welcome to the Shroomery Message Board! You are experiencing a small sample of what the site has to offer. Please login or register to post messages and view our exclusive members-only content. You'll gain access to additional forums, file attachments, board customizations, encrypted private messages, and much more!

Shop: North Spore North Spore Mushroom Grow Kits & Cultivation Supplies   Mushroom-Hut Grow Bags   Original Sensible Seeds Autoflowering Cannabis Seeds   MagicBag.co All-In-One Bags That Don't Suck   Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order

Jump to first unread post Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |  [ show all ]
"Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So * 1
    #29729140 -

Everyone can argue, deride, laugh all they want; even at the highest, most intense level of trips - no matter the drug (even DMT) - your sense of SELF (that is, some level of awareness of YOU vs NOT-YOU, even when blasted) has to be present in some capacity for it to have relevance or meaning or for YOU to experience the trip in the first place.

The background changes, but the foreground never does; YOU are always present because YOU are a metaphysical AND existential singularity.

There is no reality outside of this; YOU are the source, and reality is a function OF YOU.

This is what trips are showing YOU.

"Birth" and "death" are the ultimate paradoxical (they don't actually exist) bookends of the only true, ontological "thing" (YOU) in the only actual temporally-ontological "time"; NOW/THE PRESENT MOMENT/IS.


--------------------
:leaf:
"Real knowledge is to know the extent of one’s ignorance." β€” Confucius

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729142 -

Showing that awareness is required to perceive reality does not prove that awareness generates reality.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Rahz] * 1
    #29729149 -

Rahz said:
Showing that awareness is required to perceive reality does not prove that awareness generates reality.



You couldn't know that either way; you're epistemologically insufficient.

Whatever may or may not exist outside of YOU has no meaning, nor could have meaning, to you.

You can never observe yourself from outside of yourself, and that's the point.

Your counter claim still requires a state of constancy against a background of constant change in order to stand in the first place, which is the root of the argument here.

Rational consistency (beginning with a non-contradictory metaphysic) is going to lead to Truth with a Capital T as we as humans are best able to understand, apply, and benefit from said.


--------------------
:leaf:
"Real knowledge is to know the extent of one’s ignorance." β€” Confucius

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729161 -

I think that capitalization has gone to your head in this thread as revealed by multiple instances of ALL CAPS.

The main error is this:

Quote:
The background changes, but the foreground never does



Since in fact, what changes fills our awareness and spills into our memories, and the rest (all of the unchanging parts) is ignored and becomes background to experience and mere staging for our life stories.

You can inflate our awareness content to encompass our selves (awareness each moment is distinct for each of us).

otherwise I have to say the metaphysic is based upon error - perhaps fueled by yearning for the promised 'eternal' gifts of a trickster.


--------------------
:brainfart: _ :finger:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 2
    #29729174 -

Loaded Shaman said:
Your counter claim...



I didn't make a counter claim. I pointed out the fallacy in yours.

Maybe you were simply mistaken (giving you the benefit of the doubt) but this is a sign you might be arguing in bad faith.

If we are "epistemologically insufficient" to know what exists outside of awareness, that directly contradicts your original claim that "there is no reality outside of this; YOU are the source."

You can't argue that we can't know what lies beyond perception while simultaneously claiming to know for a fact that nothing does.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: redgreenvines] * 2
    #29729184 -

The "you" is a lonely, isolating term. I try not put people uncomfortably on the spot by asking, "how are you?".  Isn't it just a bag of grievances and pain?  I often just make eye contact with the people who I need to interact with, nod my head, and carry on with the transaction.  If they ask, "how are you?" I just reply, "not too bad", or "I'm good".  I'm aware that most of us belong to families, communities, groups.  We are only as good as the persons closest to us. 

In my case, if my neighbor living below me suffers, I suffer with her.  I'm only as good as the people in closest proximity to me.  I've also noticed the term 'you' is sometimes a way to scapegoat and blame.  All the insults are connected to the 'you' function.  You stole, you lied, you're slow, you're (insert insult here).

The 'you' is a red-hot, burning, scolding thing.  I feel much better both as an individual or member of a community or family. You can't flatter or insult someone who is a functional member of a larger tribe.  It's only when you isolate the individual and remove them from their larger connectivity that you can pull a U-turn on them, and them you've got the person backed into a corner. 

I posted this one before, and I'll reiterate it:

Where the west believes "I think, therefore I am", indigenous peoples say "I am, because we are." That is, we are all interconnected. We couldn't exist without all. - Duane Hirini

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Rahz] * 1
    #29729193 -

I might ask you this: When did you realize you had been in the womb?

The answer is: When you became conscious of it. And when is consciousness?

Your consciousness is always NOW. YOU are always NOW. You are the center of all reality…unmovable, timeless, and unchanging. It is what it is because you ARE.  Not were, not will be…you always ARE. Period.

There is thus an β€œInverted”, if you will, relationship between the realization of your β€œpast” in the womb and your present consciousness. You realizing you were at some point β€œbaby” to someone else is a direct function of your consciousness NOW. And moreover, since EVERYTHING that you observe to exist, exists NOW, you cannot declare the β€œpast” as evidence of material body preceding consciousness. You, being utterly and perpetually NOW, have no frame of reference for β€œpast”, and therefore you must concede that the β€œpast” is purely a concept, not an actuality.  Therefore the β€œpast” does not contain any evidence.  All of the evidence is NOW, and NOW is where your consciousness is.

Even that cute little baby picture of you with cake all over your face at your first birthday that you don’t remember is not an β€œimage of the past”.  It is an image that exists NOW. You look at it and you conceptualize a notion of the β€œpast” when you were β€œyounger” and β€œhad no self awareness”, but all of this is done from the frame of reference of your consciousness in the moment of NOW. Your consciousness thus is the IS which allows anything to have any meaning or relevance at all, even the notion of β€œpast existence”, which is, strictly speaking, a contradiction in terms. The only reason you can say you existed in the womb is because you can consciously acknowledge it NOW. Period. So again, which comes first, you in the womb or your consciousness? Everything is a singularity of the NOW. There is no such actual thing as β€œthen”. So to argue that being in the womb β€œthen” is the direct cause of your consciousness NOW is to elevate conceptual paradigms over reality.

To attempt to argue, β€œI know I was then because I know I am now” is logical fallacy. If what you know you always know NOW, then NOW is the frame of reference for ALL knowledge. What you didn’t know then cannot thus be the source or the proof of what you NOW know: that you exist. For that makes awareness the direct product of mindlessness; knowledge the direct product of ignorance. Impossible.


--------------------
:leaf:
"Real knowledge is to know the extent of one’s ignorance." β€” Confucius

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729214 -

I'm more inclined to put emphasis on "we" or "us".  I'm weary of U-turns and finger pointing.  However, we have to find a balance between all those words: I, me, you, we, us. Somehow it all has to come together. Individual pride, chest thumping, and the tendency to use the the word 'you' to shame or scapegoat others, this has to seen for what it is.

Time Works like An Acid:

Time works like acid,
stained eyes,

you see time fly?

The face changes
as the heart beats & breathes

We are not constant
We are an arrow in flight....


Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729216 -

You're confusing when you become aware of a fact with when the fact occurred.

Sure, I can only look at a baby photo or think about the womb in the present moment because conscious observation only happens in the present. That's a trivial truism about perception, not proof that the past didn't happen.

You're confusing epistemology with ontology.

Further, if there is no past, you are just arguing with yourself via an imagined memory. Cut it out!

And finally, you still haven't answered the core contradiction: earlier you said we are "epistemologically insufficient" to know what exists outside our awareness, yet here you are making absolute, dogmatic claims about the fundamental nature of all reality.

How do you expect me to take you seriously?


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729222 -

is there a specific crime in using the term "logic" when you mean the exact opposite?

well let us not mince words to hamburger! I will avoid logic for now and just reference my experience (memory) which has occasionally been logical when it matches the ideal forms of
.

a good policy will be consistency in the use of words, such as awareness and memory.
I think it is consistent to say that what we are aware of NOW (capitalized to show agreeance with your very important concept of NOW - which is always (eternally) changing) flows effortlessly into memory and is accessed when the context is familiar in any significant way.

Since my experience of reality is different from yours, I have to reduce the meaning of 'reality' to personal experience, and I suffer the gaps in my memory of that reality which wound its path following the changes that my awareness had been directed towards.

What you are referring to by "YOU" would be that awareness I think, and it is definitely a biological process of the body&brain functioning normally and naturally.

(admittedly some big heads getting a lot of respect these days (Penrose?) think that consciousness is something else, and they seem to think that our bodies and brains are some kind of radio receiver, but how is that 'logical'?)


--------------------
:brainfart: _ :finger:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729268 -

Nice bad faith/stolen concept combo argument attempt, douchebag; get that bullshit the fuck out of here.

You're a materialist determinist (like all mid-wits) balls deep in presupposition dogma.

Edited by Loaded Shaman (11/16/26 05:09 PM)

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Cory Duchesne] * 1
    #29729270 -

Cory Duchesne said:
I'm more inclined to put emphasis on "we" or "us".  I'm weary of U-turns and finger pointing.  However, we have to find a balance between all those words: I, me, you, we, us. Somehow it all has to come together. Individual pride, chest thumping, and the tendency to use the the word 'you' to shame or scapegoat others, this has to seen for what it is.

Time Works like An Acid:

Time works like acid,
stained eyes,

you see time fly?

The face changes
as the heart beats & breathes

We are not constant
We are an arrow in flight....





There is no collective metaphysic.

YOU only ever experience YOU.

You never experience reality as a group, nor have proof that you can, or ever will.

What is time minus the objects we use to measure it with? Where is time? When is time?

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729279 -

Auto-Summary
In this philosophical critique, Loaded Shaman argues that Objectivism is fundamentally flawed due to its inability to resolve the relationship between the observer and reality. The author contends that because all knowledge requires cognitionβ€”the process of an observer conceptualizing a distinction between the Self and the observedβ€”it is impossible to claim an "objective reality" that exists entirely independent of the observer's frame of reference. By attempting to divorce consciousness from reality, Objectivism creates a logical contradiction that collapses its own foundation. Furthermore, the author attacks the concept of "emergent properties," arguing that consciousness cannot rationally emerge from an unconscious, deterministic existence. Ultimately, the post posits that Objectivism's primary tenet, "existence exists," is a tautological failure that fails to necessitate an observer, thereby rendering the philosophy's claims about objective truth impossible to sustain and leading back to a form of inescapable subjectivism.

Objectivism is a Fallacy

Objectivism asserts a reality distinct from the observer…the observer being, of course, β€œhe who observes”.  Now, understand that when we speak of observation we necessarily imply cognition; and I prefer this term to β€œconsciousness”, since β€œconsciousness” has become rationally opaque and is used by objectivism and other philosophies as a synonym for what is fundamentally subjective. Also, β€œcognition” is less cumbersome, anyway.  It merely means an observer conceptualizing the distinction between himself and what he observes.  Which is the foundation of language, and therefore gets to the very heart and root of real truth.

But cognition is not simply a biological or physiological process…so we need to be careful here.  It CAN BE a rational synonym for β€œconsciousness”, I submit, because it implies a necessary awareness of the distinction between one’s Self, as the Observer (the frame of reference for knowledge), and that which is observed.  In other words, cognition does not necessarily imply the neurological, but rather the active and efficacious and relevancy-giving conscious awareness of the neurological (so to speak…meaning, awareness that β€œneurological” is a thing in the first place…a truth which can be applied to a purpose specifically and necessarily determined by the observer).

So objectivism assert this distinction between β€œobjective reality” and the observer…by which it means a distinction between β€œobjective reality” and cognition.  Now, this distinction is alone enough to discredit objectivism as any kind of rational school of thought, since absent the observer’s ability to define this reality from his own existential frame of reference via cognition, he cannot claim that it exists at all…as objectively real or otherwise. In which case you cannot make any philosophical claims about it whatsoever.  I mean, if β€œobjective reality” is objectively real, and the observer’s position in it is not mutually exclusive of it, then the observer must also be objectively real.  Which means that the tool by which he interprets and defines it, that is, his cognition–his own conscious and singular frame of reference–must also be objectively real.  So…how can one’s consciousness/cognition be divorced from objective reality?

It can’t.

So…there is no β€œobjective reality” outside of consciousness.  Which means that once you are no longer existentially conscious (alive), then you have no frame of reference for objective reality, which means it has no relevancy to you, which means it has no truth to you, where β€œyou” is an absolute context, which means that it cannot be said to exist.  It cannot be said to be anything. Which means that beyond your consciousness you cannot claim a reality which continues, outside of you.

As soon as you attempt to divorce consciousness/cognition from objective reality, you’re done.  You’ve created a contradiction which collapses the whole philosophy.

Nevertheless, let’s continue, because there is another problem–albeit closely related–with objectivism which bears explication.

There can be no distinction between reality and the observer because the observer has no frame of reference for such a reality; and this  because he has no frame of reference for for anything outside of that by which he knows (and therefore can claim) anything–his absolute SELF.  And himSELF, is β€œhe who observes”.

Because he cannot step outside of his own observation, he cannot claim that there is anything outside of that observation.  Whatever is outside of his powers of observation cannot be defined, and therefore he cannot claim that they exist outside of himself.  For β€œhimself” and his observation are entirely corollary.  There is no reality outside himself because it is only by himself, and absolutely so, as the observer that he can make any truth claim, of which β€œreality” is perhaps preeminent.  It is like claiming that I know what it’s like to be a cup of coffee…that is, because I can β€œbe” a cup of coffee outside of myself, I can claim that β€œhere is coffee”, and β€œthere is me”, from TWO completely distinct frames of reference.  But this is impossible since my SELF as the observer is utterly singular.  The cup of coffee β€œoutside” of me only exists as such because I OBSERVE it and define it and give it truth as a function of ME–my absolute frame of reference as the (conscious/cognitive) observer. Without me, there is no frame of reference for that cup of coffee; in which case, I have no definition for coffee that is β€œreal”, β€œoutside of me”.  That is, since I am not a cup of coffee, I can only ever define a cup of coffee as it pertains, absolutely and categorically, to me from my absolute frame of reference as the observer. The distinction, then, between β€œme” and β€œcup of coffee”, is entirely a function of MY singular ability to conceptualize the distinction.  Without that ability, that is, without me, as utterly and absolutely myself, consciously/cognitively, there is no distinction.  And therefore, there is no β€œreality’ outside of me.  A cup of coffee entirely and β€œobjectively” outside of me–outside of my SELF–is entirely and infinitely irrelevant.  And one cannot claim the existence of that which is infinitely irrelevant. And in this way, apprehending a β€œreality” for me–that is, a reality that I can observe and thus claim from the place of me, yet not from me, but outside of me–is a violation of both my identity and the identity of β€œreality”.  To claim a reality outside of me that I can somehow observe and know and yet exists entirely and absolutely and completely independent of me is not to affirm reality, but to destroy it.  It is to dismantle cognition as the means of ascertaining truth, because it is to say that human cognition has nothing fundamentally to do with reality.  But since cognition is, in fact, the means, and only means, by which man can know anything, to dismantle it is to subordinate humanity to an entirely unknowable β€œreality”.  And if that isn’t a recipe for tyranny, then I don’t know what is.  And this is precisely why in the 60 years or so since Objectivism became the chef d’oeuvre of β€œrationalists” despotism has done nothing but advance…and mightily so.

*

While Objectivists speak of absolute distinction between the observer and reality, they also claim that Objectivism fully and absolutely integrates the observer, via the metaphysical primary of Existence, into that reality.  This is a problem.  How can you step outside of that which is, at root, you–existence–in order to observe you?  That is, if you are are fully and absolutely a function of the absolute and infinite metaphysical primary, how can you make the distinction between β€œyou” and β€œreality” by appealing to an absolute which is both?

In order to answer this contradiction, some objectivists, or respecters of Objectivism, will assert the concept of β€œemergent properties”. And this is the idea that something in whole becomes greater in some sense than the sum of its parts.  This, in fact, cannot be literally true. That is, it is only ever subjectively true, never objectively so. Abstractly…subjectively, yes.  A thing can have more value than its mere material properties would suggest; but notice that this requires a conscious observer to apply that thing to his particular frame of reference of Self. In terms of objective truth, it is impossible to claim that a thing is anything more than that of which it is comprised at root.  That is, there is no such thing as some β€œproperty” β€œemerging” beyond the absolute irreducible ontic essence of something. Like, if we claim that all things, including human beings, are at root a function of immutable physical laws, or absolute fundamental particles interacting according to these absolutely immutable physical laws (which is a contradiction…but that’s a topic for later), and that this has nothing whatsoever to do with consciousness/cognition–that is, has nothing to do with the fact that man apprehends and defines ALL of what he perceives as real via his awareness of Self (his ability to conceptualize relative distinctions between his Self, and what is NOT Self)–then we cannot claim that consciousness is somehow an β€œemergent property” and therefore doesn’t contradict the absolute and irreducible source of man and all things, which is utterly and absolutely unconscious.  This is a fallacy, and cannot be taken seriously.

The idea of β€œemergent properties”, in other words, is the irrational assertion that you get consciousness from what is absolutely unconscious; that you get free will from irrelevant determinism (biological, physical, natural, mathematical); that you get Self–in the sense of a singular β€œYou”, from NOT You; an observational and existential frame of reference of β€œI” from NOT I; that what is infinite, Existence–which according to Objectivism is the irreducible, infinite metaphysical primary–spawns a plurality of finite objects; that an infinite existence somehow produces a plurality of itself without contradicting itself.

And it is from this claim–that existence as the metaphysical primary somehow spawns a plurality of itself…where things can actually exist utterly distinct from one another and allow for the observer to perceive a β€œreality” outside himself (outside his cognition)–that we get the common obectivist refrain of β€œexistence exists”.

But β€œexistence exists” is simply saying that existence has existence, which is a tautological assertion, and therefore a logical failure.  You see, the rational metaphysical argument is not that the primary simply implies itself, but that it implies someONE–some observer; some reference–who is able to claim that it is, in fact, the metaphysical primary in the first place; that it is, in fact, TRUE. That it holds REAL relevance; REAL efficacy.  That it implies something in a practical sense beyond itself, which can see it, and know it, but doesn’t contradict it as the absolute and irreducible primary.  Objectivism fails at this, and therefore ultimately fails entirely…as does any other philosophy which fails to meet the requirement for a rationally consistent metaphysical primary.

Now, having said that, reconciling this inherent metaphysical paradox is really hard.  So hard, in fact, that I’m not sure of any primary outside of my own (Ability) which successfully does this.  Here’s why it’s so challenging:

Let’s look at β€œexistence exists” again.  What is absolutely itself, and irreducibly, or infinitely so, cannot possess properties of itself, because those β€œproperties” are necessarily also infinite.  And as such they are undefinable…other than to say that the properties of existence are existence itself, which as I have explained is a logical failure.

Further, saying that existence exists is merely saying that existence is itself, which is a meaningless claim unless β€œitself” can be defined.  But if β€œitself” is infinite then it cannot be valued…for if there is no limitation to itself, then it cannot be anywhere, and thus it cannot be anything.  Another way to put it is: that which is everything and everywhere cannot be anything or anywhere.  That which is all is itself nothing.

But the rational metaphysical primary must certainly be absolute, and thus infinite, which according to my explication above is a contradiction that seems beyond resolution, making any metaphysical primary impossible.  Now, I submit that this is not actually the case–that it is a true paradox, and not a contradiction, and therefore has a resolution.  But the question here is: Does β€œexistence” as a primary resolve it?

The answer is no.  Because β€œexistence” doesn’t imply anything beyond itself, and this is proven by the epigram which oft accompanies it: β€œexistence exists”.  This simply means that existence implies existence.  It begins and ends with itself.  The β€œplurality” of itself, from which the observer ostensibly arises, ironically doesn’t actually exist! The observer cannot be made rationally distinct from β€œexistence” if β€œexistence” is the metaphysical primary…a distinction which is utterly necessary if he is to actually observe anything.  You see, it’s not about whether or not the observer exits, but whether or not the observer is able to define existence.  That is, it’s not about whether or not the observer IS at root the metaphysical primary, but whether the primary actually implies–demands/necessitates–that there BE an observer…that he occupy a place from which he can SEE it, as distinct from himself, and know it, and define it, and therefore make it relevant; make it actually the TRUE metaphysical primary.

But, again, β€œexistence” doesn’t imply anything beyond itself, and therefore the observer cannot actually observe it (nor anything else, since all β€œthings” are equally infinite β€œexistence), and so he cannot define it.  Therefore, as soon as an objectivist makes any truth claim, let alone the claim that β€œexistence” is the metaphysical primary, they have dismantled the primary and thus their entire philosophy. There is nothing outside of existence, not even the objectivist. Because all things have equal absolute existence, there is no such thing as β€œall things”.  There is just infinite existence, which is, in fact, nothing at all. Because: that which is all, is actually nothing.

In summary, there is a dreadfully complicated paradox here that for all of its beauty and Rand’s inarguable genius Objectivism doesn’t answer.  Because to answer it is to reject its metaphysical primary, which is a rejection of itself.  The only root objective thing at all anywhere is the metaphysical primary; and Objectivism’s primary, existence, spawns nothing but subjectivism by affirming and necessitating that the observer/reality paradox is infinitely paradoxical.  And this is how a paradox becomes a contradiction.  Because a paradox which can have no resolution is no longer a paradox, it is an impossibility…a contradiction in terms.  And contradiction is the mother of subjectivity. Because contradiction as infinite foundational β€œtruth” spawns infinite truths. Which is simply infinite contradiction.

All of this makes Objectivism considerably ironic.  An β€œobjective” metaphysic which demands utterly subjective epistemology, purpose, ethics, and politics is hardly objective, let alone a rational basis for the argumentation of objective reality.


--------------------
:leaf:
"Real knowledge is to know the extent of one’s ignorance." β€” Confucius

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729294 -

Rational consistency, taken as a strict categorical foundation for truth, precludes pure empiricism because sense data is inherently contingent, temporally fragmented, and incapable of generating absolute logical necessity on its own.
To assert that reality must conform to rational consistency is to establish an a priori standardβ€”one that exists logically prior to, and independent of, sensory observation.

The Categorical Conflict:

β€’ Necessity vs. Contingency: Rationalism demands internal logical necessity (what must be true without contradiction). Empiricism relies entirely on contingent sensory inputs (what happens to appear in a given moment), which can never bridge the gap to universal certainty.

β€’ The Foundation of Interpretation: Sensory perception does not interpret itself. Before an empirical observation can even be categorized, measured, or deemed valid, it must be filtered through rational axioms such as the law of identity and the law of non-contradiction.

β€’ Temporal Fragmentation: Empirical claims rely on memory, sequence, and inductionβ€”assuming that past observations reliably dictate future ones. Within a strictly consistent present-moment framework, relying on unverified past impressions or future projections introduces unproven metaphysical assumptions rather than direct certainty.

β€’ The Self-Refutation of Pure Empiricism: The claim that "all knowledge comes from sensory experience" is itself a universal, categorical rule. It cannot be observed through the senses, meaning empiricism must borrow a non-empirical, rationalist premise just to state its own core principle.

Reconciling the Two Frameworks

β€’ Rationalism as the Container: In strict epistemology, rational consistency acts as the non-negotiable boundary of what is intelligible. Anything that violates rational consistency cannot be coherently conceptualized, regardless of how vividly it appears to the senses.

β€’ Empiricism as Subordinate Description: Within a rationally consistent worldview, empirical observation can still map immediate appearances or practical patterns. However, it cannot serve as an independent arbiter of ontological truth or override logical necessity.


--------------------
:leaf:
"Real knowledge is to know the extent of one’s ignorance." β€” Confucius

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729301 -

a brain baffled by bullshit is still a brain
how can we help?
clearly you do not seek discourse.


--------------------
:brainfart: _ :finger:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729302 -

I am not going to defend Loaded Shaman's version of this, because I think it goes too far.

I do not agree there is no past, or that reality is created by YOU, or that saying we only know things NOW means the past did not happen. Rahz is right that confusing when you become aware of a fact with when the fact occurred is confusing epistemology with ontology.
I am defending a much narrower claim, and I think it is the strongest part of what he is trying to get at.

Suppose you had a complete third person description of the universe. Every atom, every brain state, every person, past present future, all in one book. You read it cover to cover. You would still not know one thing: which person in the book you are.

You would know that person #4,382,019 is sitting in a chair reading this post. You would know his memories, his history, his brain state. You would not know that you are that person, experiencing from inside that skull, rather than experiencing from someone else's.

I grant the past happened. I grant I was in the womb. I grant the baby photo is of a real past baby. That does not close the gap, because the book can include all of that and still leave out which center you are.

I am not claiming this is a ghost or an extra ingredient added to the universe. I am not claiming a new particle. I am claiming perspective itself is the thing to be explained, not just indexed. I am claiming it is a real kind of knowledge, self locating knowledge, that cannot be captured in purely third person language. Words like I, here, and now are not optional decoration. They are how that knowledge is expressed, and you cannot paraphrase them away without losing the knowledge itself.

I agree changing biology changes awareness. Anesthesia, brain damage, psychedelics, all of that is real. That shows dependence, not identity. Dependence is not the same as being purely biological. Memory does locate me, and I am not pretending memory is a list in a book. Memory is lived as mine. My question is not whether biology is tied to a center. It clearly is. My question is why there is a center at all when that biology is happening, why there is something it is like to be the process, rather than the process just happening with no one home.

Two replies I expect, so let me answer them in advance.

First, that is just language, not metaphysics. If language tracks real knowledge, and there is real knowledge that third person language cannot express, then a purely third person description is incomplete. It does not matter if you call the gap linguistic or metaphysical. The gap is real, and materialism promised a complete description.

Second, duplication solves it, each copy will think it is the one. That does not solve it, it multiplies it. The book can tell you Copy A is in Philly and Copy B is in Pittsburgh. It can distinguish them perfectly as that one and this one. What it cannot tell you, without you already knowing which perspective you occupy, is whether you are the Philly one or the Pittsburgh one. You cannot get from there are two brains in two places to this is the one I am without smuggling in an I to do the picking.

Loaded Shaman's best point, cleaned up, is the emergence point: you cannot get an I from a description that contains only NOT I, unless you smuggle the I in at the start. I am not claiming that proves emergence is impossible in general. I am claiming it is a specific, unsolved problem for this case.

So here is the challenge: show me how to derive I am this one from physical facts alone, without using I, here, now, or any other indexical to do the work. If you cannot, then there is at least one real kind of knowledge that is not third person physical knowledge, and materialism as a complete story is still incomplete on its own terms.

Edited by cubedryeguy (11/16/26 04:42 PM)

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: cubedryeguy] * 1
    #29729309 -

@cubed, was that show me request to LoadedShaman?
@LoadedShaman, do you have me on ignore?


--------------------
:brainfart: _ :finger:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729311 -

My understanding of the word "you" is that it is about what another person has to say about me.  It's reputational and status effecting.  Mr. Rogers might say I am special, in a good way.  A psychiatrist or physician may say I'm schizophrenic, in a bad way. As I mentioned in the amygdala, cannabis and insults thread, I see the 'you' as a tremendous source of confusion and suffering, as another person outside of our subjective experience can insert any insult or slight they feel like hurling.

My understanding of the word "I" or "me" is that it is the refusal or resistance to every insult or even flattery.

As for "we" or "us".... I do think there is empathy and compassion, for instance, a neighbor who screams in anger can transmit her pain to the listener. There is a collective or social experience, where another persons distress becomes the distress of the listener.

Unlike our eyes, which we can close, our ears have no lids, we can't escape sound and verbalization as easily as we can escape something we might not want to look at. 

I see the listening, hearing or ear function as uniquely pain inducing. 

Whenever someone speaks to me about me, observing or building up information about me, the word 'you' used in the context of saying something bad about the listener or reader, it seems more like an attack or verbal assault. 

We have a need to retreat into the sense of "I" or "me" or even "we".  But the "you" seems uniquely suited for mostly reputational damage, verbal assault, and at best, flattery.

That's just my personal experience.  I have a strong distrust for someone who speaks to me about me, by saying the word you, and then inserting whatever content they want into that.  In many cases, it's a kind of insulting, biting, hurting gesture, a burning word, etc.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Cory Duchesne] * 2
    #29729313 -

since our ears have no lids


--------------------
:brainfart: _ :finger:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: "Reality" is a Function of YOU, and ABSOLUTELY So [Re: Loaded Shaman] * 1
    #29729315 -

Loaded Shaman said:
Nice bad faith argument attempt, douchebag; get that bullshit the fuck out of here.

That's rich, considering ALL of the above is exactly what you're doing here, pal.

You're directly confusing what I'm saying, doubling back, and then claiming I'm doing what you're doing.

GTFO here with that bullshit YOU are the one stating contradictions and crossing wires here; in fact, the fact that you're actually accusing me of conflating epistemology with ontology proves you can't tell the difference, which proves my point you're Dunning-Krugering yourself on this one.

Rational consistency precludes empiricism buddy; that's the entire point of this argument.

You think you've won the game when you're still in reality sitting in your car, in the wrong parking lot, and can't tell the difference while yelling at passersby.

There is no contradiction I asked you bluntly how you could know that, and you're presupposing you can as a basis for your premise here.

You're accusing me of dogma for rational consistency, when you yourself presuppose the past as an actual location you can re-vist like Doc Brown.

You're a materialist/causalist balls deep in presupposition dogma.




I will assume this reply is to me.

What I'm doing is working on an assumption. You are not working on an assumption and have explicitly said so. Your contradiction is obvious and you aren't even attempting to address it.

Existence isn't logical. Time isn't logical. But in order to have working theories some level of axiomatic information must be assumed. Rejecting such starting points in the name of rational consistency just leaves you with a closed loop that explains nothing, and yet I suppose you will continue to operate with the same assumptions I do.

But if time is an illusion you still need an explanation for why experience feels ordered and why memories exist, but it seems you have no axiom that allows for logical and empirical reasoning and discovery in your alternate story.

For the record, I don't suppose the past is a location I can visit, via block universe. That is a theory without empirical support.

I also suppose your emotional outburst is defensive. No offense taken at any rate, but it does nothing for your argument.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Jump to top Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |  [ show all ]

Shop: North Spore North Spore Mushroom Grow Kits & Cultivation Supplies   Mushroom-Hut Grow Bags   Original Sensible Seeds Autoflowering Cannabis Seeds   MagicBag.co All-In-One Bags That Don't Suck   Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order


Similar ThreadsPosterViewsRepliesLast post
* Describe a version of reality. (Creativity encouraged.)
( 1 2 3 all )
PowerTrip 2,561 57 07/20/06 02:55 AM
by MushmanTheManic
* Birth and Death: Paradoxical Bookends of the Absolute Self Loaded Shaman 36 6 11/16/26 04:18 PM
by The Blind Ass
* your mind COULD be creating reality
( 1 2 3 all )
Moonshoe 7,512 47 07/17/04 05:04 AM
by Source
* imagination is reality
( 1 2 3 all )
DoctorJ 3,462 56 05/22/06 04:02 PM
by redgreenvines
* Reality is your best friend
( 1 2 all )
SkorpivoMusterion 5,827 35 10/06/10 04:47 PM
by trentinxd
* Reality: Our objective, benelovent friend SkorpivoMusterion 1,349 10 11/19/05 05:04 PM
by Ped
* can you prove the existence of absolute, objective morality?
( 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 all )
Anonymous 23,335 157 12/21/04 08:31 AM
by deafpanda
* Reality isn't real
( 1 2 3 all )
ShroomismM 5,269 43 09/24/06 05:01 PM
by Telepylus

Extra information
You cannot start new topics / You cannot reply to topics
HTML is disabled / BBCode is enabled
Moderator: Middleman, DividedQuantum
245 topic views. 2 members, 48 guests and 36 web crawlers are browsing this forum.
[ Show Images Only | Sort by Score | Print Topic ]
Search this thread:

Copyright 1997-2026 Mind Media. Some rights reserved.

Generated in 0.028 seconds spending 0.007 seconds on 16 queries.