Auto-SummaryThe author argues that the pro-choice movement's stance that it's ultimately the individual mother's decision to have an abortion, regardless of the fetus's potential status as a human life, is not a reasoned or objective position. The author advocates for an objective evaluation of the circumstances surrounding an abortion, weighing the potential status of the fetus against other factors. They suggest that if a fetus is objectively considered a discrete human life, then its rights should take precedence over the mother's rights, as killing a human being is generally considered morally wrong. The author rejects the notion that the mother's convenience should trump the potential life of the fetus, and instead proposes that abortions should be performed as early as possible and only when there is a genuine medical justification, considering the act of abortion as a serious matter rather than a matter of convenience.
>> I completely agree with your conclusion here. As does the pro choice movement. Its funny that you and the pro-choicers have come to the same basic conclusion only you go on to think it means abortions shouldn't occur. The whole reasoning behind the term "pro-choice" is that, in light of the fact that it isn't really clear when the little bugger is alive or not, it is the INDIVIDUAL MOTHER'S right to make that moral decision for herself.
To be sure, I haven't said that I think abortions shouldn't occur. Rather, I have said that the outcome of a reasoned evaluation of the subject is the conclusion that they should only occur when circumstances justify their occurrence. When the starting point is reasoned objectivity, the circumstances compelling abortion as an option are appropriately weighed against the ramifications of the aborted fetus potentially qualifying as a discrete human life.
>> If you want to make a judgement call and based on your sense of justice decide that its better to err on the rights of an unborn potential child, thats your judgement call. But it makes you "pro-life."
You have oversimplified my point and are attempting to wield this oversimplification like ram, shoving me under the "pro-life" banner. In actual reality, I do not belong under either banner, because neither of these banners operate from a reasoned stance. Such is the nature of polarization.
Suggesting that that the potential status of a fetus as a discrete life form should be weighed against the other practical circumstances prompting the evaluation of abortion as an option is not the same as assigning absolute rights to a fetus where no such rights can be objectively applied.
>> It means you are still assigning rights to the foetus that trump the rights of the mother. That means you are deciding, despite your admission that you don't know when the fetus is alive, that you are going to grant that fetus rights as if it were alive.
Actually, I have not advocated for granting the fetus rights as though it were alive absent of the determination that this is so. I have advocated for deploying the potential human-life-status of the fetus as a key consideration against other circumstantial factors. In short, I have advocated for objectivity, and I have articulated what objectivity commands of this issue.
If you were the owner of a building, and you were preparing to demolish your building, and immediately before doing so the question should arise: "what if somebody is inside the building?", it is most rational to consider whether or not someone is inside before demolishing the building. It is not rational to throw the switch irrespective of whether or not someone is inside, citing "it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it" as justification. If the potential exists that somebody is inside the building, the decision to demolish it must be weighed against this possibility if the moral principle that killing another human being is wrong is to be upheld.
If it is true, objectively speaking, the a fetus is a discrete life form qualifiable as a human being (somebody is inside the building), then its rights trump those of the mother (the owner of the building (womb)), as it is not anyone's right under our current moral framework to end the life of another human being. Unless its existence inside the womb qualifies the life form as not a distinct human being, it is not the mother's inalienable right to abort the fetus under our current moral framework. Since it is not known whether or not a distinct human being exists inside the womb, this objective reality must be taken into proportionate consideration when the decision to abort is being weighed.
It is not known if a fetus is a discrete life form qualifiable as a human being (it is not known if somebody is inside the building). Taking this acknowledgement as a starting point, you have identified two possible vectors:
1) Those rights which cannot be objectively assigned to the fetus automatically default to the mother carrying the fetus (it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it). She is given supreme authority over the life form, irrespective of its actual status, for the singular reason that its actual status cannot be ascertained. Within this framework, a pregnant woman is free to terminate the life of what is potentially a discrete human being if that is the most convenient and lowest-stress option for her. In essence, this is relegating the ramifications of terminating what is potentially a distinct human being beneath the whims, preferences, and lifestyle ambitions of the mother.
2) Upholding a preference not to risk performing the action of terminating a distinct life form qualifiable as a human being, to regard the performance of such an action with a degree of consideration for circumstances proportionate to the scope and potential ramifications of the abortion procedure (to consider whether or not someone is inside before demolishing the building). Emergent from this is the default preference to perform abortions as early as possible, decreasing the likelihood that the action results in the termination of what may later be understood as a distinct human life, and only with medical justification, regarding the act of abortion as a serious matter, and never a matter of convenience.
If the society upholds the moral principle that killing another human being is wrong, and if the definition of what constitutes a human being cannot be ascertained, the most rational application of the moral principle in such a circumstance is to assume the fetus is a discrete living being or at least potentially operating as such, thereby making the decision to terminate its continuation a gravely serious one which must be justified by circumstances proportionate to the potential scope of that action. To simply assign otherwise unassignable rights to the mother by default is relating to the fetus like property (it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it). Since it is has not been ascertained if a fetus can be objectively related to in this way, behaving as though the opposite is true is not rational.
>> it is the INDIVIDUAL MOTHER'S right to make that moral decision for herself. Not the government's. Not yours. Not mine. Hers.
All feminist gusto aside, you have not provided a rational basis for defaulting the rights of what is potentially a distinct human life to the mother. Neither have I presumed to have the right to dictate to the mother what she ought to do, nor have I expressed favour for the government to assume this right. I am not interested in such things. I am interested in unearthing a reasoned stance on abortion from beneath the piles of polarized, irrational rhetoric that has been heaped atop this issue since the debate first ignited. These pithy sentences: "Not yours." "Not mine." "Hers." - these are strongly reminiscent of the irrational and polarized rhetoric typical to the "pro-choice" side of the debate. It is not any more valid or meaningful than the equivalent rhetoric belted out by the "pro-life" camp. It is time for this kind of laconic nonsense to end, and for reasoned discourse to begin.
--------------------
Dark Triangles - New Psychedelic Techno Single - Listen on Soundcloud
Gyroscope full album available SoundCloud or MySpace
|