Auto-SummaryThe author argues that the government's labeling of certain individuals as "terrorists" is a form of propaganda used to justify war and create a sense of unity through hatred. By calling someone a terrorist, the government implies they are beyond negotiation and deserving of destruction, whereas labeling them as "rebels" or "insurgents" suggests a more nuanced and potentially resolvable conflict. The author suggests that this distinction is not just a matter of semantics, but has real-world consequences, such as discouraging public understanding of the enemy and the root of the problem. The author also critiques the government's tendency to downplay civilian casualties as "collateral damage," while condemning terrorist acts as heinous crimes. They contend that both the government and terrorists view their victims as mere collateral damage, and that it's essential to consider the motivations and perspectives of those involved in the conflict to find a way out of the cycle of violence and ideological wars. Ultimately, the author advocates for a more empathetic and nuanced approach to understanding the enemy, rather than relying on simplistic labels and negative stereotypes.
who's a terrorist and who's a soldier is really just marketing and propaganda created by the government who is simply trying to sell us something, in this case, a war. Saying someone is a terrorist paints them as the worst, most cowardly enemy we could face. they have no credibility, and absolutely no negotiating power, because everyone knows "the united states does not negotiate with terrorists". So no one listens to what they have to say. They are discounted by the public as bat shit crazy, and they must be dominated and destroyed by our government. It is the only way!
calling someone a insurgent or rebel, on the other hand, changes things drastically. rebels can be bargained with, reasoned with, bought off etc etc...In other words, violence doesn't necessarily have to be the final solution. I think maybe people are more likely to try and understand why a rebel rebels, it's perhaps in our nature as americans, since our ancestors were basically insurgents trying to get free of a dominating superpower. People will sympathize more easily with "rebels". This is why the government doesn't want people to call them rebels or insurgents (in iraq) Donald rumsfeld said "don't call them insurgents". Even the media won't call them rebels, the farthest they will go is to call them insurgents, which really doesn't have the same emotional attachments of the word 'rebel'. Our government wants to classify everyone who is against us as terrorists in one broad stroke to create a unity via hatred in the public mind that enables them to wage perpetual war in the middle east while at the same time discouraging any effort by the public to understand the enemy and the root of the problem. It seems silly because these are just words, but if you repeat something over and over on the news 30 times a day most people will start to think in those terms, without even really thinking about it. There is a word for this phenomenon, but i can't think of what it is.
Now, to say terrorists target innocents, and soldiers do not, is again a broad stroke made in a black and white painting. It's not that simple. Terrorists do target innocents, this is true, but the american government has killed more innocents in iraq than al queda did in the entire 9/11 attack. Whether these innocents were targeted by americans or not is irrelevant to the families of the dead. Again it boils down to semantics, and government marketing of what they think is morally just. When the US kills innocents by dropping a bomb into the middle of a city, it's 'collateral damage', no one is even charged or court marshalled in most cases, and the government does not issue an apology to the victims. When a terrorists kills innocents, they are evil terrorists murderers and are condoned, tracked down, and destroyed. Perhaps the terrorists have the same mind set though, and believe their innocent victims to be 'collateral damage'. 9/11 for instance, they attacked the pentagon, a military target. Were the people on the plane merely collateral damage in their eyes? Maybe the terrorists just walk around saying "war is hell, what can you do?".
So if the american army has killed more civilians who's really the worse of the two when it comes to crimes against humanity? If the terrorists victims are just collateral damage, same as the armies victims, then aren't both entities really terrorists with different codes and values? I just say that because it's probably how the american military is viewed by the people of the middle east, and it's important to try to understand why people think the way they do, and then try to use that knowledge of each other to solve the problem. Otherwise these types of ideological wars will continue forever. Many wars have been fought over differences of beliefs and opinions, and generally, just basic misunderstandings of races and people. It's why genocide still rages around the world to this day i think. A lack of understanding, compassion, and respect for people who are different is why genocide has always occurred around the world. In fact, i don't think there's a single superpower who hasn't committed genocide, whether or not it's stalin, chinese communism, or the US's war against the native americans. So, it's important to try and understand the enemy and their people rather than just lump everybody together as terrorists and terrorists sympathizers before the 'war' really gets out of hand and spirals into a full fledged religious war, which will only fuel the terrorists cause.
Anyways, who's a terrorist and who's a soldier is maybe relative to the people doing the dying. Our government calls all sorts of people terrorists, some are, some aren't. just like when the terrorists call americans evil, same thing, some are some aren't. I just think it's healthy to try and understand why these people are doing what they are doing, and when everyone is instantly labeled as a terrorist people don't even seem to try, and those who do are labeled as terrorist apologists/sympathizers, which is really just a bull shit cop out, and it hurts our chances for peace tremendously to think in those terms.
|