Auto-SummaryThe post discusses the legal and biological definitions of a "person" and "human being" in relation to abortion. It clarifies that an abortion is not murder, as the legal definition of murder requires killing a born human being with premeditated malice. The post also addresses the distinction between dilation and curettage (D&C) and abortion, stating that they are essentially the same procedure. The author argues that a fetus, prior to birth, is a human being but not a "person" within the legal definition, as the Constitution does not include the unborn. The discussion touches on the stages of fetal development and the concept of a fetus as a parasite, using modern biological definitions to support the argument.
Thanks for taking the time to respond. I am glad you addressed all those posts.
This would seem to me to indicate that, well, abortion isn't murder, since a fetus hasn't been born into the world of the spirit...at the very least, it'd indicate taht it's okay up to the point of quickening...
Actually the legal definition of murder is:
1.The unlawful killing of one human being by another, especially with premeditated malice.
So, no, an abortion isn?t murder although it is killing.
You seem to be differentiating between a D-n-C and abortion. Dilitation and Curretage is just another form of abortion.
Yes, that is correct.
Not really. Homo Sapiens, yes, but not a "human being," which is a rather fuzzier concept.
That isn?t correct. The definition of a human being is found in biology and it is highly defined. A ?person? is a fuzzier concept but the legal definition helps to some degree.
Technically, corporations are persons. Now, that's a giant hunk of shit, in my opinion, but legally, it is so. Legal definitions aren't useful to define philosophical concepts. Could an AI be human, or a person?
Whether corporations are legally considered to be persons really has nothing to do with this issue. The legal definition of a person as an individual is what we are concerned with. And it is found in Roe versus Wade:
?A. The appellee and certain amici argue that the fetus is a "person" within the language and meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment. In support of this, they outline at length and in detail the well- known facts of fetal development. If this suggestion of personhood is established, the appellant's case, of course, collapses, [p157] for the fetus' right to life would then be guaranteed specifically by the Amendment. The appellant conceded as much on reargument.(51) On the other hand, the appellee conceded on reargument(52) that no case could be cited that holds that a fetus is a person within the meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Constitution does not define "person" in so many words. Section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment contains three references to "person." The first, in defining "citizens," speaks of "persons born or naturalized in the United States." The word also appears both in the Due Process Clause and in the Equal Protection Clause. "Person" is used in other places in the Constitution: in the listing of qualifications for Representatives and Senators, Art. I, ? 2, cl. 2, and ? 3, cl. 3; in the Apportionment Clause, Art. I, ? 2, cl. 3;(53) in the Migration and Importation provision, Art. I, ? 9, cl. 1; in the Emolument Clause, Art. I, ? 9, cl. 8; in the Electors provisions, Art. II, ? 1, cl. 2, and the superseded cl. 3; in the provision outlining qualifications for the office of President, Art. II, ? 1, cl. 5; in the Extradition provisions, Art. IV, ? 2, cl. 2, and the superseded Fugitive Slave Clause 3; and in the Fifth, Twelfth, and Twenty-second Amendments, as well as in ?? 2 and 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment. But in nearly all these instances, the use of the word is such that it has application only postnatally. None indicates, with any assurance, that it has any possible pre-natal application.(54)[p158] All this, together with our observation, supra, that throughout the major portion of the l9th century prevailing legal abortion practices were far freer than they are today, persuades us that the word "person," as used in the Fourteenth Amendment, does not include the unborn.(55) This is in accord with the results reached in those few cases where the issue has been squarely presented. McGarvey v. Magee-Womens Hospital, 340 F. Supp. 751 (WD Pa. 1972); Byrn v. New York City Health & Hospitals Corp., 31 N. Y. 2d 194, 286 N. E. 2d 887 (1972), appeal docketed, No. 72-434; Abele v. Markle, 351 F. Supp. 224 (Conn. 1972), appeal docketed, No. 72-730. Cf. Cheaney v. State, -- Ind., at --, 285 N. E. 2d, at 270; Montana v. Rogers, 278 F. 2d 68, 72 (CA7 1960), aff'd sub nom. Montana v. Kennedy, 366 U. S. 308 (1961); Keeler v. Superior Court, 2 Cal. 3d 619, 470 P. 2d 617 (1970); State v. Dickinson, 28 [p159] Ohio St. 2d 65, 275 N. E. 2d 599 (1971). Indeed, our decision in United States v. Vuitch, 402 U. S. 62 (1971), inferentially is to the same effect, for we there would not have indulged in statutory interpretation favorable to abortion in specified circumstances if the necessary consequence was the termination of life entitled to Fourteenth Amendment protection.?
So, according to the court a ?person? is a human being who has been born. Prior to that they are without a doubt a human being but they are not a person. This is much like the decision where Negroes where considered 3/5 of a person.
I could, if I could remember the dates. After a certain (well-defined) point, a zygote becomes a blastocyst, and a blastocyst becomes a fetus.
Also correct. The stage of the fetus, or embryo, is eight weeks until birth.
That's a simple one: when it's no longer siphoning off nutrients and elements for respiration from another organism.
...Depending on whether you breast feed, this could be a year after birth.
Actually, that definition doesn't exclude the idea of humans being parasites. "An association in which one organism (the parasite) lives on (ectoparasitism) or in (endoparasitism) the body of another (the *host), from which obtains its nutrients" can be readily applied to a fetus. Additionally, a fetus can sometimes cause severe detriment to its host; I'm sure I don't have to go inbto the various diseases of pregnancy.
Also, just in case this is the point of your agrument, note that "includes (types of parasites)" does not exclude anything.
As I said, it is possible to use the term ?parasite? that way but it is incorrect as far as modern biology is concerned. Exclusion doesn?t imply inclusion as inclusion doesn?t imply exclusion.
When the term ?parasite? is used in biology it is assumed that the method of survival of the organism during its life cycle is parasitism. That is not the case with Homo sapiens. A dictionary definition and a section from a biology text is revealing.
Parasite 1. an animal or plant that lives on, with, or in another organism or host from which it gets its food, always at the expense of the host. It may or may not injure the host, but it is usually unable to exist independently. Lice, tapeworms, and mistletoe are parasites.
Now, while it doesn?t say explicitly that Homo sapiens isn?t a parasite it does say it implicitly because every example, and the examples by type in the Oxford dictionary of Biology, shows an organism that lives by feeding off its host during the bulk of its life cycle.
I should add that there really isn?t anything wrong with saying that a fetus functions as a parasite because that is beyond a doubt. But there we are again using function to define an organism. Biology defines organisms through many ways but functionality usually isn?t one of them.
Now we can also say that human beings are parasites on their environment. But strictly speaking that isn?t the case either. The proper biological term for that is ?heterotrophic?, which means:
Incapable of manufacturing organic compounds from inorganic raw materials, therefore requiring organic nutrients from the environment.
?There are four main groups of heterotropic organisms: the nonphotosynthetic bacteria, the fungi, the nonphotosynthetic protozoans, and the animals. The first two groups, the bacteria and the fungi, lack digestive systems and hence depend mainly on absorption as their mode of feeding. They are either saprophytic (living and feeding on dead organic matter) or parasitic (living on or in other organisms and feeding on them). By contrast, the principle mode of feeding for animals and protozoans is ingestion-the taking in and digesting of particulate or bulk food. Animals and protozoans may be herbivores, in which case they obtain high-energy compounds by eating plants that have assembled those compounds from raw materials. Or they may be carnivores, in which case they eat other animals or protozoans that have eaten plants. Some animals, the omnivores, need both plant and animal material to survive.?
|