Home | Community | Message Board


This site includes paid links. Please support our sponsors.


Welcome to the Shroomery Message Board! You are experiencing a small sample of what the site has to offer. Please login or register to post messages and view our exclusive members-only content. You'll gain access to additional forums, file attachments, board customizations, encrypted private messages, and much more!

Shop: Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order   Original Sensible Seeds Bulk Cannabis Seeds   Myyco.com Golden Teacher Liquid Culture For Sale   Sporeworks.EU Spores for European Microscopy   North Spore Bulk Substrate

Jump to first unread post Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |  [ show all ]
Re: What do YOU think about abortion? [Re: pachoo]
    #15324712 -

What if you look at it like this? I was an accident. This is a true statement. I was not aborted. I am now here. posting with you people. What if i was aborted? I just would not exist? All the freedoms and positive influences i have had on life thus far would not be true? You could just deny that?

I have had an incredibly sad life. But im here. I like it. Deny me life?

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: What do YOU think about abortion? [Re: dshow]
    #15324725 -

i don't deny you life. i don't want to deny anyone life.

i just can't stop the women who do get an abortion. but i cry like hell if they do.


--------------------


:heartpump::heartpump: :heartpump::heartpump:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: What do YOU think about abortion? [Re: dshow]
    #15324906 -

dshow said:
Right or wrong?

If its freedom of choice for the woman to choose to get an abortion, then doesnt that restrict the freedom of the probable human being that she killing?
:filosoraptor:




Doesn't it also restrict the probability of a future child if instead of getting her life more into a position where she can take care of another person, she is struggling to make a substandard life for herself and an unexpected child?

My position: Having a child, period, in an overpopulated world, is unethical.  To remove the choice from someone to end the life of something less intelligent and conscious than the animals most people willingly and happily cause the death of every day is hypocritical and unconstitutional.  The person who is pregnant is best equipped to determine whether bringing a child into the world under the conditions prescribed by their own life variables would be a cruel act. 

Who is anyone to say they know better than the person who will have to be responsible for that child for two decades minimum?

What if that mother would have developed a cure for cancer or some other major benefit to the world, had she not been able to have an abortion?

Assuming that someone is selfish because they don't want kids, and that their life couldn't possibly benefit the world in a way more valuable than the existence of one additional person, is a biased, ignorant perspective.

To the likely comment of "What if your parents had aborted you?": Clearly I wouldn't care because I wouldn't exist, and my parents' lives may have been happier, more fulfilling, and more impactful as a result.

Things are never as simple as right and wrong.  Think more openly about issues, rather than whining because it's "denying life" when the actions are more far reaching than that.  Remove individual ego from the equation.  How many animals will have to die to support the existence of that child?  What makes the expansion of the human species more entitled to life than other species?  How much will the existence of that child cause food prices to rise, and result in the starvation of other children?  How much pollution will be created as a result of that child's existence?  What if that child grows up to be a douchebag like most people and creates a net loss for society?  What if Hitler had been aborted?

Edited by Pacmanpth (11/05/11 02:04 AM)

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: What do YOU think about abortion? [Re: dshow]
    #15324943 -

There is no one true answer for if it is wrong or not. There are just various subjective viewpoints of individuals.


--------------------
Live your Life! :heart:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: What do YOU think about abortion? [Re: 4896744]
    #15325885 -

Pachoo, no need to regret posting here. You mentioned you are personally opposed to it, as in you couldn't bring yourself to having one due to the reifications you've witnessed. Could you deny someone that right?

Dshow, you were an accident, and you were kept and have probably lead an awesome life, full of joy and beauty. You can't argue the "what if I was aborted" simply due to the fact that if you were, the knowledge that you have now would not have existed. What if you were a stillbirth or got hit by a car and killed when you were 5? Those questions are impossible to answer because the knowledge you've developed since then makes you biased. Take a look at the cattle industry. People are hugely opposed to it. I don't enjoy how the animal is treated, but once it's dead, it doesn't truly matter, cuz now the animal is dead. I'm not saying 5 star resort my hamburger, and they truly can't escort each cow to slaughter, time is money. People are also opposed to the killing of cows, but without the demand for dead cows, these cows would never have been bred, fed, immunized, they just simply would not exist. Kind of like potatoes in your garden. Don't eat potatoes? Probably won plant any will ya! :smile:

True, it's hard to accept taking away any chance of a fetus developing into a child, especially after we've seen what we've seen. Can you see now why religious people want to share their God with others? They've seen His/Her beauty and want the world to. I still dont condone abortion in certain terms, but I can't be the one who denies whether it's right or wrong. When my buddy was almost dead in a coma, would it have been right to pull the plug? To me, no, that's my brother, to someone looking at it practically, possibly. He's since come out of the coma, spinal cord injury and a quad, but he's himself. Had he lost his personality and been brain dead/damaged to the point he didn't know anyone, my ideas of pulling the plug may be different.


--------------------
I challenge you to challenge yourself more! When you feel complacent and ready to hang it up, challenge yourself to get over it! If you fail, don't look at it as you didn't succeed, look at it as you would a rock face you're trying to climb. Stand back, wayyyy back, and look at it and plot another path. If you can't find one, shuffle down the way a little, a little change of scenery or a view from a different angle may give you the insight you need.

Anything I state is relayed information from a friend of a friend and should be viewed as completely fictitious. I do not partake in any illegal or grey-area-of-the-law activities, but do have lots of friends who may or may not.    -fngbronco

Pill Divider Agar Tek

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: What do YOU think about abortion? [Re: fngbronco] * 1
    #15326381 -

fngbronco said:
I don't enjoy how the animal is treated, but once it's dead, it doesn't truly matter, cuz now the animal is dead.



This isn't really true though, in the broader sense.  Choosing not to eat meat reduces the demand for it, and thus has an impact on the meat industry.  It wouldn't exist if people chose not to eat meat (although cows still would for the sake of milk and cheese), and one person choosing to do so still has an economic impact.

I also don't agree with your portrayal of religious people.  People that have "experienced the beauty of God" believe they have found something special that non-religious people haven't experienced.  That is pure arrogance and zealous pompousity, although you are completely correct in the perspective that such people have.  My personal opinion is that removing the power from yourself and giving it to a dogmatic deity is limiting your own experience of reality, and the infinite potential that it holds.  You don't need belief in a deity to experience and live a life of altruism and beauty. 

The rest of your post I agree with, and :thumbup: to your sig.

Edited by Pacmanpth (11/05/11 01:29 PM)

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Abortion [Re: dshow]
    #15327003 -

Auto-Summary
This forum post passionately argues against abortion from a religious perspective, asserting that abortion is morally wrong because it denies objective moral law and denies the inherent value of human life. The author contends that God has established clear moral boundaries, including the prohibition of murder, which includes the killing of unborn children. They argue that freedom is an illusion, as humans are all slaves to various circumstances. The post emphasizes the importance of personal choice, citing safe surrender sites and adoption as alternatives to abortion. The author concludes by urging readers to consider the consequences of their actions and seek forgiveness, while acknowledging their own shortcomings as a non-believer.

dshow said:
Right or wrong?

If its freedom of choice for the woman to choose to get an abortion, then doesnt that restrict the freedom of the probable human being that she killing?
:filosoraptor:


Or since it is not alive, it is not killing?

Throw out some arguments for and against abortion. (your personal opinion)



I don't know how to begin so...48 more posts before I can lurk again...

Alright, now that the beginning is out of the way...abortion is morally wrong.

:filosoraptor:

My proof for abortion being morally wrong:
1) for anything to be morally right or wrong there must be an objective moral law independent of reality.
2) God is The All-Seeing, The All-Hearing, The All-Knowing, The Omnipresent, Witness, The Most Just, and The Bringer of Judgement.
3) God is also The Most Gracious, The Most Wise, and The Much Forgiving.
4) God has declared that murder is wrong, except in the course of justice; and that righteous will not kill their children for fear of poverty because God provides for all.
5) because God provides the conditions for objective morality and has prohibited murdering children abortion is morally wrong.

Admittedly there is a leap of faith required from step 1 to step 2, but without it we are left in a morally relativistic universe where objective Truth and Justice cannot exist.

:filosoraptor:

On your second point: Yes, but freedom is an illusion.

We are all slaves at all times, we just typically have the choice of what we enslave ourselves to. Admittedly my great-great grandfather and his parents for a couple centuries didn't get as much choice in their slavery...but what could you expect from a 5/8th person and the property of another man.

My great grandfather, on the other hand, did not have the handicap of being property yet he enslaved himself to his family and business and worked tirelessly for his master(s). As I only had secondhand, thirdhand, or even fourthhand access to either man I cannot elaborate further on their enslavements.

When my wife got pregnant, our child took away our freedom from parenthood. Furthermore the fetus enslaved my wife for use as his or her own personal monotub. My wife is slave to her mother who is slave to more Pakistani backbiters who are enslaved further by their devils, went to Planned Parenthood and murdered the threat to her master(s). Meanwhile, the world was turning and somewhere between 6 and 7 billion other slaves went about their daily servitude in much the same way slaves have done since the beginning of time.

Although I miss the child I never knew I take comfort in two facts:
1) My child is in heaven because people under 40 are not morally responsible enough to warrant the Hellfire.
2) The only unforgivable sin is idolatry. That is, to take not-God and put it in the place of God is idolatry and it is unforgivable. So should my wife choose to turn away from her atheism and seek forgiveness from The Lord of the Universe, God is Forgiver, Most Merciful.

:filosoraptor:

A fetus is alive.
An embryo is alive.
A zygote is alive.
The sperm and ovum are alive before they fuse and become a zygote.
If you killed any of the above, they would die and be dead.
Yet each and every one of the organisms listed above struggle to maintain their lives in spite of the inevitability of death.
All alive and all fighting for life.

Tell me who, other than God, could bring forth the living from the dead? Certainly not any ordinary man or woman, and if no ordinary person then certainly not a protohuman, or a bird, or a fish, or a insect, or a bug, or a mushroom, or a protist, or even a waterbear.

Quite simply you cannot kill what is not alive.

:filosoraptor:

My personal opinion:

I was an accident, yet my parents chose not to become murderers. I guessed I was an accident as a child, but was told I was planned. When I became an adult I asked again, and I found out the truth.

I have suspicions that because I was an accident I got treated differently, but I don't know. I do know that in the US there are safe surrender sites for unwanted or unplanned for infants. I also know that there are tons of would-be parents out there waiting to adopt. 

So do not neglect, abuse, or murder your children. If you are pregnant or otherwise unexpectedly find yourself a parent please remember you have options.

Although abortion is an option so is adoption.
Although adoption is an option so is parenthood.
Although we always have options, I pray we make the right ones.

My wife says she regrets the abortion. My infant would be old enough to survive outside the womb in an ICU around now, but it was not his or her destiny. Changing diapers was not meant for me yet, if ever.

We do not know the future and tomorrow will always remain a mystery. The unease of pregnancy - physical, mental, and spiritual - is tough. However, the troubles of today may be recalled fondly tomorrow. Don't give up when the going gets tough. Don't murder your children, God provides for them and for you.



PS.
I know I mentioned God a lot, and I don't want it turn anyone away from the message. I know a lot of people that have personal conflicts with organized religion. I have a lot of trouble with organized religion myself.

However I want to stress the fact that without an objective moral law there can only be moral relativism and the plurality of perception renders moral relativism amoral (an evil man may believe himself to be doing good and that his victims are really the evil ones; e.g. abortion clinic bombers, Osama bin Laden, a lot of former Presidents, etc).

[Quran 16:90]
GOD advocates justice, charity, and regarding the relatives. And He forbids evil, vice, and transgression. He enlightens you, that you may take heed.

I wasn't always a believer, and even now I am far from a perfect submitter (muslim in Arabic): I smoke pot, skip daily prayers, skip communal prayers, stare at (but not touch, I am married) the incredibly sexy women at university, take God's name in vain, and overall I find myself inclined towards sin. I am a sinner and if God were not the Most Gracious, Most Merciful I would have no hope.

So be just and charitable, avoid evil and remember that no human can undo what has already been done, but it is never too late to ask forgiveness for whatever we have already done.





PPS.
stands for post-post script. It's a pet peeve of mine when people write PSS. Likewise PPPS (post-post-post-script) would follow PPS.


--------------------
In the name of God, Most Gracious, Most Merciful
Read, in the name of your Lord, who created.
He created man from an embryo.
Read, and your Lord, Most Exalted.
Teaches by means of the pen.
He teaches man what he never knew.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: Psychopharmakos]
    #15327181 -

Psychopharmakos said:
I also know that there are tons of would-be parents out there waiting to adopt. 



i have total respect for your religious faith but can you prove this? because i already proved this is not the case twice so far in this thread... if you scroll up you'll find my posts, if you have problems locating it i'll be glad to repost the information...

Kensho :psychsplit:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: cateyes]
    #15327308 -

cateyes said:
i have total respect for your religious faith but can you prove this? because i already proved this is not the case twice so far in this thread... if you scroll up you'll find my posts, if you have problems locating it i'll be glad to repost the information...

Kensho :psychsplit:



It's not true, if it was there wouldn't be so many orphans/foster children.  If it were true, the debate would be much different, but because so many people choose to willingly have children instead of adopting the economics of adoption end up with more parentless children than adopters.

Personally, I have no respect for people who justify anything but their own lifestyle with religion.  I would, however, defend completely the right for them to believe what they want and their right to talk about it.

Sometimes none of your listed options are options.  Place trust in people to be wise enough with their own lives to recognize when is appropriate to take bold action, but don't strip them of that power when the action they are doing is biologically hardly different than birth control, two different levels of biological life nowhere near the levels of life we are familiar with.  Until it's illegal to kill mature mammals, I don't see it as reasonable to illegalize abortion.  I do think that the time window for the mother to choose should be reconsidered, though.  Better detection and prevention technology could make this a more agreeable goal for people on both sides of the debate.

Edited by Pacmanpth (11/05/11 05:10 PM)

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: cateyes]
    #15327411 -

There are many parents looking to adopt that are on lists cuz the system is fucked up, but like pets from the pound, they want the pups and not the older, messed up ones.

@pacman, it's not it's not arrogant one bit. How many sunrises have you seen you wish you could explain to a blindman in a way he can appreciate the beauty he's never witnessed? Are you arrogant because you find beauty in it? Cuz you can see and talk about it? I'm hugely opposed to organized religion for the simple fact that the sheep follow their Shepard. Look at psychopharm. I'm sure his parents raised him right, where shi'a and Sunni are no different because they share Allah, just with different order of 2 different prophets. Now look at the American view of Muslims, that they're all terrorists, and that all Arabs are Muslims, no need for education and knowledge that one of the oldest catholic schools is in Iraq. That's what lack of education and organized religion brings. (sorry to single you out psychopharm, you're the only religious stance here).

To say something is morally wrong because a books says so totally cuts out the human element and the mind God has given us, if you so believe in a god/cradle. It doesn't matter if the Quran or Bible says it's ok to kill to protect your religious belief if someone threatens your life with their God, truly is it morally correct to kill anyone? For me the answer is yes, for you now, and for someone else, they need more information on why.

Consider this:
A man, roughly 6' tall, 150#, obviously on meth, breaks in to your house where you and your pregnant wife are watching a movie. He runs up and grabs our 2 year old and holds a knife to her throat and demands money. You've got a gun in arms reach in your nightstand drawer and the key in your pocket. Your wife distracts him and you have the gun now, do you a shoot him, B threaten him and tell him to leave.

I would kill him and never think twice about his family or loved ones, he made his bed. Morally I think most would do the same, and other would say "oh that's never gonna happen to me". This abortion discussion is the same theory, it may be a decision we face, it may never. Now I hope I never have to kill anyone to protect myself, but if it happens, it happens.

God truly is not going to judge me by the wrongs I do, but by the rights I do, and not the rights he's written, because when the bible was written, 50 years old was close to being dead. Medicine has replaced miracle. God will judge me by how much of me I sacrifice to make another enjoy their life as much as I enjoy mine. It makes me a better person and it makes them better people, I start a revolution of kindness and good will. Some it dies with, others try to one up me. Does it matter to me what happens after I make myself feel good formmaking someone else feel good? No, the guy could go hang himself, or get into a fight or beat his wife, his decisions are not mine and nothing I do will ever make his choices nor will he make mine.


--------------------
I challenge you to challenge yourself more! When you feel complacent and ready to hang it up, challenge yourself to get over it! If you fail, don't look at it as you didn't succeed, look at it as you would a rock face you're trying to climb. Stand back, wayyyy back, and look at it and plot another path. If you can't find one, shuffle down the way a little, a little change of scenery or a view from a different angle may give you the insight you need.

Anything I state is relayed information from a friend of a friend and should be viewed as completely fictitious. I do not partake in any illegal or grey-area-of-the-law activities, but do have lots of friends who may or may not.    -fngbronco

Pill Divider Agar Tek

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: fngbronco]
    #15327560 -

fngbronco said:
There are many parents looking to adopt that are on lists cuz the system is fucked up, but like pets from the pound, they want the pups and not the older, messed up ones.



when i first read this comment, i was skeptical at first considering the statistics on one year and under children in foster care... so i did a search and found no information from government agencies but i also found that these government agencies are not required to provide these statistics on adoption... now i immediately thought, "how fucked up is this?" so i modified my search and found about a half a dozen sites and all of them estimated that parents waiting to adopt is roughly two million! that totally blew my mind... government bureaucracy is out of control... i still feel a woman has the right to choose but i have a better idea where the pro-life are coming from... something needs to be done about this, quickly... thanks for the heads up... it's always good to learn something new, even if it is distressing! :smile:

Kensho :psychsplit:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: cateyes]
    #15327639 -

Yeah, and the shittiest part is most are capable, good candidates. It's quicker and more fulfilling to adopt a kid from overseas anyways. China is a big one cuz people there don't want girls, but they forget about our local kids. I think Americans as a race are generally disgruntled and shitty lol whereas a little china girl would be super happy to be given a change to live here. That previous sentence is to be read in the most smug yuppie voice you can muster :smile:

My buddy has a son that was adopted, it's cool cuz the adoptive parents let him see his son and shit and buy gifts, as well as keep contact and send my buddy pictures.


--------------------
I challenge you to challenge yourself more! When you feel complacent and ready to hang it up, challenge yourself to get over it! If you fail, don't look at it as you didn't succeed, look at it as you would a rock face you're trying to climb. Stand back, wayyyy back, and look at it and plot another path. If you can't find one, shuffle down the way a little, a little change of scenery or a view from a different angle may give you the insight you need.

Anything I state is relayed information from a friend of a friend and should be viewed as completely fictitious. I do not partake in any illegal or grey-area-of-the-law activities, but do have lots of friends who may or may not.    -fngbronco

Pill Divider Agar Tek

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: Psychopharmakos]
    #15327765 -

Psychopharmakos said:
dshow said:
Right or wrong?

If its freedom of choice for the woman to choose to get an abortion, then doesnt that restrict the freedom of the probable human being that she killing?
:filosoraptor:


Or since it is not alive, it is not killing?

Throw out some arguments for and against abortion. (your personal opinion)



I don't know how to begin so...48 more posts before I can lurk again...

Alright, now that the beginning is out of the way...abortion is morally wrong.

:filosoraptor:

My proof for abortion being morally wrong:
1) for anything to be morally right or wrong there must be an objective moral law independent of reality.
2) God is The All-Seeing, The All-Hearing, The All-Knowing, The Omnipresent, Witness, The Most Just, and The Bringer of Judgement.
3) God is also The Most Gracious, The Most Wise, and The Much Forgiving.
4) God has declared that murder is wrong, except in the course of justice; and that righteous will not kill their children for fear of poverty because God provides for all.
5) because God provides the conditions for objective morality and has prohibited murdering children abortion is morally wrong.

Admittedly there is a leap of faith required from step 1 to step 2, but without it we are left in a morally relativistic universe where objective Truth and Justice cannot exist.

:filosoraptor:

On your second point: Yes, but freedom is an illusion.

We are all slaves at all times, we just typically have the choice of what we enslave ourselves to. Admittedly my great-great grandfather and his parents for a couple centuries didn't get as much choice in their slavery...but what could you expect from a 5/8th person and the property of another man.

My great grandfather, on the other hand, did not have the handicap of being property yet he enslaved himself to his family and business and worked tirelessly for his master(s). As I only had secondhand, thirdhand, or even fourthhand access to either man I cannot elaborate further on their enslavements.

When my wife got pregnant, our child took away our freedom from parenthood. Furthermore the fetus enslaved my wife for use as his or her own personal monotub. My wife is slave to her mother who is slave to more Pakistani backbiters who are enslaved further by their devils, went to Planned Parenthood and murdered the threat to her master(s). Meanwhile, the world was turning and somewhere between 6 and 7 billion other slaves went about their daily servitude in much the same way slaves have done since the beginning of time.

Although I miss the child I never knew I take comfort in two facts:
1) My child is in heaven because people under 40 are not morally responsible enough to warrant the Hellfire.
2) The only unforgivable sin is idolatry. That is, to take not-God and put it in the place of God is idolatry and it is unforgivable. So should my wife choose to turn away from her atheism and seek forgiveness from The Lord of the Universe, God is Forgiver, Most Merciful.

:filosoraptor:

A fetus is alive.
An embryo is alive.
A zygote is alive.
The sperm and ovum are alive before they fuse and become a zygote.
If you killed any of the above, they would die and be dead.
Yet each and every one of the organisms listed above struggle to maintain their lives in spite of the inevitability of death.
All alive and all fighting for life.

Tell me who, other than God, could bring forth the living from the dead? Certainly not any ordinary man or woman, and if no ordinary person then certainly not a protohuman, or a bird, or a fish, or a insect, or a bug, or a mushroom, or a protist, or even a waterbear.




1. in objectivity, there is no right or wrong. morality is purely subjective. There can be no objective morality. You can try and give me any possible scenario of what you believe is ultimate evil, and I will present you with a scenario in which that evil can be considered a good thing.
2. is just gibberish.
3. is some related addendum to the previous gibberish.
4. again, you define justice like it is objective. justice is objective.
5. here you have attempted to consecrate your delusion of gods law as being objective and real. nothing of what you state is anything other than subjective opinion. you preach Jainism, yet you probably dont even know what that is, because if you did, you would see how ludicrous it is. every day you willingly kill thousands of living things. do you masturbate? how many sperm have you slaughtered?

you are trying to debate facts with your belief that you have turned your own delusions into objective, salient points. You havent.
everything you have stated so far, is anecdotal at best. so I counter your argument with my own fantasy..... lets see: how about my left nut.
1. my left nut has laid forth all morality.
2. my left nut is all seeing, all knowing.
3. my left nut is great.
4. my left nut has stated that abortion is ok for any reason because my left nut has plenty of sperm.
5. because my left nut has stated this, it is ok for anyone to have an abortion.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: fngbronco]
    #15327829 -

fngbronco said:
There are many parents looking to adopt that are on lists cuz the system is fucked up, but like pets from the pound, they want the pups and not the older, messed up ones.

@pacman, it's not it's not arrogant one bit. How many sunrises have you seen you wish you could explain to a blindman in a way he can appreciate the beauty he's never witnessed? Are you arrogant because you find beauty in it? Cuz you can see and talk about it?



I'd be arrogant to assume that the blindman couldn't see just as much beauty in life that I could.  It's the perspective of pity towards a disabled person that's arrogant, as if their life couldn't ever amount to anything as beautiful as someone without disability.  A blindman may very well see much more than you or I, you should try sensory deprivation if you haven't done it before, and perhaps you'll understand what I mean.  Look at what Stephen Hawking has done for the scientific community from the confines of a wheelchair.  Anyone assuming that their life is better than someone elses and that they have found some ultimate truth that other people need to hear, accept, and experience is narcissistic lunacy.  We all come from widely different backgrounds and experiences, and our perspectives and perceptions are widely different as a result, assuming that one is superior and more true or beautiful than another misses the fact that that religious believers have no inherent reason why their perspective is "more correct".  I'd never dream of preaching atheism as the true path that everyone should take, yet believers of dogmatic religions at every turn think it's perfectly acceptable to shove Jesus and God down peoples' throats whenever they need backup to prove a point, or feel like telling you how you can "fix" your life, which of course is sinful and broken to them.

Edited by Pacmanpth (11/05/11 07:39 PM)

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: Pacmanpth]
    #15327921 -

See my perspective is that I'm not seeing more, or better things, but offering a different perspective, as we are doing now :wink: you're right we've all had different experiences that help us develop into who we are and what we believe. I look at things, not as "oh he's one-upping me", or "how do they think that's the way", but rather someone sharing their life or interpretation. If you and your friend went to watch a movie and you sat way up front and he sat way in the back, you've seen the same movie still. Now add in that you're way unlucky and fat stinky bitch with her noisy 4 kids come and sit next to you, and your buddy had some super hot chick and her girl friends sit next to him. You both loved the movie and the locations you sat in was by choice, but when telling the story of how you liked your experience, I'm sure the stories would differ. Shit you could sit with your gf and watch a sunset, and your favorite part may be the way the fire red clashes with the encroaching darkness in the east where most people wouldn't look, her's could be that she's there with you.

It seems like you view the world as everyone is trying to force their views down your throat, when that may not be the case. I love listening to people's views on god and their experiences, I hate the wrote memory, Holy Book quoting bullshit. I definitely prefer hearing people's ideas and experiences, something they developed, a part of them they can share.


--------------------
I challenge you to challenge yourself more! When you feel complacent and ready to hang it up, challenge yourself to get over it! If you fail, don't look at it as you didn't succeed, look at it as you would a rock face you're trying to climb. Stand back, wayyyy back, and look at it and plot another path. If you can't find one, shuffle down the way a little, a little change of scenery or a view from a different angle may give you the insight you need.

Anything I state is relayed information from a friend of a friend and should be viewed as completely fictitious. I do not partake in any illegal or grey-area-of-the-law activities, but do have lots of friends who may or may not.    -fngbronco

Pill Divider Agar Tek

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: fngbronco]
    #15327932 -

Auto-Summary
This forum thread delves into the complex issue of abortion, focusing on the inherent human desire for pleasure and avoidance of pain. The author references iThink's perspective that opposing abortion stems from pleasure-seeking behavior. They then share a hypothetical scenario of protecting a family from a dangerous intruder, drawing parallels to the moral dilemma of abortion. The author argues that the only way to make morally sound decisions is through objective moral principles, asserting that reliance on religious texts alone neglects the human element. They also touch on the potential dangers of blindly accepting information without critical thinking, referencing Quranic verses emphasizing the importance of using one's hearing, eyesight, and brain. The author concludes by expressing hope that none of them will face such a harrowing choice, while acknowledging the complexity of the topic.

I read through the whole thread cateyes and I would be interested in reading the article you originally mentioned anyway. If you care to link?

I think iThink said it best:
iThink said:
The only reason to appose abortion is because you adhere to a set of ideals that give you some sense of pleasure or satisfaction which guide you to view abortion as wrong.



it's the reason anyone does anything. We all seek pleasure and seek to avoid pain. As cognitive dissonance can be rather unpleasant we seek to avoid it by standing up for our beliefs. It's just the nature of things even mice do it.


fngbronco said:
There are many parents looking to adopt that are on lists cuz the system is fucked up, but like pets from the pound, they want the pups and not the older, messed up ones.

@pacman, it's not it's not arrogant one bit. How many sunrises have you seen you wish you could explain to a blindman in a way he can appreciate the beauty he's never witnessed? Are you arrogant because you find beauty in it? Cuz you can see and talk about it? I'm hugely opposed to organized religion for the simple fact that the sheep follow their Shepard. Look at psychopharm. I'm sure his parents raised him right, where shi'a and Sunni are no different because they share Allah, just with different order of 2 different prophets. Now look at the American view of Muslims, that they're all terrorists, and that all Arabs are Muslims, no need for education and knowledge that one of the oldest catholic schools is in Iraq. That's what lack of education and organized religion brings. (sorry to single you out psychopharm, you're the only religious stance here).

To say something is morally wrong because a books says so totally cuts out the human element and the mind God has given us, if you so believe in a god/cradle. It doesn't matter if the Quran or Bible says it's ok to kill to protect your religious belief if someone threatens your life with their God, truly is it morally correct to kill anyone? For me the answer is yes, for you now, and for someone else, they need more information on why.

Consider this:
A man, roughly 6' tall, 150#, obviously on meth, breaks in to your house where you and your pregnant wife are watching a movie. He runs up and grabs our 2 year old and holds a knife to her throat and demands money. You've got a gun in arms reach in your nightstand drawer and the key in your pocket. Your wife distracts him and you have the gun now, do you a shoot him, B threaten him and tell him to leave.

I would kill him and never think twice about his family or loved ones, he made his bed. Morally I think most would do the same, and other would say "oh that's never gonna happen to me". This abortion discussion is the same theory, it may be a decision we face, it may never. Now I hope I never have to kill anyone to protect myself, but if it happens, it happens.

God truly is not going to judge me by the wrongs I do, but by the rights I do, and not the rights he's written, because when the bible was written, 50 years old was close to being dead. Medicine has replaced miracle. God will judge me by how much of me I sacrifice to make another enjoy their life as much as I enjoy mine. It makes me a better person and it makes them better people, I start a revolution of kindness and good will. Some it dies with, others try to one up me. Does it matter to me what happens after I make myself feel good formmaking someone else feel good? No, the guy could go hang himself, or get into a fight or beat his wife, his decisions are not mine and nothing I do will ever make his choices nor will he make mine.





I don't want to be perceived as arrogant...I just recognize that there is no point arguing morality without an objective moral source...I also have no intent of forcing my religious beliefs on anyone. In Sura 109 God grants freedom of religion. It angers me that the state is so ignorantly mixed up in religion.


fngbronco, I take absolutely no offense. In fact I agree with your point that organized religion can get people to turn off their brains and be swayed by the words of the ignorant.

It's why God reminds us to appreciate our brains and not accept info willy nilly:

[Quran 16:78] GOD brought you out of your mothers' bellies knowing nothing, and He gave you the hearing, the eyesight, and the brains, that you may be appreciative.
[Quran 17:36] You shall not accept any information, unless you verify it for yourself. I have given you the hearing, the eyesight, and the brain, and you are responsible for using them.
[Quran 23:78] He is the One who granted you the hearing, the eyesight, and the brains. Rarely are you appreciative.

I also agree that the Bible (Torah + New Testament) is kinda out-of-date.

Jeremiah 8:8
"'How can you say, "We are wise, for we have the law of the LORD," when actually the lying pen of the scribes has handled it falsely?

The Bible still contains guidance and wisdom (remember the Golden Rule?) but it was updated and superseded a little over 14 hundred years ago when God sent the Quran. In Sura 15 ayat 9 God promised to preserve the Quran...so no more trouble like Jeremiah had with Judah.

I also agree that I hope none of us have to make the choice of whether or not to shoot the meth addict that holds our child hostage. I however am less confident in my ability to shoot the "bad guy" ("bad guy" is police terminology) without harming my child. I read somewhere that unless you shoot the hostage taker in a specific spot in the brain the muscle spasms from death would cause the hostage taker to harm the hostage...but I can't find out where I read that...

Anywoo...

PS.
I'm a convert to Islam, my parent's religion is Roman Catholic.


--------------------
In the name of God, Most Gracious, Most Merciful
Read, in the name of your Lord, who created.
He created man from an embryo.
Read, and your Lord, Most Exalted.
Teaches by means of the pen.
He teaches man what he never knew.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: SneezingPenis]
    #15327971 -

SneezingPenis said:
1. in objectivity, there is no right or wrong. morality is purely subjective. There can be no objective morality. You can try and give me any possible scenario of what you believe is ultimate evil, and I will present you with a scenario in which that evil can be considered a good thing.
2. is just gibberish.
3. is some related addendum to the previous gibberish.
4. again, you define justice like it is objective. justice is objective.
5. here you have attempted to consecrate your delusion of gods law as being objective and real. nothing of what you state is anything other than subjective opinion. you preach Jainism, yet you probably dont even know what that is, because if you did, you would see how ludicrous it is. every day you willingly kill thousands of living things. do you masturbate? how many sperm have you slaughtered?

you are trying to debate facts with your belief that you have turned your own delusions into objective, salient points. You havent.
everything you have stated so far, is anecdotal at best. so I counter your argument with my own fantasy..... lets see: how about my left nut.
1. my left nut has laid forth all morality.
2. my left nut is all seeing, all knowing.
3. my left nut is great.
4. my left nut has stated that abortion is ok for any reason because my left nut has plenty of sperm.
5. because my left nut has stated this, it is ok for anyone to have an abortion.



I am on the Jaina mailing list. I'm waiting for next year's calendar. The temple artwork calendar they sent last year was amazing. Jainism isn't ludicrous it has a long history of intellectual thought and influence:
Civil Rights -> Martin Luther King Jr. -> Ghandi -> Ghandi's Jain Friend -> Jainism
However that example glosses over the work of the thousands of others of varied races that worked to bring about Civil Rights...but that would be especially off topic.

As the entire premise of my argument rests on there being an objective morality. If objective morality does not exist there is no God and no point into arguing morals.

As your left nut was unaware of my knowledge of Jainism I counter that your nut is a pretender to Godhood and unworthy of any adoration. Meanwhile, my Lord your Lord the Lord of the Universe will be praised forever.



I'm not concerned with ultimate evil so much as avoiding hell. Those in hell are not leaving hell. Hell is hopelessness, and that is a definitional statement. As I have been through more trouble and pain in my short years that many people wait 80+ years to experience, I know that a place of hopeless suffering is to be avoided.


--------------------
In the name of God, Most Gracious, Most Merciful
Read, in the name of your Lord, who created.
He created man from an embryo.
Read, and your Lord, Most Exalted.
Teaches by means of the pen.
He teaches man what he never knew.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: fngbronco]
    #15327973 -

fngbronco said:
It seems like you view the world as everyone is trying to force their views down your throat, when that may not be the case. I love listening to people's views on god and their experiences, I hate the wrote memory, Holy Book quoting bullshit. I definitely prefer hearing people's ideas and experiences, something they developed, a part of them they can share.



I very much enjoy hearing people's experiences, and have no problem when they talk openly to me about their personal beliefs and how it has been important in their course of life.  It's just that it's common for people, religious people in particular, to think that they have seen some special light that you haven't, and you are lesser because of that.  Using it as inspiration is fine, but I can't take it seriously as justification for social issues.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: Pacmanpth]
    #15328041 -

I agree that religion is not justification for public health issues, Pacmanpth. It would be wrong to make cameras illegal because some indigenous religions believe that snapping photos steals your soul. It is wrong that there are silly laws on the books that keep people from practicing their religions (Mushrooms, Chacruna, and Peyote ceremonies immediately spring to mind). I stand by my statement that abortion is morally wrong, but I don't think it should be illegal.


--------------------
In the name of God, Most Gracious, Most Merciful
Read, in the name of your Lord, who created.
He created man from an embryo.
Read, and your Lord, Most Exalted.
Teaches by means of the pen.
He teaches man what he never knew.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Abortion [Re: Psychopharmakos]
    #15328110 -

Psychopharmakos said:
I read through the whole thread cateyes and I would be interested in reading the article you originally mentioned anyway. If you care to link?



fngbronco provided me with some information... i did some research and i did a search and found no information from government agencies but i also found that these government agencies are not required to provide these statistics on adoption... i modified my search and found about a half a dozen sites and all of them estimated that parents waiting to adopt is roughly two million! that totally blew my mind... you were right... please forgive me...

Kensho :psychsplit:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Jump to top Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |  [ show all ]

Shop: Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order   Original Sensible Seeds Bulk Cannabis Seeds   Myyco.com Golden Teacher Liquid Culture For Sale   Sporeworks.EU Spores for European Microscopy   North Spore Bulk Substrate


Similar ThreadsPosterViewsRepliesLast post
* abortion-is it likely a fetus can survive? Anonymous 588 6 01/27/09 05:29 PM
by _pe AC e
* E and pregnancy????? n_tara 1,186 9 06/14/06 03:58 AM
by GoaM
* She might be pregnant Anonymous 1,129 14 01/17/08 04:30 PM
by gluke bastid
* Pregnant girlfriend - how much do we tell our doctor?
( 1 2 3 all )
Anonymous 3,495 58 08/10/09 07:35 AM
by trendal
* Girlfriend = Pregnant Mushie_Man 1,688 14 08/01/06 09:06 AM
by trunksan
* Exercise for my pregnant fiance Lucid_Euphoria 544 2 03/07/10 12:37 AM
by PDU
* :)
( 1 2 all )
Anonymous 1,798 22 03/25/08 02:05 PM
by adrug
* It's commonly accepted that drugs and pregnancy don't mix, right?
( 1 2 all )
Visionary Tools 3,580 26 09/27/08 11:42 PM
by esencias

Extra information
You cannot start new topics / You cannot reply to topics
HTML is disabled / BBCode is enabled
Moderator: CherryBom, Asante, Rose, mndfreeze, yogabunny, feevers, CookieCrumbs, Northerner
4,232 topic views. 0 members, 2 guests and 5 web crawlers are browsing this forum.
[ Show Images Only | Sort by Score | Print Topic ]
Search this thread:

Copyright 1997-2026 Mind Media. Some rights reserved.

Generated in 0.041 seconds spending 0.015 seconds on 21 queries.