Home | Community | Message Board

PlanetSpores.ca
This site includes paid links. Please support our sponsors.


Welcome to the Shroomery Message Board! You are experiencing a small sample of what the site has to offer. Please login or register to post messages and view our exclusive members-only content. You'll gain access to additional forums, file attachments, board customizations, encrypted private messages, and much more!

Shop: Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order   North Spore Bulk Substrate

Jump to first unread post Pages: 1 | 2 |  [ show all ]
Causation. Is it what it appears to be?
    #14699031 -

I'm a fan of causality because it makes a lot of sense and is simple. However, it can also be argued logically, that nothing is causing anything. Consider a row of dominos, and the question of what caused the third domino to fall. Is it the second domino? The hand? The mind? The circumstances? It could be stated that it's valid to see the 2nd domino as a cause, but cause could be traced to the hand as a more ultimate causative agent. Still yet, the workings of causation do not start or stop with us, so where does it start?

Laws of nature as I understand them indicate that there has always been momentum. There was never a time when something definitive caused everything or anything else. Does this mean that nothing is truly causing anything to happen?

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Rahz]
    #14699070 -

Rahz said:
I'm a fan of causality because it makes a lot of sense and is simple. However, it can also be argued logically, that nothing is causing anything. Consider a row of dominos, and the question of what caused the third domino to fall. Is it the second domino? The hand? The mind? The circumstances? It could be stated that it's valid to see the 2nd domino as a cause, but cause could be traced to the hand as a more ultimate causative agent. Still yet, the workings of causation do not start or stop with us, so where does it start?

Laws of nature as I understand them indicate that there has always been momentum. There was never a time when something definitive caused everything or anything else. Does this mean that nothing is truly causing anything to happen?



No, everything is causing nothing to happen.  I have no idea what that possibly means but it sounds deep.


--------------------
Anxiety is what you make it.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: LunarEclipse]
    #14700418 -

The singularity at the beginning of existence is the cause of all events, the rules of causality did not apply to it so it did not need a cause, or perhaps it was caused by something outside of itself, a temporal anomaly.


--------------------
He who attains his ideal by that very fact transcends it


To the mind that is still, the whole universe surrenders


Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: LunarEclipse]
    #14700649 -

LunarEclipse said:
Rahz said:
I'm a fan of causality because it makes a lot of sense and is simple. However, it can also be argued logically, that nothing is causing anything. Consider a row of dominos, and the question of what caused the third domino to fall. Is it the second domino? The hand? The mind? The circumstances? It could be stated that it's valid to see the 2nd domino as a cause, but cause could be traced to the hand as a more ultimate causative agent. Still yet, the workings of causation do not start or stop with us, so where does it start?

Laws of nature as I understand them indicate that there has always been momentum. There was never a time when something definitive caused everything or anything else. Does this mean that nothing is truly causing anything to happen?



No, everything is causing nothing to happen.  I have no idea what that possibly means but it sounds deep.




Fuck that does sound deep. We may have to "promote" you to the Mystery forum.


--------------------
"Don't believe everything you think". -Anom.

" All that lives was born to die"-Anom.

With much wisdom comes much sorrow,
The more knowledge, the more grief.
Ecclesiastes circa 350 BC

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Ziggy-Shr00mdust]
    #14701750 -

Ziggy-Shr00mdust said:
The singularity at the beginning of existence is the cause of all events, the rules of causality did not apply to it so it did not need a cause, or perhaps it was caused by something outside of itself, a temporal anomaly.



Perhaps it was caused by something outside (or inside) itself because an ultimate beginning of existence makes no sense.

This idea rarely comes up, so I thought it would get more replies. Basically, the Big Bang is meaningless in the scope of existence unless it can be shown how the laws of physics can be born from an absolute void. The Big Band is a replacement religion, complete with a mystical foundation. The fact that it is mystic isn't the problem, but if it contradicts what we know about momentum and causation, then the belief that 'existence' started with it seems like crap to me.

This leaves the logical conclusion that there never was a beginning, and therefore nothing is the cause of anything that happens. Is it the 2nd domino that causes the third to fall? The hand? Or nothing at all?

Is everything happening of it's own accord?


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Rahz]
    #14701975 -

I can't be entirely sure but I believe that the big bang theory only accounts for the creation of the universe, not of all existence.

The key element in wrapping your head around this concept is to understand that time doesn't work the way we perceive it; if you could stand outside of all existence and simply observe it, you would not see events happening in succession, but rather all points in space and time simultaneously.


--------------------
He who attains his ideal by that very fact transcends it


To the mind that is still, the whole universe surrenders


Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Ziggy-Shr00mdust]
    #14702006 -

maybe if you find something to do, you`ll stop thinking about dumb shit.


--------------------
There are 2 types of people, mycophobes and mycophiles R.Wasson

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Rahz]
    #14702017 -

Rahz said:
I'm a fan of causality because it makes a lot of sense and is simple. However, it can also be argued logically, that nothing is causing anything. Consider a row of dominos, and the question of what caused the third domino to fall. Is it the second domino? The hand? The mind? The circumstances? It could be stated that it's valid to see the 2nd domino as a cause, but cause could be traced to the hand as a more ultimate causative agent. Still yet, the workings of causation do not start or stop with us, so where does it start?



You have implicitly postured your question such that there is a singular cause but this is not presumed in the premise nor proven, so this needs to be addressed before your question can have any validity.

It seems you feel there's some conflict between all those different things being demonstrable causes, but you don't show how such conflict exists.

What do you define "where it starts" to be?  It isn't clear what you are asking particularly, so I don't believe an answer can be provided.

Quote:
Laws of nature as I understand them indicate that there has always been momentum. There was never a time when something definitive caused everything or anything else.




How does that follow?

Anyways, momentum is conserved, yes.

Quote:
Does this mean that nothing is truly causing anything to happen?





Obviously not since we can prove causal relationships.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: johnm214]
    #14702585 -

Quote:
You have implicitly postured your question such that there is a singular cause but this is not presumed in the premise nor proven, so this needs to be addressed before your question can have any validity.



I provided an example to show that the hand could be considered the singular cause, but the hand is a product of cause as well, so I'm not suggesting a singular cause. The question is basically, where does the momentum to knock down the third domino start/come from? Is there an ultimate source? If there is no ultimate source, then as weird as it sounds, the most logical statement would seem to be that ultimately nothing is causing the domino to fall.

Quote:
How does that follow?

Anyways, momentum is conserved, yes.



If momentum is conserved, then it also always was conserved. There is no identifiable point in which momentum wouldn't have existed. In response to the question of what caused momentum, according to the laws of momentum, nothing can cause momentum.

Quote:
Obviously not since we can prove causal relationships.




Yes, but in the example I provided, it is shown that a causal relationship is preceded by a cause, and on infinium. Because of this, a causal relationship can only be partially established, as the beginning is always open ended. This leads to the conclusion that no thing is causing every thing to occur.

Let me know if the concept is unclear, or if my logic is wrong. It's a simple concept, so if the concept is understood we can talk about what possible holes there are in it.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Rahz]
    #14703286 -

Rahz said:
Quote:
You have implicitly postured your question such that there is a singular cause but this is not presumed in the premise nor proven, so this needs to be addressed before your question can have any validity.



I provided an example to show that the hand could be considered the singular cause, but the hand is a product of cause as well, so I'm not suggesting a singular cause. The question is basically, where does the momentum to knock down the third domino start/come from? Is there an ultimate source? If there is no ultimate source, then as weird as it sounds, the most logical statement would seem to be that ultimately nothing is causing the domino to fall.

Quote:
How does that follow?

Anyways, momentum is conserved, yes.



If momentum is conserved, then it also always was conserved. There is no identifiable point in which momentum wouldn't have existed. In response to the question of what caused momentum, according to the laws of momentum, nothing can cause momentum.

Quote:
Obviously not since we can prove causal relationships.




Yes, but in the example I provided, it is shown that a causal relationship is preceded by a cause, and on infinium. Because of this, a causal relationship can only be partially established, as the beginning is always open ended. This leads to the conclusion that no thing is causing every thing to occur.

Let me know if the concept is unclear, or if my logic is wrong. It's a simple concept, so if the concept is understood we can talk about what possible holes there are in it.



:congrats:

My question that follows this is; could it be then, forward with what you show that everything is a cause and we are just witnessers in a causal slurry of matter?

Still, do recognize that this is purely subjective and although you are right about no one being a first cause to anything, you are still just a part of a causal slurry and you will react; like say for example, a guy punches you in the face. Even though you know he is not the first cause, you will still react to protect yourself, because thats what the universe intrinsically and mechanically expresses, cause and effect.


--------------------
if you ever feel lost, just remember, life is not a journey, it is entertainment, all 4 fun...


Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: AlphaFalfa]
    #14703386 -

I don't know if it is all subjective or not, but I haven't suggested that we as humans can step outside the stream/slurry of cause so no beef there... although the concept of non-reaction does create an interesting line of thought.

I guess a causal slurry is a good description:thumbup:, though I don't want to suggest I've wrapped my mind around it all. It seems bizzare to me... Not that I'm disturbed or anything. Just saying, it's a very odd thing to consider. Everything as a cause, and things being their own cause is an interesting angle, though the more the concept is refined, the more it seems to conflict with the laws that brought the concept into being. :confused:


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Icelander]
    #14705259 -

Icelander said:
LunarEclipse said:
Rahz said:
I'm a fan of causality because it makes a lot of sense and is simple. However, it can also be argued logically, that nothing is causing anything. Consider a row of dominos, and the question of what caused the third domino to fall. Is it the second domino? The hand? The mind? The circumstances? It could be stated that it's valid to see the 2nd domino as a cause, but cause could be traced to the hand as a more ultimate causative agent. Still yet, the workings of causation do not start or stop with us, so where does it start?

Laws of nature as I understand them indicate that there has always been momentum. There was never a time when something definitive caused everything or anything else. Does this mean that nothing is truly causing anything to happen?



No, everything is causing nothing to happen.  I have no idea what that possibly means but it sounds deep.




Fuck that does sound deep. We may have to "promote" you to the Mystery forum.



I am the King of Nothing.  Where's my Crown?



--------------------
Anxiety is what you make it.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Rahz]
    #14706730 -

Rahz said:
I don't know if it is all subjective or not, but I haven't suggested that we as humans can step outside the stream/slurry of cause so no beef there... although the concept of non-reaction does create an interesting line of thought.

I guess a causal slurry is a good description:thumbup:, though I don't want to suggest I've wrapped my mind around it all. It seems bizzare to me... Not that I'm disturbed or anything. Just saying, it's a very odd thing to consider. Everything as a cause, and things being their own cause is an interesting angle, though the more the concept is refined, the more it seems to conflict with the laws that brought the concept into being. :confused:




It is hard to recognize this because socially we have been brought up to believe in causality.

So we know deep down that our social interactions will change from this and we struggle against it.

I like to gasp at this type of stuff every once in a while, being a slurry of causality. It's really cool to see that as it makes life seem so simple.....

Anyways g2g swim.


--------------------
if you ever feel lost, just remember, life is not a journey, it is entertainment, all 4 fun...


Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Rahz]
    #14706928 -

Rahz said:
The question is basically, where does the momentum to knock down the third domino start/come from? Is there an ultimate source? If there is no ultimate source, then as weird as it sounds, the most logical statement would seem to be that ultimately nothing is causing the domino to fall.



the momentum is transfered from the thing that physically contacted the third domino- it appears this is the second domino in your example.  Momentum is conserved, as we agree, so it came from whatever accelerated the item in question. 

What are you defining as "an ultimate source" and what does that have to do with whether causation exists in this example or in others?

Quote:
Quote:
How does that follow?

Anyways, momentum is conserved, yes.



If momentum is conserved, then it also always was conserved. There is no identifiable point in which momentum wouldn't have existed. In response to the question of what caused momentum, according to the laws of momentum, nothing can cause momentum.



How do you conclude "nothing can cause momentum" from the conservation of momentum and what precisely are you asserting this statement to mean?  It isn't clear what your point is here.

Momentum exists because it is a fundamental property of matter.  I don't understand what you mean when you speak of something "causing momentum".  As there is no obvious way momentum could not exist per its definition, the concept of 'causing it" seems undefinable.  What do you mean by this and how do you reconcile my observations?


Quote:
Quote:
Obviously not since we can prove causal relationships.




Yes, but in the example I provided, it is shown that a causal relationship is preceded by a cause, and on infinium. Because of this, a causal relationship can only be partially established, as the beginning is always open ended.



How does that follow?  You've declared a causal relationship to be only partially established and claim this is known or due to the, arguendo, infinite precedent causes, but you do not say how the former is a conseuqnece of the later?

What does the existance of other causes have to do with whether a particular cause exists or is valid or whatever?  You don't seem to have explained this.

Quote:
This leads to the conclusion that no thing is causing every thing to occur.



How can you have a causal relationship between two sets with "nothing" as the cause?  It seems the very definition of a causal relationship requires a cause to exist as it is this property itself that defines the relationship. 

Quote:
Let me know if the concept is unclear, or if my logic is wrong. It's a simple concept, so if the concept is understood we can talk about what possible holes there are in it.



I'm not sure I understand what your saying or why in several places.  I've identified them above.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: johnm214]
    #14707173 -

Good luck with that.


--------------------

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: Rahz]
    #14708123 -

From a thread of mine over 2 years ago

We are , in a physical , material sense living out a set of dominos.
Each domino knocks down the one next to it.. and on to infinity..
But.. the natural question occurs.. who/what knocked down the first domino ?
Well.. if we understand that to be "existent" you must be a domino , therefore you must suffer the law of causality. Its inevitable , right ?
So.. the first thing to knock down the first domino.. must be outside this LAW. It musnt be a domino.
It has to be outside of causality.
To be  absolutely outside of causality , therefore.. IT must be non-existent.
Meaning.. It is nothing.



Quote:
Does this mean that nothing is truly causing anything to happen?



I tend to think so.


--------------------



---------------------

All my posts in this forum are strictly fictional.
They are derived from an acute mental illness , from which i am forced to lie compulsively.
I have never induced any kind of mind altering substance in my life  and i have no intentions whatsoever of doing anything illegal.
If I have ever suggested such a thing it would have most likely been , due to my personality disorder and i probably do not remember it at all..

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: OrgoneConclusion]
    #14708138 -

OrgoneConclusion said:
Good luck with that.



:rofl:


--------------------
Live your Life! :heart:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: johnm214]
    #14708274 -

An ultimate source would be the original catalyst in a closed system. The question is not whether causation exists or not, but within the observance of cause, are we seeing the whole picture? I don't think we can technically see the whole picture. The stratification of cause can be seen in the domino example. The mind moves the hand which moves the 1st, 2nd, and then third domino. The second domino caused the third to fall, but the first domino, as well as everything before can also be said to have caused the consequential action which causes the 3rd to fall. So it would be appropriate to ask upon entering the room "Who caused my dominoes to fall"? An interesting response might be "I swear I only knocked one over".

If we look at the universe, it can be seen through individual elements, or as a whole, that what is happening is a chain of cause and effect, yet there doesn't seem to be a beginning to the chain. This is where momentum comes in. If momentum is conserved, it was also being conserved yesterday, and last week, and at any point in the past. It suggests that the past is infinite, and thus it is impossible to trace a cause back to an initial source. In this way, the initial source would be considered the 'true cause' of an event, if it existed.

I'm saying there is no final/ultimate source as the cause of all things (or anything). Therefore, ultimately nothing is causing anything.

Some examples: A person is tried for murder. They are found guilty. The whole court process is of a practical nature for deterrence of future crimes. It is the best we can do, but it might seem better if we were able to find and correct the ultimate causes of crimes, rather than simply waiting around for crime to happen. What caused this man to die? The murderer sure. His gun? That too, along with the bullet, and the finger, perhaps his alcoholic father, or cold mother, or a streak of murderous DNA, or his shell shock from war, or maybe a horse kicked him in the head as a boy. And what caused all of that? Any and every product of cause has a chain that fades into infinity.

A soldier is shot in the head. What caused that to happen? The bullet? The gun, the man, the platoon, the commander, the general, the president? All of them? And what caused the president to give the order? Circumstances which evolved from the past? It all funnels back towards what might be mistaken to be an ultimate source. But if time is infinite, the funnel goes on forever and there is no ultimate source. Therefore, there is no ultimate cause for anything. As all causes are dependent on previous causes, a single cause can not be said to be THE cause for anything. This remains true at any point in time, to my understanding.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: OrgoneConclusion]
    #14708279 -

OrgoneConclusion said:
Good luck with that.


:spock:


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: Causation. Is it what it appears to be? [Re: jivJaN]
    #14708322 -

Quote:
We are , in a physical , material sense living out a set of dominos.
Each domino knocks down the one next to it.. and on to infinity..
But.. the natural question occurs.. who/what knocked down the first domino ?
Well.. if we understand that to be "existent" you must be a domino , therefore you must suffer the law of causality. Its inevitable , right ?
So.. the first thing to knock down the first domino.. must be outside this LAW. It musnt be a domino.
It has to be outside of causality.
To be  absolutely outside of causality , therefore.. IT must be non-existent.
Meaning.. It is nothing.



That's exactly it.:thumbup:

Looking at the past as infinite would prevent the need for anything being outside causation, but the same conclusion is reached.


--------------------
rahz

comfort pleasure power love     truth awareness peace I am      I feel      I do     I love  I speak    I see    I know

To shrink a person's vocabulary is to shrink their capacity to think.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Jump to top Pages: 1 | 2 |  [ show all ]

Shop: Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order   North Spore Bulk Substrate


Similar ThreadsPosterViewsRepliesLast post
* Momentum cube talk 698 9 11/02/08 03:12 AM
by DieCommie
* momentum as the cause of suffering deff 463 1 12/22/07 12:05 AM
by JoseLibrado
* Mind momentum Lion 1,349 17 01/29/08 07:31 PM
by redgreenvines
* Hung up!? (Momentum.) Gomp 779 6 10/08/06 08:13 PM
by Sinbad
* Being a Conservative
( 1 2 3 all )
Huehuecoyotl 3,215 52 12/06/06 10:12 PM
by Huehuecoyotl
* Law of Conservation of Energy and The Afterlife
( 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 all )
OrgoneConclusion 10,732 127 10/19/07 01:48 PM
by fireworks_god
* Water Conservation fireworks_godS 1,113 16 10/21/06 08:03 PM
by Veritas
* Personalities Reflected In Appearance?
( 1 2 all )
fireworks_godS 2,360 31 04/02/03 02:34 PM
by Anonymous

Extra information
You cannot start new topics / You cannot reply to topics
HTML is disabled / BBCode is enabled
Moderator: Middleman, DividedQuantum
1,848 topic views. 2 members, 106 guests and 33 web crawlers are browsing this forum.
[ Show Images Only | Sort by Score | Print Topic ]
Search this thread:

Copyright 1997-2026 Mind Media. Some rights reserved.

Generated in 0.031 seconds spending 0.008 seconds on 16 queries.