Auto-SummaryThe post discusses various diets, including paleo and ketogenic diets, and criticizes their effectiveness for fitness and muscle growth. The author argues that carbohydrates are essential for energy, especially during intense workouts, and that a balanced diet with complex carbs, lean meats, and plant fats is more beneficial for building muscle and maintaining energy levels. They also emphasize the importance of proper hydration and the misconception that meat is harder to digest than vegetables. The post concludes that a well-rounded diet is crucial for optimal performance and muscle growth.
hidenseek1 said: ok i honestly dont know what im talking about, but im going to spout my bs further
just because your spouting ideas instead of insults
withoutawire said:
hidenseek1 said: he says he has never been constipated, and carbs are wrse for that
as meat takes about 15 to pass through where vegetabke can linger for hours

Try eating vegetables, beans, legumes, and rice for three days then try an all meat diet for three days...rice is the least of the evils on a low carb diet, i dont believe vegetables or legumes are digestible raw, you need to lacto-ferment it first(i wish i had a source on thatm but cant find the one i had)
Carbs make you poop more and poop softer. Meat and fat take much longer to digest and come out much harsher. If you don't drink water with either diet it's tough pooping, but really trying eating 50% beans/legumes + fibrous veggies + rice + tofu with the same amount of water. Your poop will come out like frozen yogurt.
again same missing source,pluss a source i never had taking a fello message boards giy on this one
meat is really suspectable to the acid in your sstomach, breaks doen thesteak, and turns off, other carbs the acid satys in longer as its hard for you to digest a raw vegetable
paleo diet. I think it really works. meat, fruit, and nuts, just no grains at all.
the term gets my pantie in a nought, its really hard to tell what a paeol diet is, and are current paolo diet its probably a neolithic diet
You can still only eat a limited amount of fruits and nuts because the carbs add up. Also green leafy vegetables are acceptable because there are few carbs. i havnt been able to follow this diet too strictly as i its not hard to eat potatoe chips when mommy comes home and throws the bag at me, i dont even know what fruits are low carb, im hoping avacada as its loaded with other goodies
Carbs = energy. If you want to get fit, eat primarily lean meats and complex carbs. You'll work out longer and be able to push yourself much longer, especially when its six days a week. Lean meats mean less calories going in so more overal protein is in your diet. Fruit is all filled with sugar and causes a large insulin spike, aka the fat storing hormone. You are much better off eating an equal caloric amount of whole wheat, prevent the insulin spike/crash, and use complex carbs that will allow you to have more energy for an extended period of time. (now from what i read from oswald stevens is that your endurance will spike on a locarb diet, something to do with your body using the protiene on hand instead of ripping some chem fro, you live and converting it, so kno "wall" is hit when running
Not to mention the first several pounds lost on paleo is water weight, so muscles look smaller. you NEED carbs if you are weight training to help with muscle repair and prevent tissue breakdown. Keto diets are effective for people trying to get to single digit body fat (men) who are having a hard time shredding the lbs. giving your mussels adequate time to heal micro damages is all thats needed, along without pushing your work out too far
In conclusion, I think paleo is fucking stupid if you are really trying to get in shape. On paleo diet I can get myself to moderately lift four times a week and go on a few walks. A diet that's complex carbs, lean meats, and a little bit of plant fat gives me the ability to weight train HARD and push myself each time, plus I can go run for a hour or do sessions of HIIT the three days I am not lifting no problem. After 10 days I need a break, but paleo diet does not give me the energy, desire, or will power to push myself.
speculation again but.... humans were ment for short spurts of hardcore energy using, or moderate endurence
est some fat on your meat, the body love burning that stuff
Once again, why don't you TRY what your preaching instead of telling me how it is- someone who HAS DONE THESE DIETS.
You do NOT have more energy eating an all meat/keto diet. When your body and brain runs on ketones vs glycogen you will not have the same ability to push yourself for longer and harder.
Quote: The bigger and much more important issue is the ratio, amount and type of carbohydrates used in concert with ANY great protein. The fact is every serious bodybuilder and lifter has been sidetracked and horribly misguided on the 'zero or low carbohydrate' kick. Not only is this a whole lot of nonsensical marketing schlock anyway, but also going low carbohydrate is absolutely disastrous for athletes who want to build muscle faster, especially natural bodybuilders not stocked up on Mexican steroids.
Not to mention when your body is producing ketones, and your performance is suffering without carbohydrates, your body resorts to burning protein aka those things called muscles if your protein intake isn't perfect.
Quote: But for serious athletes who train consistently at high intensity levels (bodybuilders), food bars, with high protein and moderate-to-high carbohydrate and some fat, definitely offer better gains and faster recovery. There is absolutely no question about this. Carbohydrates spare protein and are your body's principal source of fuel. They provide the energy necessary for intense workouts more efficiently than any other energy source. Protein needs carbohydrates to work.
In fact, starving your body of carbohydrates during and after periods of intense exercise will likely cause your body to use protein as an energy source. In severe cases of low carbohydrate for prolonged periods, this may even result in the breakdown of hard-earned muscle proteins to be used as fuel during workouts or to replenish muscle glycogen after training.
Quote: i havnt been able to follow this diet too strictly as i its not hard to eat potatoe chips when mommy comes home and throws the bag at me, i dont even know what fruits are low carb, im hoping avacada as its loaded with other goodies

Potato chips are loaded with carbs. You just prefer to eat low carb with tons of meat. Not a ketogenic or paleo diet where your body produces ketones as a fuel source. Eat a bag of chips and you won't be in Ketosis, which does't peak until 3 days of eating 20g-30g carbs per day.
Vegetables are harder to digest than meat? Lol, once again, why don't you try eating beans legumes avocados green leafy vegetables and fruit. Then tell me how easy it is to poop vs eating a shit ton of meat. Digestion is a longer process with meat. I've done keto diets and vegan diets. Guess which one worked the best? A balance of everything because carbs = energy.
I'm a body builder. I lift four times a week, and do HIIT two times. I eat a caloric surplus for 200calories and get 1g/1lb protein per bodyweight. I avoid simple sugars because they make me crash vs complex carbs which sustain energy and control insulin levels. I add weights or reps every work out. I am 140lbs 5'5. I use to be 107lbs. Anyone who has adopted exercise as a daily practice HAS to eat a diet with plenty of complex carbs or you'll never be able to push yourself on day 6 doing squats after day of 5 of HIIT on a stationary bike.
--------------------
Edited by withoutawire (03/23/13 01:31 PM)
|