Auto-SummaryThis forum post highlights a musician's dedication to creating music without adhering to genre restrictions, releasing multiple albums quickly, and focusing on quantity over quality. The commenter appreciates the artist's creative and musical approach but critiques specific tracks for production issues, such as poor drum sequencing, lack of processing, and ground noise. The artist acknowledges these critiques, expressing a desire to improve production skills and welcomes advice from fellow producers. The post concludes with gratitude for the in-depth feedback and a commitment to refining sound engineering techniques.
Viveka said: Hey, I know the syndrome. At moments it can feel like...huh, why bother releasing stuff if people usually could not care less to even listen, much less provide feedback. But it is our love and we do it regardless.
I've listened to most of the tracks on your first two albums and I haven't turned them off immediately, which is saying a lot about any music amateur or pro, and some I've listened to all the way through and even checked out again.
I like that you don't give a fuck about trying to make your material conform to a genre or expectation of some sort. I have zero tolerance for that bullshit, like what is so common in the 'electronica' realm.
I don't particularly care about fitting into any genres or categories and focusing on creating music of one style is nothing more than a mere unnecessary limitation. It's a mystery to me what kind of music I'll make on any given day, really depends on my mood and what has been influencing me recently.
Quote: In general, it seems like your focus is quantity over quality though. I mean you've released like four albums that you claimed to have put together(from archives or whatever) on the spot over the course of what, two weeks tops? Lol, most artists are considered to be pushing the envelope if they release more than one album in a year. Slow your pace a little when it comes to releasing material and refine what you've got.
My focus is not on quantity over quality at all! I treat each and every song I make with respect and put an equal amount of effort into each. The reason I've released 4 albums in such a short span is because, as I mentioned in my album sticky, these are all from the course of the last 5 years. In fact I'm actually rediscovering some old songs I made and am finally able to gather them together in a much more organized and focused manner as opposed to my unfocused teenage ideas. I have a good ~150 songs on my HD that are just collecting dust so I'm trying to quickly clear up that backlog so I can continue creating some new stuff (I've made maybe 6-7 new songs this year? that's about it, everything on my 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th albums are from like 3 years ago or 4 or 2 or 5, it's all over the place).
Quote: I like a lot of your beat sequencing and rhythm and groove choices but as an example of something really problematic that should have been fixed, the track Midnight Shaman from the first album you released here...wtf, dude? It's got this cool bass line in 7/8, but then the drums come in and it's just a slopfest. I like how you're going for an open, free sound rhythmically with shifting downbeats in the drums here and there but it's just a mess. Did you just do a single pass using your keyboard to trigger the drum sounds or what? And if that wasn't bad enough it sounds as though you applied zero processing to the drum sounds, which is something you really shouldn't skip when working with sampled drum sounds, especially when they are exposed as they are in that track. Just the basics - volume, eq and image left to right, front to back(pan and reverb) are all you really have to think about but they're absolutely critical to achieving a worthwhile sound.
Midnight Shaman is sort of just an intro track. I originally planned to have some saxophone over it but that never fell through I made that song in Garageband a long time ago when I was just familiarizing myself with it. With every new song I record in recent times however I gradually refine my recording/producing/mixing techniques. There's some shit that sounded excellent but I wouldn't dare release on account of clipping, crackling, annoying humming, buzzing, it's fucking annoying, especially since I use some pretty unorthodox methods of recording, my gear is admittedly very shitty and I pretty much have to make the best of what I have; I don't have the time nor money to head out to a studio everytime I want to make music, I just open up my software, set up my mic and do my thang when I'm in the mood.
Quote: Then there's the ground noise type of hum running throughout. Which brings me again to the issue of production. Now I know you've said you really don't give a fuck about production quality and properly routing your signal and all that but at this point I'd say it's become an obstacle to realizing your potential, which I honestly think is great. What does your typical signal chain look like anyway? I might be able to give you some pointers as a fellow guerilla producer myself, and I do a mix of live and sequenced stuff as well, hardware, software in more or less equal amounts.
I really appreciate this post man, you come off as being very knowledgeable about production. I would definitely appreciate any tips you might have! I'm honestly an amateur at producing/mixing, it's all trial and error and learning as I go along and always refining my modus operandi.
Quote: I've only checked out your first two albums so far but I give kudos for your creativity and musicality. I like the grooviness and melodic playfulness and the little things here and there, and even the raw, distorted sound of the drum grooves to a certain extent. And while I appreciate a prolific maniac and apparent juggernaut of spirit such as yourself, you really oughta focus on drastically improving production. A lot of your tracks sound like you recorded the entire mix with a mic up against a keyboard speaker. And this is coming from someone who doesn't care much about about typical audiophile considerations. I'll take a VBR mp3 over a flac or wav in most cases, it's not that big a deal. But if the source is botched production wise, most people will not care to listen or know what to make of what they're hearing. Especially if they are listening to your material next to other stuff. That's enough typey typey for now but I'm all for having a little production workshop sort of discussion, I'm sure we could all learn something.
You're actually very correct about that. I set up my keyboard, adjust the levels to ensure it doesn't crackle or clip and have a very clean sound (i'm learning everyday) and I experiment with my mic placement (some small shitty mic my dad gave me a while ago). I'm pretty poor, and I have very amateur gear/methods, but none of that has anything to do with my desire and passion to create music, and rather than let it impede me I will do my overall best to overcome these obstacles, deal with them and eventually transcend them so eventually I should have no problems in the future.
I'm really flattered that you call me a prolific maniac and juggernaut of spirit I have ideas floating around my head all day long, and the only thing I do on my free days at home now is compose. Hell even if I trip I take at least 30 minutes to jam some tunes! As I said, I REALLY appreciate this post of yours; there've been enough complaints about the production value of my music to make me realize it is indeed a very real and major problem which is detracting from my music... I mean when I listen to my stuff I don't hear too much of a problem however I acknowledge there is some buzzing/humming/unintentional noise screwyness but I wasn't aware that it would be that huge of an issue! Fuck it, tomorrow I'm going to do nothing but refine my sound engineering techniques.
If you have AIM you can feel free to IM me dude, I'd really appreciate some pointers/expert advice. I can use all the help I can get now, anything that can help me improve I'll go for it.
Once again... thank you for addressing this issue in such an in-depth manner.
|