Auto-SummaryIn this forum post, user AzurianBlue argues against the "all lives matter" response to "black lives matter," asserting that the experiences of black Americans, particularly in the context of law enforcement, are fundamentally different from those of other racial or ethnic groups. AzurianBlue cites personal experiences and observations, such as the disproportionate use of force by police on black individuals, disparities in school infrastructure, and differences in treatment based on race. They maintain that these issues are not merely about individual instances but systemic and historical injustices that still affect black communities today. The user criticizes the dismissal of these concerns as mere "statistical commonsense," emphasizing the lived reality of systemic racism and the need for genuine acknowledgment and action.
AzurianBlue said: I don't really understand the point of the OP 
I don't understand how American enslavement of blacks - being hunted down and forcefully removed from their homes, imprisoned, moved to another continent, and sold as property, actual property with a deed for entire generations with no way out - is comparable to our culture's obsession with making money. I've never experienced anything remotely like this in my pursuit of material wealth. Have you?
While I do see how slaves of the Egyptian empire were likely treated in the same way as black slaves in America, I think to compare the two events like you did is disingenuous, as it completely ignores the fact that one happened thousands of years ago in a fallen ancient empire, while the other ended less than two hundred years ago, and its effects are still felt by blacks living in America to this day.
I also don't understand the need to appropriate someone else's argument. Going from "black lives matter" to "all lives matter" seems to me to make the assertion that the challenges and prejudices faced by blacks in America are equivalent to those faced by people of any other race in America, including whites.
Maybe you live in a magical garden where blacks really are treated the same as whites, but both where I grew up and where I live now, it's just not what I've seen
The most visible instances for me of how blacks are treated differently come from watching how LE interacts with them versus me and other white people. When black people get pulled over, no matter the reason, they're immediately pulled out of the car, put in cuffs, and at least two or three other cops show up as backup to start searching the car. Maybe some of the people they run into have this justified, but it happens every time I see a black person pulled over.
White people get to stay seated in their car, no handcuffs. I rarely see cops calling for another car to back them up if they've got a white person pulled over. I routinely see blacks pulled over for minor traffic infractions that I've gotten away with doing countless times right in front of a cop's face.
In my own personal experience, I got pulled over once and had a pocket knife fall out of my glovebox while I was getting my insurance card out. The cop absolutely saw it and he didn't even flinch. I gave him my insurance card like nothing had happened and soon I got sent on my way. I'm absolutely certain if I was black, I'd have had cold steel pressed to my temple before getting thrown in the back of a cop car.
Being a white guy with a gun or knife and interacting with a cop where I live means being treated with respect as someone exercising my constitutional right to be armed. You tell them where the weapon is, they tell you to keep your hands on the wheel, and they go about their business so long as you stay still. Being a black person in the same scenario means at a minimum a cop's gun in my face, getting handcuffed, disarmed, and searched, if I'm lucky.
It doesn't stop with LE. The schools where I grew up in the parts of town where majority black populations lived have to give students bottled water to drink because the drinking fountain pipes are filled with lead. Twenty minutes down the road where the white folks live, you could have your name engraved on a gold plate on a safe, working drinking fountain if you made a donation to the school.
Maybe I've just happened to live in areas where cops and other authority figures treat blacks differently. And maybe such simple things as safe drinking water are provided equally for black and white children elsewhere. Where I've lived, your standard of living, how you're treated by others, especially authority figures, and your overall opportunities in life are better if you're white than if you're black.
I gain nothing by saying this. I don't have an agenda, and I'm reasonably certain that as an average joe without millions of dollars, nothing I do or say will make any difference in these effects. It's just calling it how I honestly see it 
The "all lives matter" thing seems like a way for people to minimize these things. I think we should be honest about it. Maybe somewhere in America, the way blacks have been treated throughout our history, from slavery to segregation to Jim Crow to voter suppression laws - maybe somewhere in America none of that really has any effect on the life of the average black person anymore. But everywhere I've been they're all still relevant, I understand why BLM exists, and I understand why they take such offense to trying to turn it into "all lives matter".
Cops have different interactions with many blacks because of their past experiences, you do realize not all cops are white? They're also black, Hispanic and Asian.
There's a logical reason why law enforcement treats them differently, the interactions are more dangerous in nature, it's called statistical commonsense.
Cops also treat younger people differently than older people, males differently than females, rich people differently than poor people, where is your outrage over ageism, sexism and classism? Or does that just make more sense at the end of the day?
|