[Dip]The security of any cryptosystem MUST lie in the intractability of breaking the system, not in the secrecy of the inner workings of the system. As a matter of course, cryptanalysts publish their designs so they can be scrutinized for weaknesses by the public. If no design weaknesses are found after millions of people look, it's a pretty sure bet that so long as the key (password) is kept secret, the data will be secure.
Corporate executives who know nothing about technology always seem to insist on keeping their company's cryptosystem algorithms secret despite the advice of their engineers. (Note: if you ever see a software product that uses "proprietary encryption" run the other way.)
By vesting the security of their cryptosystem in the secrecy of the design, they risk the design being leaked, or as more commonly happens, some smart teenager with a fresh brain finds a weakness that would have been found in advance had the design been public... and the genie is out of the bottle.
This is akin to designing a safe that is secure not because the combination is secret but because the safe is opaque. This vests the security of the safe in the secrecy of the blueprints. If the blueprints are ever leaked, every safe of that design ever manufactured will be easy to open. The right way to design a safe is to let everyone know how it's built, but design it so that knowledge of this is useless for opening the safe. Only knowledge of the combination will do the job.
The problem Apple is facing now is the same problem the movie industry faced when they too thought that keeping secret the cryptosystem used to encrypt DVDs would keep the system secure. A 15 year old proved them wrong, and the same guy, now 22, just proved Apple wrong and for the same reason.
Arrogant exec types will never learn. It's no coincidence that Microsoft is one of the biggest companies in the world, and for most of its history it was headed by a technical geek, not some technophobe with an MBA.[/Dip] 
--
SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - A hacker who as a teen cracked the encryption on DVDs has found a way to unlock the code that prevents iPod users from playing songs from download music stores other than Apple Computer Inc.'s iTunes, his company said on Tuesday.
Jon Lech Johansen, a 22-year-old Norway native who lives in San Francisco, cracked Apple's FairPlay copy-protection technology, said Monique Farantzos, managing director at DoubleTwist, the company that plans to license the code to businesses.
"What he did was basically reverse-engineer FairPlay," she said. "This allows other companies to offer content for the iPod."
At the moment, Apple aims to keep music bought from its iTunes online music store only available for Apple products, while songs bought from other online stores typically do not work on iPods.
But Johansen's technology could help rivals sell competing products that play music from iTunes and offer songs for download that work on iPods as they seek to take a bite out of Apple's dominance of digital music.
ITunes commands an 88 percent share of legal song downloads in the United States, while the iPod dominates digital music player sales with more than 60 percent of the market.
Cupertino, California-based Apple, whose profits have soared in recent years on the strength of the iPod, declined to comment.
Johansen, known as DVD Jon, gained fame when at the age of 15 he wrote and distributed a program that cracked the encryption codes on DVDs. This allowed DVDs to be copied and played back on any device.
His latest feat could help companies such as Microsoft Corp., Nokia, Sony Ericsson and Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., which have all announced plans over the past few months for music download services combined with new devices to challenge Apple.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/10/24/AR2006102401427.html
-------------------- Republican Values:
1) You can't get married to your spouse who is the same sex as you.
2) You can't have an abortion no matter how much you don't want a child.
3) You can't have a certain plant in your possession or you'll get locked up with a rapist and a murderer.
4) We need a smaller, less-intrusive government.
|