Auto-SummaryThis forum post criticizes the effectiveness and motivations of therapists, arguing that many therapists may have personal issues and are more interested in making money than helping clients. The author shares anecdotal evidence from meeting a few therapists and suggests that individuals should be cautious about long-term counseling, as therapists may profit from ongoing sessions. The post questions the premise that therapists study "fucked up people" and argues that if a therapist's approach works, clients would see improvement quickly. It also emphasizes the importance of self-improvement and suggests that therapy should focus on prescribing medication only for severe chemical imbalances, not for general emotional issues. The author criticizes modern psychotherapy's reliance on treating depression and argues that pain can sometimes be motivating for change. The post concludes by suggesting that setting time deadlines for personal goals can help overcome apathy and depression, implying that acceptance should only be pursued when change is impossible.
MushroomTrip said:
Quote: I think most of the therapists you could go to are more fucked up in the head than you are. From the ones that I've met, I think they were fucked up in College, so naturally became interested in the study of fucked up people. They usually recommend long term counseling for everyone, because if they actually fix your problem you will stop coming in and paying them every week.
Do you have any source for these ridiculous claims?
As I stated above, my claims are based "from the ones that I've met" which is about a half dozen or so. No, I didn't go out and perform a large scientific study on hundreds of therapists with double blindes etc. before I reached the conclusion that they are fucked in the head.
Quote: While there might be some therapist that try to do that, I honestly don't see how you reached the conclusion that "most" of them are like that, and how you can state that they are "fucked up", which is the reason why they chose the "study of fucked up people". 
Sit back and think about it for a little while and I trust that you can see the sense in this. If a person has major mental problems and a decent IQ, does it not make sense to you that this person would be more predisposed than the average person to want to study such things? I don't think it's that much of a stretch.
Quote: I don't know about you, but I'm aware that each person can choose the therapist they want, and they can choose one who's specialized in short therapies. Also if the OP won't notice any change or improvement with him in a few weeks, he can just drop the therapy but also take to consideration that maybe he wasn't actually motivated to change himself.
In other words if there's no results than he should take into consideration that it's not the therapists fault? Or maybe he should just save his $$$ and work on improving his life on his own.
Quote:
Quote: Now I'm not saying people shouldn't go if they have bi-polar, or schizophrenia, or something similar that the therapist possibly may be able to prescribe something for.
Quote: So people should only go to see a therapist so that they can get prescriptions to medication? 
What is so shocking about this? If you have a chemical imbalance then yes, you may need to go to someone that can prescribe medicine.
Quote: No, nobody SHOULD feel depressed, as the thought "boy, my life sucks" IS the result of depression, and not the other way around.
This is the major fallacy that modern psychotherapy is based on. Why do you think it is in human nature to feel depressed? If the emotion has no survival value, why have we evolved to have this emotion?
Let's say a person is a talented musician, but they decide to sit around in an office cubicle all day long doing paperwork that is not fulfilling to them, and then they go straight home and do no socializing, don't you think its natural that said person would feel depressed? If they can take some kind of pill or do some kind of therapy that makes the depression go away and makes their situation more tolerable so they can keep doing it, I fail to see how that is a good thing. Pain is not always negative because sometimes it motivates us to do something different.
Quote: It is very possible to simply acknowledge that some aspects of your life are not so satisfactory, without feeling depressed, you know? Why put yourself though all that hassle of feeling bad and isolated from the world, when it serves absolutely any purpose? Perhaps you can explain how depression can MOTIVATE one to change their lives for the better, when one of the most basic traits of depression are incapacitating, while, if instead of feeling depressed and having your mind clouded, you can think your way out of an undesired life situation and at the same time remaining able to enjoy all the other good aspects of your life?
Because most people who are not in pain are less motivated to change. Yes, depression does produce incapacitating emotional states that one has to fight against to escape the pain. That's why I recommend the exercise and the planning for a better life. The therapists will tell you to come in and talk to them once a week, what good is it? I'd say most people would be better off to go camping by themselves for a week and eat a bunch of mushrooms and figure it out.
Quote:
Quote: In my experience I've found that it helps to set time deadlines to accomplish the changes...such as within two years I will have a girlfriend and will be living somewhere I like, will have a better job, etc.
I think that partially it's exactly those dead-lines that create a stare of discomfort and can lead to depression, especially in the moment where they are unfulfilled and the person who practiced them starts feeling like a loser. The more shoulds exist in someone's life, the more obstructed the path to acceptance is. 
If your life sucks and you can change it, then acceptance is the last thing you should seek. If you can't change it, then yes, acceptance is good. The OP's life sucks right now, the longer he accepts it the longer it will continue to suck. Maybe others will have a different experience, but in my life when I've been staring into the abyss, setting time deadlines really helped to fight the apathy and got the ball rolling, your mileage may vary.
|