In fact, lets clear this up even more. From TMC, chilton and Stamets, 1983:
"Amazonian: Medium to large mushrooms on rye grain; thick whitish stems; tenaciously attached to the casing
Matias Romero: Medium to large mushrooms on rye grain; early fruiter; thick whitish stems and tenaciously attached."
This alone tells us that the Matias Romero and Amazonian strains are different. Unless somebody is gonna tell me that Stamets and Chilton are idiots and they made a mistake, but don't bet on it. This also means that all three names can't be interchangeable.
Now, what PF says about his strain in related areas:
"7. SIZE TENDANCIES (overall size of the mushroom at maturity)
Small to about as big as they get. 2. STEM (length - girth - flesh - colors)
It can be short and fat or long and hefty. It depends on the air and humidity. The PF race responds to this seriously. with lots of air and humidity, the PF stem is long, slender, thick fleshed and white. The flesh of the PF race is unique amongst all the races. It is very much like soft moist BREAD. But sometimes there can be a bit of fibrousness here and there.
5. TENACIOUSNES (Strength of attachment of the stem base to the cake)
The PF is the champ at this. Usually the PF shroom as a large base (big foot). In fact, "BIG FOOT" should be the sur name of the PF race. This makes the PF race the most tenacious to the substrate of them all. When harvested, it is common to pull off large chunks of cake in the process.
6. SHAPE SHIFTING (shapes and changes of flush to flush - strain to strain)
The PF race is the champ in this also. It goes from ugly little abhorts and convoluted dwarfs, to tall robust white thick stemed specimens with large deep reddish colored caps that go to plane and then wildly upturn at full maturity. "
So, does this tell us if the PF strain came from either the MR or the Amazon or neither? I don't think so. The similarities in the descriptions are obvious, but don't rule out but half of all cube strains. Also, don't you think that Stamets and Chilton would have noted some of the AMAZING and UNIQUE characteristics of the PF strain? LIke it's moist bread consistency? Or it's EXTREME tanacity? Or the fact that it sometimes makes small shrooms, not the medium to large that stamets uses to describe the other two? Or the mutants that the PF strain shows? Do you really think that the master of mycology would overlook "ugly aborts, convoluted dwarfs, and wildly upturned caps"?
Sorry, but if any of those traits of the PF strain had been present in the Amazonian or Matias Romero strain, you better bet that at least one of them would have been mentioned.
Going back to my previous post, it's still obvious that the current day PF strain is different from either of the two described by stamets in 1983, whether they share ancestry or not.
Now if people want to mislead people into buying Stamets strain and getting the PF strain, then I guess they can use either Amazonian or Matias Romero freely. But if the point of a strain name is to let the consumer have any idea of what they are growing, I think the prudent thing to do would be to not use these names interchangeably.
But then again, PF did say
"It is also called "Matias Romero" at other spore sellers sites or Amazonian. It lately has picked up the name "PF CLASSIC"."
So that gives us permission to call it whatever we want and claim that it's correct. I mean people can't be expected to know what strain they really have, it's too complicated. Let the growers and future vendors figure it out. I mean, they're just gonna call em whatever they want as well. Right?
-------------------- "From a certain point of view"
-Jedi Master Obi Wan Kenobi
PM me with any cultivation questions.
I just looked at my profile and realized I had a website at one point in time on geocities, it's not there anymore and I have no idea what I had on it. Anybody remember my website from several years aga? PM if so please.
|