A couple weeks ago, my friend showed me a house with a couple rooms that were available for rent. Due to the price and overall look of the house, we both wanted to live there; it's a pretty cool house.
The first day we checked it out, we brought along a friend, S*, and the landlord's son M*, who's also living there, showed us two of the three available rooms (one upstairs, one downstairs); the third room still had a tenant living there. Needless to say, we all liked it. Well, one day while I was in town, I decided to swing by the place to pick up the necessary forms that I had to fill out. There, M showed me the third room just for reference, and I immediately decided that I wanted that particular room. Apparently, my friend and his dad also came by that day and M also showed them the room. Incidentally, my friend wanted the room and had told M that, too.
Well, two days after M showed me the room, I decided to turn in the papers and security deposit to the landlord. He asked me which room I wanted, and M told him I wanted the room that was still being rented out. They told me it was okay.
That situation leads us to the predicament. When I told my friend I had picked that room, he pretty much deemed it as a false and unfair statement, even saying that he deserved it more than I did. After a few arguments and conversations, he still wants the room. He decided that a coin toss would be fair. I said that I rightfully attained the room. Thus, no coin toss was necessary since I was the official tenant of that room. Somehow, my friend weaseled his way with M, convincing him that a coin toss was the better option. My friend skewed the truth by saying that I had chosen that room behind his back, which wouldn't make sense since I never even knew he wanted the room, or had even seen it. Well, I called M tonight to clear things up, and he said that he thinks I rightfully attained the room since I paid first. He also said that the tenant living in that room will be moving out on Saturday sometime.
I don't really know what to do.
My plan is to move in right after the tenant moves out tomorrow, and to pay the first month's rent and to have the landlord sign a written agreement specifying which room was to be rented out to me and for how much.
My friend still abides by the coin toss, saying that that would be the fairest way of doing things.
Who do you think is right, Anon? And, what do you think I should do?
|