Auto-SummaryIn the realm of car searches, understanding your rights is crucial. Police need probable cause to search a car without consent, which is often obtained through a "consent search" following a routine traffic violation. Many drivers unknowingly agree to these searches, but doing so can lead to trouble if illegal substances are found. Consent searches are the most common, with most contraband cases arising from them. However, if you have drugs in your car and the officer asks for consent, refuse. Instead, lie about any bulges in your pockets to avoid incriminating yourself. Probable cause searches require more substantial evidence, often involving suspicious items or a drug dog's alert. Trunk searches are generally not allowed without probable cause, except in "search incident to arrest" scenarios. If you have drugs in the passenger compartment, the best course is to ask a passenger to conceal it, as any search of their body is likely a consent search. Remember, never volunteer incriminating information and assert your right to remain silent if arrested.
(This could use some work and revision; it's intended to just be a brief overview):
Police must have probable cause to search the car. Vague suspicion is not good enough.
Most searches in cars that turn up drugs lack probable cause altogether. The searches are legal because the ignorant driver consents to it. The vast majority of all car searches turning up contraband begin with a routine traffic violation followed by the police officer "asking" the driver if he can search his car. And for some reason, the drivers give permission most of the time.
Now, if you have nothing in your car to hide, agreeing to what's known as a "consent search" may actually help you avoid a ticket by being cooperative. But if you have mushrooms, coke or whatever in your car and the police pull you over for speeding, do not say "yes" when the cop asks if he may search your car. Be happy with the speeding ticket. Unless he sees something to give him probable cause (example white bag of powder, bong, etc), he cannot search your car unless he is arresting you for some reason.
Some people may have stories which contradict this, but the law on this has been evolving over the last 15 years explaining the differences in these stories, and this is where it currently stands at the present time due to recent decisions by the U.S. Supreme Court overruling state laws.
A couple other notes: store contraband in the trunk, not the passenger capartment. In a search incident to arrest, the trunk will end up being searched eventually anyway as part of an inventory search after being impounded. But in searches using probable cause, in 'most' cases the right to search the car will not extend to the trunk. Usually the officer will tell the person to get out of the car, and search the passenger compartment.
But then the officer will "ask" the driver if he may search the trunk. He usually gets to, because the driver agrees to it.
After being pulled over for anything, the officer has the right to ask the occupants to step out of the car so he can do a quick pat-down. The purpose of this is to scan for weapons, not drugs. If the officer feels something like a soft pouch while doing the Terry-like pat-down, he does not have the right to order you to give it to him. He may very likely, however, "ask" you if you will. At this point, the driver usually agrees. Or, the cop may ask the driver what is in his pocket. If the driver responds by saying he has contraband or paraphenalia, etc, this will *give* the officer probable cause so that he can extend the search beyond a consent search into a probable cause search. So, lie when asked what the bulge in your jacket/pants pocket is.
So, to make a long story short, if you have drugs in your car, and the officer asks you permission to search, don't say "yes" for God's sake.
Finally, do not ever volunteer any information at all that serves to incriminate you. Everyone's heard the phrase "anything you say can and will be used against you" on tv a million times, but for some reason people just don't get it. Prior to being arrested, there is no right to miranda warnings, so don't say anything dumb.
If you are arrested, don't say anything. "Remain silent". Police will often try to play "good cop" and try to get you to incriminate yourself. Never say anything until talking to an attorney. If you want to fully secure your miranda rights and get police to stop trying to question you after being arrested, assert your right to an attorney rather than saying nothing at all. At this point, no further questioning by police is allowable. If you simply assert your right to remain silent, police may legally wait a while and try to question you again.
In summary, there are three main types of car searches:
1) Consent Searches (which comprise the vast majority of searches turning up contraband). With consent searches, drivers get themselves into trouble by agreeing to allow the police to search their cars even though the police cannot force them to. These usually start with a routine traffic violation like speeding. When the officer comes to the window, he "asks" the driver if he may search. The driver often mistakingly thinks s/he doesn't have a choice, and agrees.
2) Probable Cause Searches: Probable cause is required to search without consent; i.e. probable cause for believing a crime was committed. In order for there to be probable cause it must be more likely than not that a search will turn up incriminating evidence. Typically this may involve the officer spotting something in the car through the window with his flashlight that looks like a liquor bottle or beer can, or a weapon. A drug dog may also sniff and provide probable cause. Police can also get probable cause if you say something to give them probable cause. In this case, consent is not necessary to search, although the police may still ask for consent because it will eliminate any future argument over whether there was sufficient probable cause. Typically, probable cause searches cannot get the officer into the trunk. Usually the officer will "ask" before opening the trunk. For this reason, contraband should always be stored in the trunk. Actually, it should never be in the car at all. If a drug dog smells something in the trunk, btw, the trunk exception won't save you. You'll be detained until a warrant can be procured, and even if the warrant request is still in process, the search of the trunk may be upheld under the doctrine of "inevitable discovery".
3) Search incident to arrest. Here, the police arrest someone, say for a dui. After putting this person in the back of the patrol car they may legally search the entire passenger compartment even if the crime arrested for has nothing to do with suspicion of contraband. (Say, for instance, you pushed an old lady down in the Wal-Mart parking lot and then drove off and were pulled over.) After the car is impounded, the trunk may be searched as well.
What to do if you have drugs in the passenger compartment and are about to be pulled over for dui or another crime: If you see those lights come on, the best thing to do if you can't get rid of it is to ask a passenger in the car (if there is one) if s/he is willing to to put the joint or whatever on his/her person. The passenger will not be arrested for your crime of driving under the influence, and any search or request to produce whatever's on the body of a passenger is likely to be a consent search and voluntary. The passenger should not, however, claim posession of any alcohol, weapon, or anything else in the car that cannot be concealed, because this will provide probable cause to arrest the passenger.
Edited by danr49 (03/31/07 02:27 PM)
|