malcom43 said: Just to set the record straight, under the federal constitution in the USA, warrantless arrests are permissable for very minor criminal conduct, i.e. not whereing a seatbelt, even when the maximum statutory penalty does not include a custodial sentance.
THerefore, under sepperate authority which I can't cite right now but will if anyone seriously disagrees, an officer could simply arrest your ass and do a search of the car incident to the areest, when you refuse to consent to search for your speeding ticket. See: ATWATER V. LAGO VISTA (99-1408) 532 U.S. 318 (2001)
IMO, you should still refuse consent to preserve the issue of reasonableness, and to generally excercise your rights/ piss off johhny law.
This is not entirely correct. In order to conduct a search incident to arrest, the key point is that the officer has to intend to fully carry out the arrest and actually take you down to the station for booking regardless of whether the search turns up anything or not. He can't arrest you for failing to signal or speeding or whatever, put you in the back of his car, perform the search, and then let you go. The search will not be admissable.
And aside from this, just because in the case you cited someone was arrested for a minor traffic violation and the federal courts upheld it does not mean that it is legal to do this under state law in every state. The U.S. constitution provides a floor for rights, not a ceiling. In a majority of states, no authority exists to arrest a person for many minor traffic violations, as they are considered civil infractions rather than misdemeanors, and/or the state courts or legislatures decided this was not allowable under state law.
And also, the well-known case you cited is not all representative of the way police function. There is something known as abuse of discretion in law enforcement as well as policy rules established by the local departments. You're simply not going to see police arresting someone for going five miles over the speed limit and taking them down to the station to have them charged because someone refused consent to search. The policeman will face discipline.
As to the basic idea put forth in this thread, if you have drugs or other contraband in your car and get pulled over for a traffic violation and the police say something like, "Is it alright if I search your car?", do not say yes! And keep your crap in the trunk of a 'car' if you really need to take it with you somewhere. If you've had a few drinks and are unsure whether you might be over the limit, when the cop comes to your window at night and says, "How much have you had to drink tonight?", do not answer by saying "just a few", because the officer is trained to ask this question just to get you to incriminate yourself. Some argue that you should just be honest and kiss butt, but then again realize that almost everyone does this and every week in the paper you see a long list of people arrested for these violations. It's a safe bet that most of these people contributed to their own arrest and prosecution by volunteering and admitting to their own crimes, and were hoping that if they kissed butt and cooperated they wouldn't get arrested. Again, police everywhere are trained to do this: get the driver to incriminate himself, and play good cop. It's ubiquitous practice, and people fall for it all the time.
Edited by danr49 (04/28/07 05:03 PM)
|