Rahz said: An ultimate source would be the original catalyst in a closed system.
What is that? This doesn't seem to be common language or terms so I really think my confusion here is reasonable. Id on't understand what your talking about.
Quote: The question is not whether causation exists or not, but within the observance of cause, are we seeing the whole picture?
Ok, then I misunderstood your post. Of course we don't see the whole picture. None amongst us are omniscient and there exists a fundamental imprecision to our observations. This seems quite a simple matter.
Quote: I don't think we can technically see the whole picture. The stratification of cause can be seen in the domino example. The mind moves the hand which moves the 1st, 2nd, and then third domino. The second domino caused the third to fall, but the first domino, as well as everything before can also be said to have caused the consequential action which causes the 3rd to fall. So it would be appropriate to ask upon entering the room "Who caused my dominoes to fall"? An interesting response might be "I swear I only knocked one over".
It is plain that if you knock over the first domino you cause the rest to fall. This is easily verifiable. I don't get where your going with these observations: that a plurality of causes exists doesn't seem to be problematic or unexpected.
Quote: If we look at the universe, it can be seen through individual elements, or as a whole, that what is happening is a chain of cause and effect, yet there doesn't seem to be a beginning to the chain. This is where momentum comes in. If momentum is conserved, it was also being conserved yesterday, and last week, and at any point in the past. It suggests that the past is infinite, and thus it is impossible to trace a cause back to an initial source. In this way, the initial source would be considered the 'true cause' of an event, if it existed.
How does this suggest the past is infinite or that there was no start? If we imagine a close system with two plates between some reactive matter, we can observe that the momentum of the bodies is 0 at the start if they aren't moving at t=0. If the reactive matter starts reacting it may liberate gas which pushes the plates over. Despite their being 0 momentum of the bodies at the start, there are several bodies with nonzero momentum at t>0. You seem to suggest this is impossible, but you can easily verify this experiment. Doesn't this suggest your interpretation is wrong? Its plain to see that the momentum of various bodies in the system exists despite conservation and a discrete starting point.
Quote: I'm saying there is no final/ultimate source as the cause of all things (or anything). Therefore, ultimately nothing is causing anything.
I don't think you've clearly shown how anything suggests this. As discussed above, that items have momentum is not at all incompatible with a starting point.
Quote: A soldier is shot in the head. What caused that to happen? The bullet? The gun, the man, the platoon, the commander, the general, the president? All of them? And what caused the president to give the order? Circumstances which evolved from the past? It all funnels back towards what might be mistaken to be an ultimate source. But if time is infinite, the funnel goes on forever and there is no ultimate source.
Mathmatically this is not true. An infinite set, such as time, may have a discrete starting point.
As for the question of what caused it, all those things seem to be correct answers. In court the cause is generall defined by common law to be of a particular type, generally the non-justified proximate cause. Due to the specific nature of the cause at issue in that scenario, I don't believe it is particularly useful for an inquiry into the more general question of cause, per se. If the person would not have killed the guy but for his wife bitching at him and making him late for work, the bitching wife would indeed have been a cause but not an act liable for murder as the reasonable person would not have understood the result to be possible from that conduct.
Besides, courts rules often have little to do with logic anyways
Therefore, there is no ultimate cause for anything. As all causes are dependent on previous causes, a single cause can not be said to be THE cause for anything. This remains true at any point in time, to my understanding.
|