Home | Community | Message Board

MushroomMan Mycology
This site includes paid links. Please support our sponsors.


Welcome to the Shroomery Message Board! You are experiencing a small sample of what the site has to offer. Please login or register to post messages and view our exclusive members-only content. You'll gain access to additional forums, file attachments, board customizations, encrypted private messages, and much more!

Shop: Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order   Myyco.com Golden Teacher Liquid Culture For Sale   MagicBag.co All-In-One Bags That Don't Suck, Certified Organic All-In-One Grow Bags by Magic Bag

Jump to first unread post Pages: | 1 | 2  [ show all ]
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18031653 -

Auto-Summary
The author argues for a reasoned, objective approach to the abortion debate, emphasizing that the potential status of a fetus as a discrete human life should be considered alongside other circumstances. They reject the notion that the mother's rights automatically supersede the potential life of the fetus, arguing that the fetus's rights should only be upheld if it can be objectively proven to be a distinct human being. The author criticizes the pro-choice stance for being subjective and argues that a rational, non-dualistic approach to the issue is necessary. They also reject the idea that the mother's convenience or lifestyle preferences should be the primary factor in the decision to abort, instead advocating for a serious consideration of the potential ramifications of terminating a potentially distinct human life.

Ped said:
>> I completely agree with your conclusion here. As does the pro choice movement. Its funny that you and the pro-choicers have come to the same basic conclusion only you go on to think it means abortions shouldn't occur.  The whole reasoning behind the term "pro-choice" is that, in light of the fact that it isn't really clear when the little bugger is alive or not, it is the INDIVIDUAL MOTHER'S right to make that moral decision for herself.

To be sure, I haven't said that I think abortions shouldn't occur.  Rather, I have said that the outcome of a reasoned evaluation of the subject is the conclusion that they should only occur when circumstances justify their occurrence.  When the starting point is reasoned objectivity, the circumstances compelling abortion as an option are appropriately weighed against the ramifications of the aborted fetus potentially qualifying as a discrete human life.



You can start a discussion from a point of reasoned objectivity and still end up in a place of subjectivity. As in such questions as "when does life begin?" or "what is the best art?" It is a rational conclusion to allow for subjectivity.

Quote:
You have oversimplified my point and are attempting to wield this oversimplification like ram, shoving me under the "pro-life" banner.  In actual reality, I do not belong under either banner, because neither of these banners operate from a reasoned stance.  Such is the nature of polarization.

Suggesting that that the potential status of a fetus as a discrete life form should be weighed against the other practical circumstances prompting the evaluation of abortion as an option is not the same as assigning absolute rights to a fetus where no such rights can be objectively applied.



What you are calling for is that people weigh the potential status of a fetus as a discrete life form before abortions are performed. Let's say hypothetically, everyone did, to the degree to which your demands were satisfied, and yet still abortions were performed to the extent that they are today. Would you be happy? My point is that you can be anti-abortion and be pro-choice, just like you can be anti-gun ownership and still think people should be free to own guns.

Quote:
Actually, I have not advocated for granting the fetus rights as though it were alive absent of the determination that this is so.  I have advocated for deploying the potential human-life-status of the fetus as a key consideration against other circumstantial factors.  In short, I have advocated for objectivity, and I have articulated what objectivity commands of this issue.



All you have articulated, to me, is what everyone who isn't a right-to-lifer or a subscriber to catholic doctrine already knows, which is that we don't have a clear black and white definition of when life begins. I agree, and support your logic. I also agree that anyone getting or performing an abortion should bear this in mind. For me, this all fits solidly within the pro-choice side of the political duality, and is rhetoric that the pro-choice side has been using for years. Your refusal to take a stance on the legal issue of abortion I guess is what is actually ultimately confounding. To me, at least.

Quote:
If you were the owner of a building, and you were preparing to demolish your building, and immediately before doing so the question should arise: "what if somebody is inside the building?", it is most rational to consider whether or not someone is inside before demolishing the building.  It is not rational to throw the switch irrespective of whether or not someone is inside, citing "it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it" as justification.  If the potential exists that somebody is inside the building, the decision to demolish it must be weighed against this possibility if the moral principle that killing another human being is wrong is to be upheld.



This is a bad analogy. A building is just physical property, and in your analogy its easy enough to check the building for any stragglers, remove them, send them on their merry way, and then destroy the building later. Surely a rational person would understand the many differences between property in terms of a building and one's own body. Your body is not your property, it is you yourself. And a child isn't just some stranger who shows up. I'm not willing to go along with you on this analogy. It doesn't hold up. Let's stick to the issue at hand instead, unless you can come up with a better analogy.

Quote:
If it is true, objectively speaking, the a fetus is a discrete life form qualifiable as a human being (somebody is inside the building), then its rights trump those of the mother (the owner of the building (womb)), as it is not anyone's right under our current moral framework to end the life of another human being.  Unless its existence inside the womb qualifies the life form as not a distinct human being, it is not the mother's inalienable right to abort the fetus under our current moral framework.  Since it is not known whether or not a distinct human being exists inside the womb, this objective reality must be taken into proportionate consideration when the decision to abort is being weighed.



I think its pretty obvious that the fetus is not a distinct form of life, even if it is "alive." Hence more of the grey area. If you ask me, an unborn child in its mother are a fascinating union that smash our duality of "single life form." They are single and separate. But again, I don't insist that everyone adopt this definition of life. I insist that, in the absence of a clear definition of life, we allow individuals the choice to come that conclusion for themselves. How do you not see this as rational? Is it so irrational to have morally ambiguous questions solved on the ground level without a dictate coming from either a pope or a president or a philosopher king? :shrug:

Quote:
It is not known if a fetus is a discrete life form qualifiable as a human being (it is not known if somebody is inside the building).  Taking this acknowledgement as a starting point, you have identified two possible vectors:

1) Those rights which cannot be objectively assigned to the fetus automatically default to the mother carrying the fetus (it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it).  She is given supreme authority over the life form, irrespective of its actual status, for the singular reason that its actual status cannot be ascertained.  Within this framework, a pregnant woman is free to terminate the life of what is potentially a discrete human being if that is the most convenient and lowest-stress option for her.  In essence, this is relegating the ramifications of terminating what is potentially a distinct human being beneath the whims, preferences, and lifestyle ambitions of the mother.




Now your subjectivity is showing. "convenient?" "lowest-stress?" "whims?" You've just painted every potential abortive mother as a derivative stereotype. She's not an individual making a difficult informed choice, no. She's lazy. She's made a mistake by not being responsible. She doesn't want a child because she wants life to be easy. How sluttish she is. How UNINTELLIGENT. How irrational, unlike us debaters here in our ivory tower.

I think, if you truly want to be objective, it would pay for you to recognize the way you picture a potential abortive mother. I also find it interesting that you assume that what you have been calling for this whole time "that the outcome of a reasoned evaluation of the subject is the conclusion that they should only occur when circumstances justify their occurrence" is something that mothers-to-be haven't done. Maybe they all do...and get the abortion. How would you know? I would venture most people thinking about getting an abortion have thought about it at least as much as you have.

Quote:
2) Upholding a preference not to risk performing the action of terminating a distinct life form qualifiable as a human being, to regard the performance of such an action with a degree of consideration for circumstances proportionate to the scope and potential ramifications of the abortion procedure (to consider whether or not someone is inside before demolishing the building).  Emergent from this is the default preference to perform abortions as early as possible, decreasing the likelihood that the action results in the termination of what may later be understood as a distinct human life, and only with medical justification, regarding the act of abortion as a serious matter, and never a matter of convenience.

If the society upholds the moral principle that killing another human being is wrong, and if the definition of what constitutes a human being cannot be ascertained, the most rational application of the moral principle in such a circumstance is to assume the fetus is a discrete living being or at least potentially operating as such, thereby making the decision to terminate its continuation a gravely serious one which must be justified by circumstances proportionate to the potential scope of that action.  To simply assign otherwise unassignable rights to the mother by default is relating to the fetus like property (it's my building, and it's my right to demolish it).  Since it is has not been ascertained if a fetus can be objectively related to in this way, behaving as though the opposite is true is not rational.



It's perfectly rational, as I've stated multiple times, to let individuals decide for themselves what is moral in situations of moral ambiguity. You may not like it, but its rational.

Quote:
All feminist gusto aside, you have not provided a rational basis for defaulting the rights of what is potentially a distinct human life to the mother.



The rationale is that "potential" is not sufficient in rights based law. We know that an adult woman is an individual and therefore has rights. We aren't "assigning" new or special rights to her now that she is pregnant. She is merely exercising rights she has had her whole life. The right to do what she wants with her body. That she has a child growing in her is definitely something she should consider before getting an abortion. I hope she does. But its her choice. It has nothing to do with feminist gusto. This individual just happens to be a woman. Does that threaten you?

Quote:
Neither have I presumed to have the right to dictate to the mother what she ought to do, nor have I expressed favour for the government to assume this right.  I am not interested in such things.  I am interested in unearthing a reasoned stance on abortion from beneath the piles of polarized, irrational rhetoric that has been heaped atop this issue since the debate first ignited.  These pithy sentences: "Not yours."  "Not mine."  "Hers." - these are strongly reminiscent of the irrational and polarized rhetoric typical to the "pro-choice" side of the debate.  It is not any more valid or meaningful than the equivalent rhetoric belted out by the "pro-life" camp.  It is time for this kind of laconic nonsense to end, and for reasoned discourse to begin.



Well its easy to be pithy and succinct when your argument isn't bringing anything new to the table and then you demand that everyone follow your lead and debate you on your own terms. Its great to have a rational debate on abortion. That you have an unshakeable faith that it will lead us away from a dualistic stand-off on legal issues is, I think, simply inaccurate. A pro-choice stance is, in my view, IMPLIED by rationality. I've tried to show that, but you keep wanting to assign rights to unborn children, but then dance away from that conclusion by saying that you want a rational non-dualistic debate. If you keep trying to prove that a fetus is potentially alive and therefore its rights trump a mother's right to abort, you are making at least an implied if not explicit pro-life argument. This is familiar territory. I still haven't encountered anything new or groundbreaking. Same old argument.


--------------------
:hst:
Society in every form is a blessing,
but government at its best is but a necessary evil
 
- Thomas Paine

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: gluke bastid]
    #18033063 -

Auto-Summary
The post argues that abortion should be approached objectively, considering the potential life of the fetus. It criticizes the "pro-choice" movement for conflating the issue with feminism and ignoring the possibility of the fetus being a distinct human life. The author asserts that the right to not be killed supersedes the right to not be pregnant, and that the decision to abort must be weighed against the objective reality of the fetus's potential life status. The post concludes that fewer abortions would occur if the objective reality of the fetus's potential life was considered, and that the current polarized rhetoric surrounding the issue is preventing a rational discussion.

>> Now your subjectivity is showing. "convenient?" "lowest-stress?" "whims?" You've just painted every potential abortive mother as a derivative stereotype. She's not an individual making a difficult informed choice, no. She's lazy. She's made a mistake by not being responsible. She doesn't want a child because she wants life to be easy.

A high number of abortions are performed for convenience, to preserve a lifestyle preference, to defer responsibility for reckless behaviour, or because of sheer lazy selfishness.  This is a fact.  It is actually true that a high number of abortions are performed for these reasons.

If it is considered that the fetus is potentially a distinct human being with the capacity to undergo the human experience in even the faintest way, all of these are astoundingly immoral reasons to have an abortion.  That these reasons are commonly invoked to perform an abortions is purely a result of the "pro-choice" movement conflating the issue with feminism, annihilating all discussion as to what constitutes a new human life, what potential exists that a fetus qualifies as a human life, what the resulting ramifications of the abortion procedure are, displacing all rational arguments to that end with feminist rhetoric. 

It is also true that a high number of women approach the question of abortion gravely, making a difficult and informed choice, and inasmuch as these women correspond properly with the potential ramifications of the procedure in an independent manner, not swayed by the drum-pounding of the "choice" and "life" camps, there's no cause for anyone to object to that.


>> It's perfectly rational, as I've stated multiple times, to let individuals decide for themselves what is moral in situations of moral ambiguity. You may not like it, but its rational.

This is not correct.  The incorrectness of this statement has nothing to do with personal preference and everything to do with its incorrectness.

Abortion is not a matter of individuals deciding for themselves.  It is a matter of individuals deciding for themselves and for what may potentially exist as an additional, discrete human life.

The right to not be killed supersedes the right to not be pregnant.  If it is even potentially true that the fetus exists as a discrete life form with the right not to be killed, this dramatically affects the moral and ethical ramifications of the abortion procedure.

If it remains a possibility that an unborn fetus qualifies as a distinct human being, defaulting it's right to life to the mother necessarily ignores this possibility and therefore fails to correspond with the abiding reality that the life-status of the fetus is unknown.  Failing to correspond with reality is not rational, because a person cannot be rational while failing to correspond with reality.

If the decision to abort is to be approached objectively, the ambiguity of the fetus' status as human being must be related to objectively.  When this ambiguity is related to objectively, the notion "it's my body and my right" is not an objective one.  The notion "it's my body and my right" only arises when the question is conflated with feminism, which really has absolutely nothing to do with this issue, as it is the life status of a separate human being which is the primary consideration, with the personal preferences of the mother as a secondary consideration.


>> I think its pretty obvious that the fetus is not a distinct form of life, even if it is "alive." Hence more of the grey area. If you ask me, an unborn child in its mother are a fascinating union that smash our duality of "single life form." They are single and separate. But again, I don't insist that everyone adopt this definition of life. I insist that, in the absence of a clear definition of life, we allow individuals the choice to come that conclusion for themselves. How do you not see this as rational?

Very simple: a deficiency of insight into reality does not somehow translate into the inalienable right to decide what reality is and isn't.  Since the reality in question is the potential existence of a discrete human life, it is doubly true that it is no one's right to arbitrarily determine what is true and what is not.

It's pretty clear here that the latter half of your statement is informed by the first.  You have decided privately and unto yourself (ie., not objectively) that a fetus does not qualify as a distinct human life, therefore it makes sense for you that people should have the right to decide whether or not to relate to an unborn fetus as though it were a discrete life form. 

In contrast, if the premise is an objective one--that the status of an unborn fetus is not known--then the right to determine its status does not actually belong to anybody; it belongs to scientific inquiry.  In the absence of scientific conclusion, the decision to have an abortion must be weighed against this objective unknown. 


>> Is it so irrational to have morally ambiguous questions solved on the ground level without a dictate coming from either a pope or a president or a philosopher king?

I believe this will be the third time I have iterated that this post is not about law and authority.  It is about calling for objectivity amid polarized hogwash.

That the morally ambiguous question should be solved on the ground level sounds correct.  It is a decision which ought to be made on the ground level, and it is a decision which must be weighed against the objective realities in play.  Perhaps the most important of these realities is that the actual reality that the life-status of the unborn fetus is not known. 

The statement "It's my right to have an abortion because it's my womb" is faulty; it is irrational; because it may not actually be just your womb; it may also be the habitat of a discrete human being.

The statement "It's my right to tell you not to have an abortion because I have decided that the fetus is human being" is faulty; it is irrational, because no one is presently qualified to make that determination.

The statement "Before we (the mother, father, doctor) decide to perform an abortion, we must weigh the necessity of that procedure against its potential ramifications" is sound; it is rational, because it approaches the issue from the starting point that the abortion procedure potentially constitutes terminating the life of discrete human being, which is an objective component of the actual realities surrounding the contemplation.


>> All you have articulated [...] we don't have a clear black and white definition of when life begins. I agree, and support your logic. I also agree that anyone getting or performing an abortion should bear this in mind.

This all I am calling for, and it is also precisely the conclusion that is steamrolled by the warfare between the two sides.


>> What you are calling for is that people weigh the potential status of a fetus as a discrete life form before abortions are performed. Let's say hypothetically, everyone did, to the degree to which your demands were satisfied, and yet still abortions were performed to the extent that they are today. Would you be happy?

If the objective reality that the unborn fetus might potentially exist as a discrete human being and may thereby qualify as entitled to human rights is taken into consideration, far fewer abortions would be performed today.

These 2001 statistics are from Physicians for Reproductive Choice and Health and the Alan Guttmacher Institute in An Overview of Abortion in the United States:

Reasons women give for choosing abortion:

01. Does not want/is not prepared for responsibility: 21%
02. Inadequate finances: 21%
03. Lifestyle would be changed too much: 16%
04. Unmarried, unstable relationship: 12%
05. Too young: 11%
06. Just don't want a child now: 8%
07. Fetus has possible health problems: 3%
08. Woman has health problems: 3%
09. Pregnancy caused by rape, incest: 1%
10. Other: 4%

If the objective reality that the unborn fetus might potentially exist as a discrete human being and may thereby qualify as entitled to human rights is taken into consideration, it compels the following assessment:

Reasons 1-6 (89% of all abortions) are almost entirely unjustifiable if the society and its members are to uphold the universally accepted moral principle that no one has the right to kill another human being.  This is because the ramifications of potentially destroying a human life are not offset by any of the reasons given in 1-6.  The later the term, the more significant the potential ramifications, and the more unjustifiable these reasons are.  The earlier the term, the less significant, and the more justifiable these reasons are.  When the ramifications of the unborn's potential are weighed against the scope of reasons 1-6, reasons 1-6 do not hold very well.  If these realities are received and corresponded with objectivity, the decision to have an abortion becomes a much less likely one, and far fewer abortions would actually occur.

Reasons 7-9 (7% of all abortions) are much more justifiable motivations to carry out an abortion, and remain justifiable much later in term than reasons 1-6. 

Of course, the variables of individual circumstances must also be taken into account here, and cannot be adequately reflected in statistics.


>> For me, this all fits solidly within the pro-choice side of the political duality, and is rhetoric that the pro-choice side has been using for years.

Do you deny that the pro-choice movement declares with finality that abortion is strictly a woman's right to choose, period?  "Not yours.  Not Mine.  Hers."?  Do you deny that any of the above reasoning would be unilaterally rejected by a significant number of people who self-identify as pro-choice, particularly the most vocal of these? 

It is precisely because of the absolutist rhetoric of the vocal pro-choice crowd, together with the absolutist rhetoric of the pro-life crowd, that the discussion about the ramifications of the abortion procedure, and how these ramifications are to be weighed against the justifications for the procedure, has been shut down.


>> Your refusal to take a stance on the legal issue of abortion I guess is what is actually ultimately confounding. To me, at least.

Ideally, laws surrounding abortion are articulated out of public opinion.  Since public opinion is so alarmingly polarized and distorted, correcting this is a first priority if we are to arrive at sound laws.  I am not a lawmaker or a judge.  I am a concerned citizen.  My role is as such and I do not intend to stray from it.

In an ideal world, all people would be capable of evaluating all of the objective realities surrounding this issue, and be capable of rendering their own decisions in a moral and ethical manner, without the need for laws.


--------------------


:poison: Dark Triangles - New Psychedelic Techno Single - Listen on Soundcloud :poison:
Gyroscope full album available SoundCloud or MySpace

Edited by Ped (03/30/13 03:45 PM)

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Re: The Abortion Debate: Irrational and Off the Mark [Re: Ped]
    #18033155 -

My gf and I had our abortion to prevent human suffering.  It worked as far as I can tell. :satansmoking:


--------------------
"Don't believe everything you think". -Anom.

" All that lives was born to die"-Anom.

With much wisdom comes much sorrow,
The more knowledge, the more grief.
Ecclesiastes circa 350 BC

Extras: Filter Print Post Top
Jump to top Pages: | 1 | 2  [ show all ]

Shop: Unfolding Nature Unfolding Nature: Being in the Implicate Order   Myyco.com Golden Teacher Liquid Culture For Sale   MagicBag.co All-In-One Bags That Don't Suck, Certified Organic All-In-One Grow Bags by Magic Bag


Similar ThreadsPosterViewsRepliesLast post
* A debate on the subject of the morality of drug use. neuro 1,944 7 02/21/03 07:10 AM
by Sclorch
* Rational vs. Irrational Beliefs
( 1 2 all )
Swami 10,778 39 01/14/05 07:58 PM
by Alan Stone
* Abortion
( 1 2 all )
absolute zero 1,547 20 11/29/05 05:21 PM
by Silversoul
* Hey challengers of "irrational" thinking gettinjiggywithit 1,411 15 11/07/05 03:53 PM
by fireworks_god
* Abortion
( 1 2 all )
Alan Stone 2,673 34 05/26/05 11:54 PM
by captiveharmony
* Slightly different view on abortion BleaK 1,323 12 12/02/02 06:19 PM
by psilocybinist
* I want to debate a "creation scientist".
( 1 2 3 4 ... 11 12 all )
Phluck 17,328 232 12/01/04 06:26 PM
by Diploid
* why we ought to debate -isms Malachi 989 10 07/02/03 04:08 AM
by Rhizoid

Extra information
You cannot start new topics / You cannot reply to topics
HTML is disabled / BBCode is enabled
Moderator: Middleman, DividedQuantum
2,789 topic views. 1 members, 122 guests and 49 web crawlers are browsing this forum.
[ Show Images Only | Sort by Score | Print Topic ]
Search this thread:

Copyright 1997-2026 Mind Media. Some rights reserved.

Generated in 0.024 seconds spending 0.006 seconds on 15 queries.