Auto-SummaryThe forum post discusses the "100 monkey theory" and its connection to morphogenetic fields, a concept in developmental biology. The author clarifies that they did not advocate the theory as factual evidence but explained how behavior changes within populations can occur without resorting to the "100 monkey" mysticism. They argue that if morphogenetic fields and critical mass are real, then "100 monkey theory" could be possible among animals. The post also delves into the quantum mechanics behind morphogenetic fields and their relevance to biological organisms. Sheldrake's theory is further supported by scientific phenomena like in situ hybridization and immunocytochemistry, which have found molecules whose expression domains coincide with morphogenetic fields. The author concludes by emphasizing that the morphogenetic field concept is regaining importance in developmental biology and evolution, bridging the gap between genes and evolution.
who did that?
I certainly didn't postulate '100 monkey theory' as factual evidence of morphogenetic fields.
Read my 2 posts directly above and you will see that I actually gave a factual explanation of how behaviour changes within populations, and paradigm shifts within populations, can happen without '100 monkey' mystification.
The post of mine directly above demystifies the '100 monkey theory' (check the link - for full detail) and explains a factual evidenced path for the course of behaviour transformation among the monkeys.
A course of behaviour change that is certainly accessable to humans, and demonstrated when we study any major societal shift throughout history.
You are picking on a sentence which was a minor aside in the post it is drawn from, and actually does not form the base of my proposal to you. All I was stating here is that '100 monkey theory' (whether true or not in actuality), when taken at face value (at least coincidentally) illustrates known scientific concepts. If these concepts are real (which they certainly seem to be), then there is certainly a strong possibility that something like '100 monkey theory' is possible amongst animals.
And if '100 monkey theory' per ce is totally untrue, and if we also discard morphogenetic field theory (and even critical mass); undeniably the resulting behavioural evolution it explains certainly still is true.....well just read the rest of my 2 posts above and tell me what you think.
(The one directly above mistakenly may appear to be me addressing me - it is actually for you to read)
And the below, which regards morphogenetic fields, is very interesting too:
---------------------------------------------------------------
"To understand his (Sheldrake's) theory, it helps to begin in the strange world of quantum mechanics. At the beginning of this century it became clear that sub- atomic particles - electrons, protons, x-rays, etc. - behave as if they are both particles (bundles of mass/energy) and waves (spread in time and space). The wave aspect carries no energy but strongly influences how the particle aspect can behave. Translated into biologist's terms, the wave can be seen as the morphogenetic field for the particle. Sheldrake takes this step and then goes further to suggest that larger forms, like biological organisms, have morphogenetic fields that are more than just the sum of their parts. These fields carry no energy but influence (in perhaps the same way the quantum fields do) the form the parts take as they come together."
http://twm.co.nz/shel_morfields.htm
----------------------------------------------------------------
" The Reappreciation of the Morphogenetic Field
Several phenomena have contributed to a new appreciation of the morphogenetic field. First, in situ hybridization and immunocytochemistry have found molecules whose expression domains coincide with those of morphogenetic fields. For instance, if one looks at textbook Figure 15.6, one can see a stained region of the embryo that corresponds to the cardiac fields of the chick embryo. Second, the ability to respond to a morphogen could now be detected by looking at cell surface receptors. The cells bearing these receptors often can be seen as having boundaries coincident with that of a morphogenetic field. Thus, these fields do appear to be real entities.
In some areas of developmental biology, the concept of the field had persisted, and the notions of limb fields and heart fields are still in the literature (see Sater and Jacobson 1990; Easton et al. 1994; Cohn et al. 1995). In such instances, no claims are usually made other than that these areas of mesoderm are destined to form these particular structures. In recent years, several developmental biologists have revitalized the ideas of fields and have reclaimed their fundamental importance for both development and evolution. De Robertis and his associates (1991) synthesized molecular and classical material "to increase awareness among modern developmental biologists of the old concepts of morphogenetic gradient fields." At that time, however, the interactions between parts of any field were still unknown, but De Robertis et al. (1991) emphasized the roles that homeobox genes may play in initiating and organizing these fields. Especially important to them were two observations concerning gradients produced by Hox proteins in limb buds. The first was that gradients of these proteins could induce the production of specific proteins at specific sites, and that these proteins might establish the conditions for a field (such as the limb field or feather bud field) to emerge. The second notion was that the gradients of these proteins might establish the polar axes of these organs. Until recently, the interactions that constituted these fields could not be identified. However, the discovery of the homologous pathways of development has given us new insights into how these fields are established and maintained.
Molecular biologists have recently rediscovered fields in Drosophila. The imaginal discs of insects have long been considered as gradient fields (see French et al. 1976; Ingham and Martinez Arias 1992; Williams et al. 1994), since they are well defined groups of cells whose interactions form an organ, since they regulate to replace missing parts, and since they retain their ability to generate the particular organ, when the disc is transplanted to other sites in the larva.
The concept of fields was also rediscovered by clinical geneticists. Given that a specific malformation (such as an extra thumb) can be caused by different mutations and be a component of different syndromes, it was established that the complex of anatomic structures that was malformed together constituted a dysmorphogenetically reactive unit. It was presumed that the same complex of anatomic structures constituted a morphogenetically reactive unit under normal circumstances. The dysmorphogenetically reactive fields, defined on the basis of clinical syndromes, were seen to be the equivalent of the self-organizing, spatially coordinated and temporally synchronized morphogenetic fields of classical embryology. This equation was supplemented by the observation that, in many vertebrate species, the same malformations (e.g., cyclopia, polydactyly) could be produced experimentally or by mutation (Opitz 1985).
The morphogenetic field is returning as an important unit of development and evolution and phylogenesis. Moreover, it integrates the gene with evolution (Gilbert et al. 1996). Since genes work as part of pathways, and pathways are the physical interacting units of the morphogenetic felds, the field is the middle ground between the gene and evolution."
http://www.devbio.com/article.php?ch=3&id=18
----------------------------------------------------------------
Robert Gilman, including an interview with Rupert Sheldrake:
"Robert: Have there been any interesting attempts at disproof?
Rupert: Well, my book and this theory have been attacked quite a lot, but none of the attacks have actually struck at the heart of the argument. No one has actually claimed that what I'm saying is impossible or that it's illogical or that it couldn't occur on any kind of basis. The attacks have mostly been along the line that this theory is completely unnecessary because regular biology, given time, will solve all the problems along conventional lines, that I'm either being too impatient or misleading the public. But so far there has been nothing of scientific substance.
The only experiment which at least claims to disprove the hypothesis is one done by Francisco Varela, the neurophysiologist. He assumed that this hypothesis applied to computers, and he did an experiment where a computer did an iterated operation many times over and over again. He measured the time taken for this operation to see whether it speeded up. And it didn't. He regards this as a refutation of the hypothesis, but I don't because I never claimed that the hypothesis applied to computers in the first place. I think of it as applying to self-organizing systems like cells, molecules, and crystals, but not to artificial machines.
Robert: There's no opportunity for the computer to change its speed of operation.
Rupert: No. He didn't take that point into account. He thought that there might be an increase in the rate with which the silicon chip responded.
Robert: Good grief, if that's the most serious challenge you've gotten, you're certainly in very good shape.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
"The most difficult part for most to accept is the fundamental idea that information, created by and retrievable by physical systems, can be transmitted and stored in a non-physical form. This is a direct contradiction of the materialist vision that has served as the basis for most of the sciences, and many (but by no means all) scientists are reluctant to let go of that vision. Yet the experimental support for materialism has been crumbling for some time - from the "instantaneous communications" implied by Bell's Theorem in quantum physics to the solid experimental demonstrations that now exist for such psychic abilities as telepathy, clairvoyance, precognition, and psychokinesis (see, for example, Charles Tart in the December 1985 Special Report for Members from the Institute of Noetic Sciences, 475 Gate Five Rd, Suite 300, Sausalito, CA 94965). Thus the morphogenetic field research is more like the last straw than the first wave in the assault on traditional materialism."
"one of the reasons why the morphogenetic field research is so important is that it is starting to provide a common language, a meeting ground, that may permit mystics and scientists to cooperate in exploring these realms. The New Story does not have to adopt any particular traditional belief system, but it can acknowledge that these traditions may hold verifiable knowledge. The results of this will probably be full of surprises, disappoint most partisans, and increase religious interest at the same time that it deflates scriptural authoritarianism. Out of it all may even come a fresh synthesis that will finally end the three-way war between science, religion, and mystical spirituality."
http://www.context.org/ICLIB/IC12/Sheldrak.htm
------
http://www.co-intelligence.org/P-morphogeneticfields.html
http://www.co-intelligence.org/P-moreonmorphgnicflds.html
------
Bell's Theorem : A mathematical proof derived from physics demonstrating that when ever two particles interact, they are thereafter connected in a mysterious faster-than-light way that doesn't diminish with time or distance and can't be shielded. Also known as the "mechanism of non-locality".
Have you ever considered an ontology that embraces more than just materialism?
Voodoo-style links, that are a Reality behind Appearance.
Edited by CJay (08/12/04 11:01 AM)
|