Home | Community | Message Board


This site includes paid links. Please support our sponsors.


Welcome to the Shroomery Message Board! You are experiencing a small sample of what the site has to offer. Please login or register to post messages and view our exclusive members-only content. You'll gain access to additional forums, file attachments, board customizations, encrypted private messages, and much more!

Shop: Original Sensible Seeds Feminized Cannabis Seeds   Myyco.com Golden Teacher Liquid Culture For Sale   Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order

Jump to first unread post Pages: 1 | 2 |  [ show all ]
The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark
    #18026817 -

This post will succeed in demonstrating that the abortion debate is fallacious in nature, and that a coherent, rational argument against abortion does exist to the exclusion of a coherent, rational argument in favour of abortion.

The abortion debate, like so many other debates in popular discourse, is polarized between two erroneous extremes.  The debate consists of a false dichotomy which obstructs people from approaching the issue in an independent, rational manner.  If you are strongly aligned for or against abortion, and if this subject arouses feelings of righteous indignation in you, it is highly likely that you are a victim of this polarization and are not thinking clearly.  Consider this carefully as you read the remainder of this post.

On one side of the debate is the assertion:

If you are against abortion, you are against a woman's right to choose.  To be against abortion is to be anti-female.

On the other side of the debate is the assertion:

If you agree that a woman has the right to choose abortion, you are anti-life and are a direct or indirect accessory to infanticide.

Both of these assertions are ludicrous in that they are rooted in beliefs as opposed to evidence.  Both sides of the argument presume knowledge as to the definition of life and its beginning, when in actual reality no such knowledge is presently available to human beings.

The first position--in support of abortion--presumes knowledge that life begins at birth, and from this erroneous conclusion the ancillary conclusion that abortion is strictly a civil rights matter is rendered.  The second position--against abortion--presumes knowledge that life begins at conception, and from this erroneous conclusion the ancillary conclusion that all abortion is equivalent to infanticide is rendered.

In actual reality, it is a fact that human beings do not possess sufficient scientific insight into the nature of life and of consciousness to differentiate with certainty between a loosely organized composite of cells and a functioning, sentient living being.  Because this is true, neither side of the abortion debate is tenable.  Furthermore, this absence of evidence-based scientific insight itself constitutes a reasonable position against abortion.  From the point of view of a morally conscious society--which already agrees that taking life is immoral--to abort a fetus without unalloyed foreknowledge as to its status as a living being is at best a morally irresponsible and recklessly negligent act.

It's for this reason that the most rational position on abortion is one of default disapproval with provisions for pragmatic exception.  Such a stance prefers abortions carried out at the earliest possible term, and for justifiable medical reasons, such as a clear genetic aberration which would severely impair the fetus' quality of life or capacity to survive without constant artificial intervention after birth, or a significant and qualifiable medical risk to the mother.  Late term abortions, and abortions without a medically justifiable cause (abortions of convenience), are not acceptable from the point of view of this reasoned stance.

The argument that hundreds of thousands of babies would have been born into poor living conditions were it not for abortion does not stand up to reason.  If the anticipated living conditions of a child were grounds for terminating a life, then it ought to also be acceptable to terminate babies after delivery if their living conditions are unfavourable.  Since human beings do not actually know when a new life begins, there is no rational basis for differentiating between terminating an early-development human pre or post partum.  Only an arbitrary basis exists, and this arbitrary basis is not a coherent justification for carrying out an abortion.

This post and its conclusions are logically founded on the accurate premise that human beings do not possess clear, evidence-based scientific insight into the nature of life and of consciousness, and are therefore not capable of rendering an ineluctable conclusion as to the moment a human fetus transitions from a loosely organized cellular composite to a functioning, sentient, living being.  Any arguments which contradict this premise are incorrect, because to contradict facts is to be incorrect.


--------------------


:poison: Dark Triangles - New Psychedelic Techno Single - Listen on Soundcloud :poison:
Gyroscope full album available SoundCloud or MySpace

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped] * 2
    #18026820 -

Here is my main argument for choice. Illegal abortion merely drives abortion underground into untrained medical hands putting the pregnant woman at risk. I see nothing to be gained by doing so.


--------------------

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: OrgoneConclusion] * 1
    #18026831 -

Rather than arguing for a certain legal decision on abortion, I am arguing for independent, critical thought on the subject.

Societies populated by individuals who think critically and independently require very few laws.


--------------------


:poison: Dark Triangles - New Psychedelic Techno Single - Listen on Soundcloud :poison:
Gyroscope full album available SoundCloud or MySpace

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18026839 -

I do like the assertiveness of your first sentence.


--------------------
"They consider me insane but I know that I am a hero living under the eyes of the gods."

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18026889 -

Ped said:
Rather than arguing for a certain legal decision on abortion, I am arguing for independent, critical thought on the subject.

Societies populated by individuals who think critically and independently require very few laws.



That dismissive response had nothing to do with my point and is why I generally avoid your threads. Great example of non-critical thinking.


--------------------

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18026892 -

Quote:
human beings do not possess clear, evidence-based scientific insight into the nature of life



Quote:
and are therefore not capable of rendering an ineluctable conclusion as to the moment a human fetus transitions from a loosely organized cellular composite to a functioning, sentient, living being.



You say that with such authority, so it must be true.

Source?


--------------------
.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Masked]
    #18026894 -

Ped is famous for such vacuous declarations.


--------------------

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: OrgoneConclusion]
    #18026896 -

You're kindof a lonely guy, aren't you?

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped] * 1
    #18026913 -

Quote:
To be against abortion is to be anti-female.



I also don't agree this is entirely correct.

I find that a very bold assertion.

I've always found it fascinating how science coupled with the ability to consciously think and be aware...gives us as humans the ability to pull of such things as abortion.

In my own opinion, ff you took science out of the equation and we truly lived in the present moment as I believe most other mammals on the planet do, abortion wouldn't even be an option, let alone a philosophical debate.

Don't take this statement to heart.  It's kind of just a never never land thought full of what ifs and assertions.


--------------------
.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18027196 -

Ped said:
Rather than arguing for a certain legal decision on abortion, I am arguing for independent, critical thought on the subject.

Societies populated by individuals who think critically and independently require very few laws.



:lol: Have you have learned so little in all these years Ped?

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Icelander]
    #18027513 -

Even less than that.


--------------------

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: OrgoneConclusion]
    #18028322 -

Auto-Summary
The post argues against the notion that illegal abortion drives it underground and against the assertion that being against abortion is anti-female. It critiques the "pro-choice" and "pro-life" positions, stating that neither can be considered legitimate due to the lack of scientific evidence determining the exact moment a new life begins. The author suggests that a more rational and moral stance on abortion would acknowledge the uncertainty surrounding this issue and reject the arbitrary assumptions of both sides. The post also discusses the implications of a society populated by individuals who think critically and independently, arguing that such a society would require fewer laws due to its capacity for autonomous, objective thinking.

>> Here is my main argument for choice. Illegal abortion merely drives abortion underground

>> That dismissive response had nothing to do with my point

Not sure why you took it as a dismissive response.  This post is not about abortion law.  Commenting about abortion law has nothing to do with the point of this post.  These kind of laws emerge from public opinion, which essentially means that the group with the loudest voice and the most forceful legal thrust ultimately articulates the law.  This post is about illustrating the distortions that exist in public opinion, and it is a post which presents a new disposition based on available facts, as opposed to the distortions of personal bias and arbitrary assumption.


>> To be against abortion is to be anti-female

>> I also don't agree this is entirely correct.

>> I find that a very bold assertion.

This is the assertion made by the vocal majority of people who identify as "pro-choice".  It is not my assertion.  This is the most visible argument rendered against people who wish to end abortion.

This "pro-choice" identification is itself erroneous, because if abortion does qualify as the taking of a life, then choice is not actually at issue.  Since human beings do possess scientific insight determining the moment a new life begins, the "pro-choice" stance makes this determination arbitrarily (generally, at birth), and is therefore not a legitimate position on the subject.

The same is true for the "pro-life" side of the argument, the vocal majority of which proclaim that a new life begins at the moment of conception.  This too is an arbitrary assumption rooted in private morality as opposed to science, and consequently it is an equally illegitimate position on the subject.

A legitimate position on the moral and ethical ramifications of abortion must take into account the fact that human beings do not possess exacting knowledge into what constitutes the origins of a new life form.  Human beings do not possess scientific insight into what exactly takes place between the moment a composite of dividing cells becomes a distinct human being.  Scientific insight does not even understand what processes occur to render an adult human being sentient and aware: how then could it be understood when this sentient awareness begins?  Obviously it cannot.  Once this is accepted, the only rational, moral stance to take on abortion is as I stated in the original post.


>> You say that with such authority, so it must be true.

>> Source?

What foolishness.  I am stating that there is no evidence available.  I say this with authority because it is true: no definitive evidence has been presented which satisfies the question of the precise moment a new life emerges. That is the truth, and the truth is the authority, therefore I speak it authoritatively. 

Scientific journals do not present evidence for the lack of evidence for something.  Scientific journals present evidence, not the absence of evidence. If it is your assertion that such evidence definitively ascertaining the beginning of an autonomous human life does in fact exist, then the burden of proof rests on you.  Please, present it.  Show us the scientific data conclusively proving the precise moment a new, distinct human life begins.  You cannot do this, because no such scientific data exists to that end.  It is therefore completely absurd for you to ask me to provide concrete data demonstrating the absence of concrete data, to present evidence for a complete lack of evidence.

There are papers published by physicians who assert that a new life begins upon autonomy from the mother, and there are papers published by physicians who assert that a new life begins upon the union of sperm and ovum, at which point these two distinct cells become non-distinct and autonomous in their function.  While these debates are much more qualified than what occurs in the mainstream, they are still driven by private opinion which has been imputed upon observations made.

There exists a published opinion that the neural framework required to sustain consciousness is present somewhere between the 24th and 28th week of gestation, but that it is "unlikely" that the fetus develops the capacity to functionally perceive before the 30th week.  [Lee S.J., Ralston H.J., Drey E.A., Partridge J.C., Rosen M.A., August 2005].  This is obviously very unclear and far from definitive.

There also exists a published opinion that the neocortex--considered the seat of mammalian perception and of conscious thought--may be adequately developed at the 6th or 7th week, one or two weeks after its initial differentiation sometime during the 5th week. [E. B. Smirnov, V. F. Puchkov and V. A. Otellin, November 2001].  This is obviously very unclear and far from definitive.

That science does not possess adequate insight into the definition of and origins of a distinct, sentient life form is common knowledge.  It does not require a source.  If you want to criticize this absence of a source, please provide a source demonstrating that science does in fact possess adequate insight into the precise moment a cell-division process because a qualified individual lifeform.  You will not find such a source, because no such source exists. 


>> Have you have learned so little in all these years Ped?

I'm not sure exactly to what this comment pertains.  The statement "societies populated by individuals who think critically and independently require very few laws" is a coherent philosophical insight, albeit worded somewhat romantically.  A society populated by critical, independent minds is capable of autonomous, objective thinking, which is by definition uncontaminated by arbitrary self-interest.  The onus of justice in such a society thereby requires less centralization, less officiation, and in turn fewer written laws.  Your incapacity to envision such a society is much more likely to be resultant from the obstructions of your own cynicism, rather than a deficiency in my education.


--------------------


:poison: Dark Triangles - New Psychedelic Techno Single - Listen on Soundcloud :poison:
Gyroscope full album available SoundCloud or MySpace

Edited by Ped (03/29/13 03:26 PM)

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped] * 1
    #18028430 -

A society populated by critical, independent minds is capable of autonomous, objective thinking, which is by definition uncontaminated by arbitrary self-interest.  The onus of justice in such a society thereby requires less centralization, less officiation, and in turn fewer written laws.  Your incapacity to envision such a society is much more likely to be resultant from the obstructions of your own cynicism, rather than a deficiency in my education.

I can envision any fantasy you can but it's still a fantasy.  No such society has ever existed or will it as far as you know.

It's like saying "when I become superman then I will be in charge".


--------------------
"Don't believe everything you think". -Anom.

" All that lives was born to die"-Anom.

With much wisdom comes much sorrow,
The more knowledge, the more grief.
Ecclesiastes circa 350 BC

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Icelander]
    #18028473 -

>> I can envision any fantasy you can but it's still a fantasy

It seems like you're missing the purpose of the statement.  I was saying to Orgone that this post is not intended to advocate for a given legal position on marriage, rather to criticize the polarized and remarkably unscientific content of popular discourse, while simultaneously exemplifying an opinion which is articulated apart from such distortions.  The intent was to invoke an image of what the public discourse and legal structure would appear if these were rooted in scientific insight as opposed to religiosity or feministic impulse.

Compared to the world we live in today, I agree that such a vision is fantastical and highly romantic.  It is nonetheless so that the human species is not likely ever to emerge from its polarized, bellicose state until members of the species are at least capable of visualizing a world where truth is taken as the authority, as opposed to authority taken as the truth, to invoke Gerald Massey.


--------------------


:poison: Dark Triangles - New Psychedelic Techno Single - Listen on Soundcloud :poison:
Gyroscope full album available SoundCloud or MySpace

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18028532 -

So you're saying you're a romantic?


--------------------
"Don't believe everything you think". -Anom.

" All that lives was born to die"-Anom.

With much wisdom comes much sorrow,
The more knowledge, the more grief.
Ecclesiastes circa 350 BC

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18028606 -

Both sides of the argument presume knowledge as to the definition of life and its beginning

This is not relevant. Who cares when life begins or ends? The very definition of life is notoriously slippery to begin with. What DOES matter is when can proto-life begin to experience pain and suffering.

No rational argument posits that destroying a sperm is "bad". The same is true of a single fertilized egg though there are many illogical religious and emotional arguments that destroying an egg once it's fertilized is "bad". But those arguments aren't rational either because a fertilized human egg is not much different in this context than a bacteria. From all evidence, no suffering takes place when a bacteria is destroyed, and no suffering takes place when a fertilized egg is destroyed either.

Carry this rationale forward and a human Zygote does not suffer when destroyed. Neither a human morula. Neither a human blastocyst. And neither the eventual human embryo that results. The earliest point when human life is capable of experiencing pain or discomfort of any kind is after the nervous system begins to develop and function sufficiently to sense pain. Even the most rabid anti-abortion activists agree that this does not happen until the 20th week of gestation at the absolute earliest because before this time, a region of the spinal cord important in processing the sensation of pain (the substantia gelatinosa) is undeveloped and has not yet formed connections to the thalamus. Without maturation of these structures, there is no sensation of pain. This notion is further supported by the fact that the SG is full of kappa-opioid receptors which is where morphine and heroin exert their pain-reduction effects.

After the 20th week there is less certainty about if and how much a fetus can feel pain. Leaving aside the argument that a fetus can be anesthetized before abortion at any stage and so be aborted without any suffering, there is no non-emotional argument against abortion before the 20th week.

Far more suffering than painless abortion is likely if an unwanted child is allowed to achieve consciousness only to spend its life languishing unwanted in foster homes. There are already far too many children born into that life. It's one of humanity's nastiest feature.

in actual reality no such knowledge is presently available to human beings

Again, since life itself is hard to define, the exact moment when a blob of chemistry becomes life is even harder to define. My sense is that there is no sharp demarcation but rather a gray zone separating blob of chemistry from life.

But exactly when a fetus becomes capable of sensing pain  IS fairly clearly demarcated and even rigid anti-abortion fanatics tacitly agree. This is why they base their arguments on emotion instead of knowledge; because they want to stop ALL abortions on grounds of mysticism and faith, not just the abortions likely to cause the suffering of a fetus. THAT (faith) is the definition of non-critical thinking.


--------------------
Republican Values:

1) You can't get married to your spouse who is the same sex as you.
2) You can't have an abortion no matter how much you don't want a child.
3) You can't have a certain plant in your possession or you'll get locked up with a rapist and a murderer.

4) We need a smaller, less-intrusive government.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped] * 1
    #18028759 -

A society populated by critical, independent minds is capable of autonomous, objective thinking, which is by definition uncontaminated by arbitrary self-interest.

You're just making shit up.

Self-interest is the ultimate purpose of objective critical thinking because it benefits the thinker. Why else do it? To benefit others? Benefiting others may be compassionate, but it is not rational unless it ultimately benefits the benefactor. Without this notion, species would never have evolved beyond single-cells because life and its evolution is born of the struggle to acquire limited resources of space, food, water, shelter, and so on. That's why life ruthlessly eats other life: to steal by force all its resources and advance at the expense of others.

If the universe (or god if that floats your boat) provided life unlimited resources, then it could be beneficial to others without limiting its own growth. But the universe is nihilistic (or god is a malevolent, sadistic piece of shit, take your pick), so life struggles against other life or it dies. If god were an ancient Roman, he would have bought season tickets to the slaves' forced gladiatorial games to the death.

The truth is sometimes ugly. That doesn't make it any less true.


--------------------
Republican Values:

1) You can't get married to your spouse who is the same sex as you.
2) You can't have an abortion no matter how much you don't want a child.
3) You can't have a certain plant in your possession or you'll get locked up with a rapist and a murderer.

4) We need a smaller, less-intrusive government.

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Diploid]
    #18029357 -

>> This is not relevant. Who cares when life begins or ends?

In fact, what constitutes the beginning of a new life is what differentiates between terminating a pregnancy and murdering an unborn child.  If it can be definitively ascertained that a fetus is a discrete human life, then aborting it constitutes murdering an unborn child.  If it can be definitely ascertained that a fetus is not a discrete human life, then aborting it constitutes terminating a pregnancy.  Since it cannot be definitively ascertained what a discrete human life is and at what point it emerges as such, it is at the present time impossible to determine if abortion qualifies as terminating a pregnancy or murdering an unborn child, objectively speaking. 

Far from being irrelevant, this is the central and most important issue, and it is the one issue which goes almost completely unconsidered amid the polarization that exists between "pro-choice" and "pro-life", both of which erroneously claim by way of their own arbitrary distinctions to possess definitive insight into what constitutes the beginning of a new life and what does not.


>> The very definition of life is notoriously slippery to begin with.

Simply because the definition of life is difficult to pin down doesn't mean that the question should be arbitrarily discarded in favour of another parameter, such as:

>> when can proto-life begin to experience pain and suffering.

All you're doing here is changing words around and bending parameters, or in other words: making shit up. 

Firstly, the term "proto-life" is not a valid scientific term in this application.  This is an attempt to create a arbitrary distinction, in this case between a "life" and a "proto-life" as "not exactly life", invoking the term as a qualifier for the statement that terminating a "not exactly life" process is different from terminating a life, and is therefore acceptable provided there is no experience of pain and suffering.

There is no scientific basis for this distinction between "life" and "not exactly life".  It thus remains true that the life status of a human fetus remains undetermined, and the "pain and suffering" consideration remains secondary, not primary.

The parameters for determining what is terminating a human life and what is terminating something that is not a human life cannot be ascertained scientifically at this time.  It's for this reason that a moral position on abortion cannot be objectively defined.  Invoking the made-up term "proto-life" to describe a fetus does not affect this simple reality, objectively speaking.


>> But exactly when a fetus becomes capable of sensing pain  IS fairly clearly demarcated and even rigid anti-abortion fanatics tacitly agree.

The capacity of a fetus to respond to pain stimulus begins very early, however it is not known at what point these responses shift between strictly autonomic and perceptual.  It is not known with even vague precision what transpires between a fetus' capacity to respond to external stimulus, and its capacity to subjectively experience pain, and it is not known when this capacity arises.  If this distinction could be made, it would be a step closer to definitively ascertaining when a new human life emerges, as the phenomena of subjective experience is perhaps one of the key defining traits of a distinct human life.


>> Self-interest is the ultimate purpose of objective critical thinking because it benefits the thinker. Why else do it? To benefit others? Benefiting others may be compassionate, but it is not rational unless it ultimately benefits the benefactor.

This is an entirely different discussion that I will not be drawn into in this thread.  If you wish to discuss self-interest, other-centredness, and the philosophical underpinnings of these, this should be done in another thread.


Icelander:

>> So you're saying you're a romantic?

Yes sweetie, I suppose I'm prone to it at times.


--------------------


:poison: Dark Triangles - New Psychedelic Techno Single - Listen on Soundcloud :poison:
Gyroscope full album available SoundCloud or MySpace

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18029483 -

Ped said:
Both of these assertions are ludicrous in that they are rooted in beliefs as opposed to evidence.  Both sides of the argument presume knowledge as to the definition of life and its beginning, when in actual reality no such knowledge is presently available to human beings.



I completely agree with your conclusion here. As does the pro choice movement. Its funny that you and the pro-choicers have come to the same basic conclusion only you go on to think it means abortions shouldn't occur. The whole reasoning behind the term "pro-choice" is that, in light of the fact that it isn't really clear when the little bugger is alive or not, it is the INDIVIDUAL MOTHER'S right to make that moral decision for herself. Not the government's. Not yours. Not mine. Hers. If you want to make a judgement call and based on your sense of justice decide that its better to err on the rights of an unborn potential child, thats your judgement call. But it makes you "pro-life." It means you are still assigning rights to the foetus that trump the rights of the mother. That means you are deciding, despite your admission that you don't know when the fetus is alive, that you are going to grant that fetus rights as if it were alive. And what are you basing that on? You haven't shown that conclusion to be rational in the slightest.


--------------------
:hst:
Society in every form is a blessing,
but government at its best is but a necessary evil
 
- Thomas Paine

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: gluke bastid]
    #18029987 -

Auto-Summary
The author argues that the pro-choice movement's stance that it's ultimately the individual mother's decision to have an abortion, regardless of the fetus's potential status as a human life, is not a reasoned or objective position. The author advocates for an objective evaluation of the circumstances surrounding an abortion, weighing the potential status of the fetus against other factors. They suggest that if a fetus is objectively considered a discrete human life, then its rights should take precedence over the mother's rights, as killing a human being is generally considered morally wrong. The author rejects the notion that the mother's convenience should trump the potential life of the fetus, and instead proposes that abortions should be performed as early as possible and only when there is a genuine medical justification, considering the act of abortion as a serious matter rather than a matter of convenience.

>> I completely agree with your conclusion here. As does the pro choice movement. Its funny that you and the pro-choicers have come to the same basic conclusion only you go on to think it means abortions shouldn't occur.  The whole reasoning behind the term "pro-choice" is that, in light of the fact that it isn't really clear when the little bugger is alive or not, it is the INDIVIDUAL MOTHER'S right to make that moral decision for herself.

To be sure, I haven't said that I think abortions shouldn't occur.  Rather, I have said that the outcome of a reasoned evaluation of the subject is the conclusion that they should only occur when circumstances justify their occurrence.  When the starting point is reasoned objectivity, the circumstances compelling abortion as an option are appropriately weighed against the ramifications of the aborted fetus potentially qualifying as a discrete human life.


>> If you want to make a judgement call and based on your sense of justice decide that its better to err on the rights of an unborn potential child, thats your judgement call. But it makes you "pro-life."

You have oversimplified my point and are attempting to wield this oversimplification like ram, shoving me under the "pro-life" banner.  In actual reality, I do not belong under either banner, because neither of these banners operate from a reasoned stance.  Such is the nature of polarization.

Suggesting that that the potential status of a fetus as a discrete life form should be weighed against the other practical circumstances prompting the evaluation of abortion as an option is not the same as assigning absolute rights to a fetus where no such rights can be objectively applied.


>> It means you are still assigning rights to the foetus that trump the rights of the mother. That means you are deciding, despite your admission that you don't know when the fetus is alive, that you are going to grant that fetus rights as if it were alive.

Actually, I have not advocated for granting the fetus rights as though it were alive absent of the determination that this is so.  I have advocated for deploying the potential human-life-status of the fetus as a key consideration against other circumstantial factors.  In short, I have advocated for objectivity, and I have articulated what objectivity commands of this issue.

If you were the owner of a building, and you were preparing to demolish your building, and immediately before doing so the question should arise: "what if somebody is inside the building?", it is most rational to consider whether or not someone is inside before demolishing the building.  It is not rational to throw the switch irrespective of whether or not someone is inside, citing "it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it" as justification.  If the potential exists that somebody is inside the building, the decision to demolish it must be weighed against this possibility if the moral principle that killing another human being is wrong is to be upheld.

If it is true, objectively speaking, the a fetus is a discrete life form qualifiable as a human being (somebody is inside the building), then its rights trump those of the mother (the owner of the building (womb)), as it is not anyone's right under our current moral framework to end the life of another human being.  Unless its existence inside the womb qualifies the life form as not a distinct human being, it is not the mother's inalienable right to abort the fetus under our current moral framework.  Since it is not known whether or not a distinct human being exists inside the womb, this objective reality must be taken into proportionate consideration when the decision to abort is being weighed.

It is not known if a fetus is a discrete life form qualifiable as a human being (it is not known if somebody is inside the building).  Taking this acknowledgement as a starting point, you have identified two possible vectors:

1) Those rights which cannot be objectively assigned to the fetus automatically default to the mother carrying the fetus (it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it).  She is given supreme authority over the life form, irrespective of its actual status, for the singular reason that its actual status cannot be ascertained.  Within this framework, a pregnant woman is free to terminate the life of what is potentially a discrete human being if that is the most convenient and lowest-stress option for her.  In essence, this is relegating the ramifications of terminating what is potentially a distinct human being beneath the whims, preferences, and lifestyle ambitions of the mother.

2) Upholding a preference not to risk performing the action of terminating a distinct life form qualifiable as a human being, to regard the performance of such an action with a degree of consideration for circumstances proportionate to the scope and potential ramifications of the abortion procedure (to consider whether or not someone is inside before demolishing the building).  Emergent from this is the default preference to perform abortions as early as possible, decreasing the likelihood that the action results in the termination of what may later be understood as a distinct human life, and only with medical justification, regarding the act of abortion as a serious matter, and never a matter of convenience.

If the society upholds the moral principle that killing another human being is wrong, and if the definition of what constitutes a human being cannot be ascertained, the most rational application of the moral principle in such a circumstance is to assume the fetus is a discrete living being or at least potentially operating as such, thereby making the decision to terminate its continuation a gravely serious one which must be justified by circumstances proportionate to the potential scope of that action.  To simply assign otherwise unassignable rights to the mother by default is relating to the fetus like property (it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it).  Since it is has not been ascertained if a fetus can be objectively related to in this way, behaving as though the opposite is true is not rational.


>> it is the INDIVIDUAL MOTHER'S right to make that moral decision for herself. Not the government's. Not yours. Not mine. Hers.

All feminist gusto aside, you have not provided a rational basis for defaulting the rights of what is potentially a distinct human life to the mother.  Neither have I presumed to have the right to dictate to the mother what she ought to do, nor have I expressed favour for the government to assume this right.  I am not interested in such things.  I am interested in unearthing a reasoned stance on abortion from beneath the piles of polarized, irrational rhetoric that has been heaped atop this issue since the debate first ignited.  These pithy sentences: "Not yours."  "Not mine."  "Hers." - these are strongly reminiscent of the irrational and polarized rhetoric typical to the "pro-choice" side of the debate.  It is not any more valid or meaningful than the equivalent rhetoric belted out by the "pro-life" camp.  It is time for this kind of laconic nonsense to end, and for reasoned discourse to begin.


--------------------


:poison: Dark Triangles - New Psychedelic Techno Single - Listen on Soundcloud :poison:
Gyroscope full album available SoundCloud or MySpace

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Jump to top Pages: 1 | 2 |  [ show all ]

Shop: Original Sensible Seeds Feminized Cannabis Seeds   Myyco.com Golden Teacher Liquid Culture For Sale   Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order


Similar ThreadsPosterViewsRepliesLast post
* A debate on the subject of the morality of drug use. neuro 1,944 7 02/21/03 07:10 AM
by Sclorch
* Rational vs. Irrational Beliefs
( 1 2 all )
Swami 10,779 39 01/14/05 07:58 PM
by Alan Stone
* Abortion
( 1 2 all )
absolute zero 1,547 20 11/29/05 05:21 PM
by Silversoul
* Hey challengers of "irrational" thinking gettinjiggywithit 1,411 15 11/07/05 03:53 PM
by fireworks_god
* Abortion
( 1 2 all )
Alan Stone 2,673 34 05/26/05 11:54 PM
by captiveharmony
* Slightly different view on abortion BleaK 1,323 12 12/02/02 06:19 PM
by psilocybinist
* I want to debate a "creation scientist".
( 1 2 3 4 ... 11 12 all )
Phluck 17,328 232 12/01/04 06:26 PM
by Diploid
* why we ought to debate -isms Malachi 989 10 07/02/03 04:08 AM
by Rhizoid

Extra information
You cannot start new topics / You cannot reply to topics
HTML is disabled / BBCode is enabled
Moderator: Middleman, DividedQuantum
2,789 topic views. 1 members, 51 guests and 54 web crawlers are browsing this forum.
[ Show Images Only | Sort by Score | Print Topic ]
Search this thread:

Copyright 1997-2026 Mind Media. Some rights reserved.

Generated in 0.032 seconds spending 0.007 seconds on 16 queries.