fahtster said: Well, I think if the scalpel dips in the agar and the transfer is left there, there’s not really any difference because the scalpel went through the same parts as the tuft.. they’re both as dirty as each other.
Just to be clear, I am talking about dipping the scalpel in the new receiving plate to get the AMT off the scalpel. Dipping in the plate I'm taking the transfer from is a DOA 
fahtster said: From your video, it didn’t look as tho you had a hard time getting the tuft off. My hands aren’t steady at all so using a scalpel without a hook doesn’t work very well for me. I rest the scalpel on the edge of the plate sides so I don’t dip into the surface when I’m taking the transfer which works great but the tuft likes to get a bit stuck onto the hook. This creates a problem putting it on the receiving plate where I have to use the plate surface and end up jabbing multiple spots on the surface to get it off and sometimes it just disappears and I don’t even know if I got it off or not
For example.. here’s a plate where that happened and more times than not, the transfer isn’t successful

Chances are that it was a pretty tiny tuft to begin with and after trying to remove it on the surface, it compacted into something I couldn’t even see on the tip anymore. And all this is because I can’t seem to get my gellan gum as firm as my agar. That’s why I use a firm WA plate to dislodge the tufts initially. I can use the WA to jab as much as I need to get it off but it usually doesn’t take much with a nice firm surface.
I noticed a while back when I was using agar that every once in a while, the tuft would come right off and those transfers were always the best transfers so, what I started doing was using part of the receiving plate off to the side as the area is dislodge the transfer and then move it over to the other side of the plate where there weren’t a bunch of stabs in the surface. Then I just decided to make a bunch of firm WA plates that I use each transfer session so my receiving plates didn’t have a bunch of bacteria all around it.
Sometimes the tuft comes off without even touching the receiving plate, usually it takes a stab or two, and other times it never comes off or it dissapears 
I was just wondering at what point it's time to accept defeat and find peace with going for a new plate and a new transfer. I will have to try pouring a sleeve of hard WA plates and see if I can get the hang of what you are describing 
fahtster said: All that’s to say, I don’t want to waste a bunch of plates either the only time I call a plate a loss is if I drop it. Aerial transfers are always going to be better than wedge transfers (to me) even if you do end up jabbing the plate a bunch or don’t do a “perfect” AM transfer. But really, the throw away firm WA plate makes every transfer “perfect” because all the bullshit that might happen is left on the WA plate.
Kinda figured that and you were just showing what an aerial transfer was in a general sense. The “note” wasn’t really for you, more the ppl watching the video that haven’t done it before… a further clarification.
I didn't think the note was to me only, I just wanted to explaine to clarify to everyone reading so thanks for bringing it up. I believe I know you well enough to know that you do your work for the love of the hobby and don't care who's right or wrong, best practice is best practice and we share the same goal. I am here to learn to improve my skills and cultivate healthy fruits.
Unfortunately for some of you that will lead to me asking questions that might seem as they are challenging what was said, but that is not the case, I just want to be sure I understood what was explained correctly and while I work my way towards a better technique, know what is acceptable and what is not. Which in this case was if it would be better to take AMT's rather then wedge.
fahtster said: I’m so anti-wedge transfer lol. At least for pans. Any AMT is better than a wedge, imo/e. Even if it’s from the more inner part of the culture… it’s more than likely not going to get it cleaner, but it’s probably not going to make it worse either.
What I will do in that situation (and ik exactly what you’re talking about because it happens to me too) is stop if the leading edge get blown down because if the leading edge is healthy enough, you can wait a couple few days and that edge will pop back up and you can take another stab at it.
This actually happened to me the other day.. I thought this culture would be a super easy AM grab and when I opened the plate, the myc was so delicate, it immediately started laying down and I wasn’t fast enough to get a tuft to grab into the hook. I kept dipping into the surface and eventually said fuck it and took a leading edge wedge because I thought it looked clean enough that would be safe to do

Time will tell but anyway, you can see how the leading edge grew back in those few days even better than it was.. possibly from the influx of o2 from the plate being opened
Sweet, because I already know that going forward I will probably abandon wedge transfer except for inoculations, but once in a while time just ain't on my side and so it would be good to know if a barren AMT is better then a wedge, as I pressumed, but wanted to hear your thoughts on the matter.
fahtster said: I’m glad you asked that question because I forgot about that plate and will do an AMT from the leading edge tomorrow now that it’s grown back 
I’m not saying I have all the answers but I’m doing a fuck ton of AM and just sharing what I’m finding along the way
Happy to be your alzheimer pill for the day And sure you don't have all the answers but as far as I'm concerned, have done the most AMT around here and it felt natural to ask you. I'm not here searching for, or demanding objective definite truths, just your thoughts and methods on the matter 
Which you provided elegantly, thanks again man, appreciate it a lot
-------------------- “All Fungi are edible.
Some fungi are only edible once.”
― Terry Pratchett
  
|