Home | Community | Message Board


This site includes paid links. Please support our sponsors.


Welcome to the Shroomery Message Board! You are experiencing a small sample of what the site has to offer. Please login or register to post messages and view our exclusive members-only content. You'll gain access to additional forums, file attachments, board customizations, encrypted private messages, and much more!

Shop: Sporeworks.EU Spores for European Microscopy   Myyco.com Isolated Cubensis Liquid Culture For Sale   Original Sensible Seeds Autoflowering Cannabis Seeds   Mushroom-Hut Mono Tub Substrate   MagicBag.co All-In-One Bags That Don't Suck   North Spore North Spore Mushroom Grow Kits & Cultivation Supplies   Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order

Jump to first unread post Pages: 1
robots.txt and other security/privacy issues
    #17765277 -

I would like to preface this post with a reminder of the sensitive nature of the information and discussions that occur on this website. We must not forget that we live in a society where information is more accessible than ever by both civilians and law enforcement. Not everyone is tech saavy, nor is everyone capable of perfect discretion.

I am inspired to suggest these things as I am quite impressed at the warning of the potential security vulnerability. Not many websites would take it that seriously, especially considering the vulnerability may not even have been maliciously exploited. That being said, the state of privacy options for a particularly privacy-sensitive website is abhorrent. One could argue privacy to be a human right, and for it to be reserved for donors is potentially unethical.

  • 1. SSL available for all users, by default. While I understand the need for donations to keep the site alive, the security of the communications to and from this site is too important to be a premium feature. It is in the best interest of both the users and the website which relies on said users for things to be as secure as possible. It is expensive and unrealistic to enable SSL on all site visitors, but it would be nice for it to be a free opt-in feature for the members here. This would help create a balance between server strain and non-members and the careless such as my former self would probably not bother/know to enable it.

  • 2. Stricter robots.txt policies if possible. Indexing of threads should be off by default for all users with an opt-in option. I have previously been denied access to an invite based website on the premise that googling the username I chose (Identical to this one) brought up this website and many others. Web history can paint a pretty clear picture at times. A search for "site:shroomery.org forums" on Google yields "about 1,570,000 results (0.20 seconds)". I know that when other sites link to a page it may be indexed despite robots.txt policies, but I am certain there are not 1.5 million different links to threads out there. As for search engine presence, there are plenty of pages and articles aside from the forums that will yield results and shroomery is likely to be one of if not the first page rankings for psilocybin mushroom related queries already, I doubt it would even impact traffic to the website.

    To illustrate, on the early pages just past all the sub forums I found:
    http://www.shroomery.org/forums/showflat.php/Number/14033629
    Entitled "Illegal drug sources... forum?", could draw some attention if people were looking. There's nothing really serious in that thread, however I figure the majority of threads are indexed. Some of those threads potentially contain photos with identifiable things in the background, as well as hosting location and metadata. A dedicated investigator can (quite easily) write a script to crawl indexed threads in search of identifiable information which could be cross referenced internally and externally, if he were so inclined.

  • 3. Shroomery history anonymizing or other tools to erase Shroomery presence. I understand the necessity for posts to remain archived, as much of the information on here lies on the forums. I also wouldn't want to give incentive to abandon the community. However, one could implement a per-thread randomized identity/dummy profiles, so as all previous posts on an account vary from thread to thread. This would for the most part preserve the integrity of the archived information while still offering a reasonable way for people to cover their tracks if need be and would not be that difficult to implement with a bit of scripting. I would personally make it a paid feature, more expensive than the simple name change as a more complete solution to internet privacy reserved for more extreme cases.

  • 3. Paid anonymous puppet accounts permitted for use with cultivation related forums only, also using per-thread unique profiles. This would allow people to be both discreet as well as participate in the wonderful community without tying their hobby to their online persona.

  • 4. Bitcoin donations. No paper trail, pretty self explanatory.


And any other information security technologies which can help protect our privacy and identity would be a welcome addition. Stay tuned for some pre-emptive arguments, sensationalist scaremongering and condescending lectures, in my (redundant) next post.


--------------------
Huuuuurrrrrr!

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: robots.txt and other security/privacy issues [Re: AlCapwn]
    #17765489 -

So, for some scaremongering:

I work at a job which sometimes involves investigating people, for financial reasons. (Oh look at the potentially identifiable information I just posted)  For the most part, I use the same tools available to anyone connected to the internet. It's pretty terrifying the amount of information that is out there on you, especially if you have any residential services or open lines of credit. I have access to detailed transactional information on millions of people all over North America (that I don't access unless necessary, of course). It's pretty obvious when you order pot seeds online. I have co-workers who have not completed high school and also have the same access as I do, if that gives you any idea of the type of people that can just see all this stuff.

I'm not the one you have to worry about, though. It's law enforcement. A simple 3 to 4 minute phone call and some simple verification is enough for us to legally provide months of information and location data. It is generally used as evidence against people in court to facilitate indictment. There are some restrictions, but in context the information flows like water. Is someone suicidal? No questions asked.

This stuff is just essentially kickin' around for the cops to pick up when needed. Given, our company is complicit as well as our customers who usually don't read the ToS to their own demise.

I know at least one of yous is going to say that it's my job to be cautious and private, but in this day and age something as simple as buying a pack of gum can reveal your geographical location. It is getting increasingly difficult to stay private. Likes on facebook make up a collage of your interests, giving much insight into your personality and affiliations. Your cellphone keeps tab of your acquaintances, location data and so on. Much of your privacy is out of our control. And for the record, it is my responsibility to remain private, but it is very difficult when the tools to do exactly that are unavailable.

I've been relatively cautious, but had I known what I know now I would have been much more cautious. My shroomery account is linked to my email address, which is linked to virtually everything that makes up my online identity and many things trace back to my real world identity. This is why I have been mostly absent from this website, as well as abandoning the pursuit of mycological knowledge.

I implore all you idealists and counterculturists to take this stuff seriously lest it bite you in the ass a couple of years down the road. People on this site take great risks in sharing their work on this website, and ask nothing in return. All that I ask is that these people be granted as much sanctuary from authoritarian forces and potential enemies as is reasonably possible.

I'm not being paranoid either, this corner of the interwebs is fairly low drama, I'm just concerned with the privacy of the community as a whole.

And finally, even MORE fearmongering:


--------------------
Huuuuurrrrrr!

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: robots.txt and other security/privacy issues [Re: AlCapwn]
    #17766306 -

Auto-Summary
The post addresses various suggestions regarding security, privacy, and monetization on a forum, explaining why certain features like universal SSL encryption or Bitcoin payments aren't feasible. The author outlines technical limitations, such as SSL performance issues without load balancing and the trade-off between security and performance when using Cloudflare. They also discuss the business model, emphasizing that free users contribute through content and visibility, while paid supporters get additional features. The author acknowledges privacy concerns but argues that many security measures, like secure PMs and proxying, are already in place. They also mention the challenges of implementing new features, like per-thread anonymity, due to potential misuse and the difficulty of balancing accessibility with security. Despite the limitations, the author expresses pride in the forum's security offerings and commitment to maintaining a balance between openness and user safety.

I really appreciate your taking the time to write out all these suggestions, and your justifications for requesting them. This isn't the first time we've heard many of these ideas and I'll try to address them individually. I must warn you though, you may not like my answers. :frown:

Quote:
SSL available for all users, by default. While I understand the need for donations to keep the site alive, the security of the communications to and from this site is too important to be a premium feature. It is in the best interest of both the users and the website which relies on said users for things to be as secure as possible. It is expensive and unrealistic to enable SSL on all site visitors, but it would be nice for it to be a free opt-in feature for the members here. This would help create a balance between server strain and non-members and the careless such as my former self would probably not bother/know to enable it.



You rightly point out that we don't have the hardware capacity to support everyone browsing with SSL, as I talked about in this post. When we installed the new servers I did some load tests to compare regular HTTP, SSL, and SSL accelerated by our load balancer. SSL without any acceleration is literally more than 100x slower once we start to run out of entropy. So for every visitor with SSL enabled, it's like having over 100 without. The good news is that with the load balancer handling SSL, performance is practically normal, so once we get that in place it should be more practical to offer for everyone.

Another thing I should mention is that we use Cloudflare now, and they offer support for two kinds of SSL configurations. The default encrypts traffic to and from their CDN, but then uses an insecure connection to communicate with our server. We could switch to this and enable SSL for everyone right now, since Cloudflare would be handling the load. But instead we use end-to-end SSL, where the connection is also encrypted between our server and Cloudflare. This is more secure, but it negates any performance benefits. However, I feel that it's worth it because when people see the lock icon, they expect their connection to be fully encrypted at every point in the transmission.

Speaking frankly, I also don't think SSL really offers much benefit for your average user besides securing logins from sniffing on public networks and that sort of thing (which we already do). If you're trying to hide your activity from your boss or something, it's not going to be very effective against any modern monitoring software since it just forces you to accept a self-signed certificate to use the internet. If you're running from the FBI, you'd better believe they have their own root cert and won't be dissuaded by a little SSL. I'm just having trouble thinking of a scenario where additional SSL would offer much protection. Our free options like secure PMs and proxying offsite images are much more effective at protecting private data in common scenarios, but most people don't even use them! :tongue:

Quote:
Stricter robots.txt policies if possible. Indexing of threads should be off by default for all users with an opt-in option. I have previously been denied access to an invite based website on the premise that googling the username I chose (Identical to this one) brought up this website and many others. Web history can paint a pretty clear picture at times. A search for "site:shroomery.org forums" on Google yields "about 1,570,000 results (0.20 seconds)". I know that when other sites link to a page it may be indexed despite robots.txt policies, but I am certain there are not 1.5 million different links to threads out there. As for search engine presence, there are plenty of pages and articles aside from the forums that will yield results and shroomery is likely to be one of if not the first page rankings for psilocybin mushroom related queries already, I doubt it would even impact traffic to the website.

To illustrate, on the early pages just past all the sub forums I found:
http://www.shroomery.org/forums/showflat.php/Number/14033629
Entitled "Illegal drug sources... forum?", could draw some attention if people were looking. There's nothing really serious in that thread, however I figure the majority of threads are indexed. Some of those threads potentially contain photos with identifiable things in the background, as well as hosting location and metadata. A dedicated investigator can (quite easily) write a script to crawl indexed threads in search of identifiable information which could be cross referenced internally and externally, if he were so inclined.



It's not something I'm thrilled about in modern society, but we're all adults here, and I think it should be obvious that when we receive a service for free, it's because we are the product. It's not like Facebook or Google are running their sites out of the goodness of their hearts. Even if everybody worked for no pay, there are fixed hosting and bandwidth expenses, and our bottom line is a concern which cannot be ignored. So, for people who wish to browse the site at no cost, they "pay" by contributing their posts to our message board and increasing our search engine visibility, which in turn brings in more advertising. It does make a difference; "some random thread found via Google" is (in aggregate) our largest source of traffic. Supporters have the option to prevent their threads from appearing in search engines because they've paid for their use of the Shroomery with actual money.

Also, we automatically strip metadata from all uploads, so if people use our hosting it shouldn't be a problem. If they choose to take an incriminating photo tagged with GPS coordinates and upload it to a third-party site, I don't think we're obligated to protect that. You can't make things totally idiot-proof but we do have the Security and Safety forum to bring attention to these types of concerns.

Quote:
Shroomery history anonymizing or other tools to erase Shroomery presence. I understand the necessity for posts to remain archived, as much of the information on here lies on the forums. I also wouldn't want to give incentive to abandon the community. However, one could implement a per-thread randomized identity/dummy profiles, so as all previous posts on an account vary from thread to thread. This would for the most part preserve the integrity of the archived information while still offering a reasonable way for people to cover their tracks if need be and would not be that difficult to implement with a bit of scripting. I would personally make it a paid feature, more expensive than the simple name change as a more complete solution to internet privacy reserved for more extreme cases.



We don't want to offer this feature because it breaks things like the ability to hide all of a user's posts, or search through them. Plus a lot of our members are extremely paranoid and would probably use it and regret it. I could see offering it priced at something like $100 to weed out all but the most legitimate cases, but then we'd be accused of trying to profiteer off security, and extort people when they're in trouble. It's easier to just make our policy clear up front, and allow everyone to edit their posts indefinitely so they always have the option to redact anything they've said.

Quote:
Paid anonymous puppet accounts permitted for use with cultivation related forums only, also using per-thread unique profiles. This would allow people to be both discreet as well as participate in the wonderful community without tying their hobby to their online persona.



We already offer free anonymous grow puppets. These are created by an admin, so they are not linked to the user's IP address, and the cultivation forums are excluded from our proxy checks, so they can be used with TOR or a VPN or whatever. Per-thread unique profiles is an interesting idea, but that's basically the same as enabling the "post anonymously" feature in all forums, and I'm not sure our non-paying members would be thrilled with that.

Quote:
Bitcoin donations. No paper trail, pretty self explanatory.



As a libertarian, I love bitcoins as an alternate currency without central control or oversight. As a programmer, I admire the ingenuity and elegance that went into the system. But as a businessman, I simply can't make a case for accepting them. The vast majority of our income is from advertisers. Supporter payments go towards features like e-mail and image hosting, and at the end of the day they just don't bring in a lot of profits. If someone wants to support the site but they can only pay with bitcoins, the best thing they can do for us is literally just remain an unpaid member, and maybe spread the word about the site, or contribute content, or remember to order from our sponsors or something. There is no possible way that the cost of implementing bitcoin checkout would ever be recouped with the additional subscriptions it might bring in. It's not like we're the Silk Road here, and I really doubt most people would go through the trouble of using bitcoins when the most common complaint is no Paypal support and the hassle of creating a Google Checkout account.

Anyway sorry for the wall of text and the possibly unsatisfying answers, but we really do try to prioritize privacy and security. I believe we offer more comprehensive security options than any comparable forum, and I'm proud of that. A lot of the features we offer for free, like secure PMs and proxied offsite images, aren't available on any other counter-culture sites to the best of my knowledge. Obviously, there are conflicting interests when you want to run a site which is relatively open and accessible to newcomers, while remaining discreet and keeping existing members secure. Everybody wants the Shroomery to be a walled garden once they get here, but then they wouldn't have found it in the first place. We do our best to strike a good balance, and a lot of thought and discussion has gone into all the issues you bring up. That doesn't mean there's no room for improvement, but it isn't something we take lightly either. I will certainly keep your suggestions in mind, and some of them (like SSL for everyone) are really just a matter of time. :cheers:

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: robots.txt and other security/privacy issues [Re: Ythan]
    #17766589 -

Wow, thanks for taking the time and writing such a comprehensive post. (Dont you have anything better to do?:awesome:) I apologize for underestimating the challenges in operating a fairly large website and the harsh criticism. I'm glad SSL access may be freely available somewhere down the road. I'm also quite satisfied with some security features that I was not aware of (I did look around, promise), particularly the free puppets and the stripping of metadata.

I can gladly work with that. A namechange and a free puppet will take care of past and future posts, respectively.

Only thing I still dislike is the indexing of the forums by default, but I understand that it generates necessary revenue. Hopefully someday there will be a more elegant solution to that issue.

Finally, on why I place so much importance on SSL is mainly to defeat the growing privacy violations introduced by large scale DPI technologies, particularly by AT&T and the NSA. While it would not prevent them from reading my data were it specifically targeted, it would make it difficult to identify my data from a large stream. If we want any sort of privacy in the coming years, adoption of encrypted data streams by default will be increasingly necessary. I guess i'll have to quit being a cheapskate for the time being.


--------------------
Huuuuurrrrrr!

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Jump to top Pages: 1

Shop: Sporeworks.EU Spores for European Microscopy   Myyco.com Isolated Cubensis Liquid Culture For Sale   Original Sensible Seeds Autoflowering Cannabis Seeds   Mushroom-Hut Mono Tub Substrate   MagicBag.co All-In-One Bags That Don't Suck   North Spore North Spore Mushroom Grow Kits & Cultivation Supplies   Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order


Similar ThreadsPosterViewsRepliesLast post
* New Feature: Secure Private Messages!
( 1 2 3 4 all )
YthanA 15,600 76 05/03/15 03:33 PM
by milonix
* Issues with activating supporter account MOTH 816 4 12/06/05 12:32 AM
by OneMoreRobot3021
* secure pm problem, 2 computers and one key? ZippoZM 1,191 12 07/21/05 10:06 PM
by Ythan
* SECURITY ISSUES SHOULD BE DEALT WITH IMMEDIATELY World Spirit 2,795 15 05/16/02 06:31 PM
by World Spirit
* Secure Private Messages delta9 1,423 11 08/13/05 05:45 PM
by delta9
* Legal Issues tlearyfan 916 7 12/11/04 12:05 AM
by tlearyfan
* Legal Security? Anonymous 894 2 05/16/03 07:07 PM
by Papaver
* An added Security measure for all members World Spirit 892 8 12/30/05 11:58 PM
by theuser

Extra information
You cannot start new topics / You cannot reply to topics
HTML is disabled / BBCode is enabled
Moderator: Ythan, Thor, Seuss, geokills
515 topic views. 0 members, 8 guests and 2 web crawlers are browsing this forum.
[ Show Images Only | Sort by Score | Print Topic ]
Search this thread:

Copyright 1997-2026 Mind Media. Some rights reserved.

Generated in 0.023 seconds spending 0.004 seconds on 16 queries.