Auto-SummaryThe author of this post disputes the official explanation for the collapse of the World Trade Center (WTC) on 9/11, arguing that the destruction of the towers cannot be attributed solely to the plane crashes and resulting fires. They point out that several other buildings, including the Meridian One Building in Philadelphia, have withstood significant fires without collapsing, and that the fires at the WTC did not burn hot enough to damage the steel structures. The author also notes that the black smoke seen billowing from the towers indicates incomplete combustion and suggests that other factors, possibly explosives, may have contributed to the collapse. Additionally, they question the official narrative surrounding the collapse of Building 7, which fell without being hit by a plane, and raise doubts about the role of jet fuel in causing damage to the steel beams. The author's arguments are based on their expertise in engineering and explosives, which they claim are being ignored by the official investigators.
Pure rubbish...
* No steel building has ever been destroyed by fire.
Just because something has never happened, does not mean that it cannot happen.
* The South Tower fell after only 1 hour. The North Tower fell one hour later. After the initial fireball, neither building burned significantly. The Meridian One Building burned significantly. The Meridian One Building in Philadelphia burned fiercely for 19 hours and never collapsed.
How do we know that neither building burned significantly after the initial fireball? I saw smoke continously billowing out of both buildings after they were hit. Usually, smoke indicates a fire, and a fire which is energetic enough to drop a building would seem to be classified as a significant fire. Comparing the fire at the Meridian One Building to the fires of the World Trade Center is like comparing apples to oranges.
* Building 7 at the WTC, steel and constructed differently from the twin towers, fell at 5:30. It was not hit by an airplane and had no apparent significant fire.
The energy released by the collapse of the two towers was enormous. It is so surprising that other buildings in the area were damaged? Saying "no apparent significant fire" would indicate that there was at least some fire. If the damage from the twin towers was enough to start some fire at Building 7, then how much more structural damage was also done that we cannot see.
* Jet fuel burns at too low a temperature to harm steel. The black smoke indicates that the jet fuel was not even burning at maximum temperature. And the fires did not burn long enough to harm steel.
Coal burns at too low a tempature to harm steel, yet I can melt steel with burning coal. Black smoke indicates incomplete combusion, of something; there were a lot of other things burning in the towers other than jet fuel. Incomplete combustion can occur at very high temperatures if there is not enough oxygen present. Black smoke in this case means nothing, except that there was a fire somewhere. The author needs to make up his mind: "Jet fuel burns at too low a temperature to harm steel" followed by "and the fires did not burn long enough to harm steel." I have turned solid steel into slag in just minutes using a very hot fire. Without knowing the temperature of the fire, there is no way of knowing how long it would have taken for the steel to fail.
* Days later, there were still "hot spots" in the building that exceeded the maximum temperature possible for burning jet fuel, but just the right temperature if explosives had been used.
This claim comes from a complete ignorance of engineering, explosives, and thermal transfer. What is the maximum temperature possible for burning jet fuel? If you force the hydrogen in the jet fuel to fuse, the maximum temperature is going to be around the same temperature as the sun. Excluding nuclear forces, we still cannot determine a maximum temperature without knowing other factors; things like oxygen availability, thermal insulation and rates of thermal transfer, surface area, availability of fuel, and many other factors all effect the burning temperature. The comment about "just the right temperature if explosives had been used" is equally ignorant. Ever notice those craters burning for days after a bomb is dropped in Iraq? Me either... wonder why? Perhaps it is because an explosive releases all of it's energy very quickly as chemical bonds rearrange. The force of an explosion goes into moving things, not into heating them up (for the most part).
* The concrete clouds shooting out of the buildings are not possible from a mere collapse. They do occur from explosions.
Have you ever watched a non-explosive building demolition... there is a whole lotta clouds from concrete dust given off as things fall. All of the air trapped inside of the buildings had to go somewhere as they were falling. Common sense here, folks. Fill a balloon with some talc and then inflate the balloon and tie it off. Now have somebody watch while you crush the balloon, popping it. Did all the talc stay in one place, or did it shoot out in all directions? I guess explosives must have been used on the balloon as well...
* The buildings collapsed at the maximum speed of gravity. That is almost impossible without explosives.
Ah yes, the speed of gravity. Nobel prize here if somebody can actually measure the speed of gravity... even Albert Einstein couldn't figure this one out, and he tried quite hard. Gravity does cause objects to accelerate downward if nothing is holding them up. In a vacuum, objects will fall at the same rate, regardless of size or mass. This is simple high school physics, not rocket science... you don't even need to understand calculus for this one. Explosives, jet fuel, it doesn't matter...the buildings would have fallen at the same rate regardless.
* The impact of the airplanes and the resulting fires were way off center. More than 2 sides of the tower and the main center columns were untouched. Why did all three buildings collapse?
Who says a fire, or impact, has to be centered for it to do damage? If I shoot you in the side of the head as opposed to the center of the head, you still die. How to we know that the main center columns were untouched? Let's just make up some stuff here and pretend that we know what we are talking about.
* The specifics of the fires in WTC 7 and how they caused the building to collapse remain unknown at this time.
... and? We can't even say for sure that fires caused the collapse of WTC 7.
* F-16 fighers are supposed to form an umbrella over Washington in an emergency. The Pentagon was attacked over AN HOUR after the second aircraft hit the WTC. Why were no fighters scrambled?
Why did Bush keep reading to the kids for so long... why were we not ready during WWII when Japan hit pearl harbor... because we were caught with our pants down and it takes time to prepare a F-16 for a combat mission. You think they have fighters all over the country sitting on the runway at ready-5, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week... just in case they are needed? In fact, fighters were scrambled and created an umbrella over the entire country... it just took a while to coordinate it.
-------------------- Just another spore in the wind.
|