Shroomism said:

Besides shouldn't you be able to judge the integrity of someone's cultivation advice/knowledge just by reading their posts on it?

---

Ythan said:

Hey,

This is an interesting idea but I think it would be kind of redundant. The whole purpose of the rating's "comment" field is so you can clarify what the rating is for. Thanks for the suggestion though!

Peace,

-Y

---

Paradigm said:

By that logic, there shouldn't be a need for trade ratings either.

---

so what you are saying is, that the solution to this problem is to get rid of the trade ratings? brilliant idea

OneMoreRobot3021 said:

I think the two rating systems that are in place are all that's needed.  I mean, do you actually judge someone on this site wholly by all their ratings?  I look through to see what people have said about them but only REALLY take note of the comments made by people who I already know I have a certain rapport with, people whose judgment I would trust.  And the trade ratings have a place, just like ratings on eBay have a place.

---

well no i dont judge anyone by them, it jsut, well it gives you some kind of better overwiev.

especially for people who axx the shroomery soley for mycological use this third rating thingie
i suggested would be such a charm.

but many people came up with good ideas why it wouldnt be so good so i guess,
itll just stay some idea.
still wanted to point it out.
peace ohm

Anno said:

>The way I see it, the general rates are for your opinion of that poster's personality

No.
The general rating is for everything you find good or bad about a person, except anything that has to do with trading goods.

---